r/Songstuff•
musomox

**🎸 Craft & Magic 🎸: Is Songwriting Mastery a Learned Skill or Pure Mystical Inspiration? Let's Uncover the Secrets! 🎤✨**

Songwriting: Is It a Skill or a Feeling? Or Both? 🤔

So I've been diving deep into the world of songwriting for a while now (shoutout to all the late-night sessions and random voice memos 🎵) and there's something that keeps gnawing at me... Where does great songwriting come from? Is it something we meticulously learn, sharpen, and perfect? Or is it this intuitive, out-of-nowhere feeling that we channel?

Because we’ve all been there, right?

  • You're stuck. Like, super stuck. You've been staring at the same line for...who’s counting? đź‘€
  • Or suddenly... BOOM! You're at the grocery store and this melody just pops into your head. (Let's be honest, we’ve all hummed into our phones outside the freezer aisle once or twice... pulled any weird looks?).

There’s this constant tug-of-war in my mind where either songwriting feels like a puzzle that needs solving or it’s something completely free-flowing and spiritual. And sometimes it's both, like a dance between knowing your craft and letting your emotions or subconscious take over.

So, TBH, I can never fully decide:

Craft vs Intuition

Let’s break this down a little:

CRAFT (a.k.a. stuff you intentionally learn):

  • Hooks, rhyme schemes, motifs; knowing the theory, structure, and why certain chords just feel right 🎹
  • The whole business around persistence. You’ll hear so many greats talk about how they rewrote their songs over and over until it clicked (looking at you, Mr. Springsteen 🚀). That deliberate practice with a side of discipline.

INTUITION (a.k.a. pure unplan-able magic):

  • Some songs FEEL like they just write themselves. Moments of catharsis or emotion that seem to pour out. Is that joy? Pain? Breakups? Breakthroughs?
  • Inspiration that pops up from who-knows-where. You could be ready to sleep and BAM đź’ˇ. Suddenly, you're scrolling through your Notepad and opening GarageBand in the dark.

Honestly, I think the best songs often land somewhere in between. You have the craft to refine, but rely on deeper intuition to spark the beginning of something real.

What About YOU?

  • Do you find yourself leaning more on technical skill or gut reactions?
  • Does it change depending on the song genre? Or even your mood at the time?
  • What about inspiration—how do you catch it? Any weird or go-to places (shower’s got to win, right? There's science behind that, I swear!).

And on that note, here's a fun one: What's the fastest song you've ever written—and did it end up becoming something great or just an “ehhhh...let’s chuck that in the drafts?” 🤣 Be honest!

Songwriting is so personal yet universally shared. I don’t think we ever truly "master" it. It's alive. The ever-elusive art. But still, there's something so satisfying about the journey between blankness and a full, poignant track that speaks your truth. ❤️🎤

Hope to hear your thoughts on this! Would love to know what songwriting genuinely feels like for each of you and if it’s more science or soul.

Posted Nov 16, 2024, 1:21 PM UTC

10
Loading comments…