Just offering a trip report here. I played through kcd1 on normal recently. Now playing through kcd2 hardcore on the first playthrough. Super great experience so far. About 45 hours in and about to go to the wedding.
I've only gotten lost once so far during the drinking with the cumans thing. Being wasted and trying to fumble my way back with more booze in the dark was an adventure...
If you've never played a kcd game, I can definitely recommend this as a way to go if you are a patient enough gamer.

