Does narration in short stories tend to differ stylistically from that in novels? If so, why? (I'm thinking primarily of Western literature from 19th century onward, but all insights are welcome)

My work involves reading analyses of many short stories and novels. I may be imagining things, but I've started to feel like the narration for short stories tends to be more complex.

For example, short stories seem to involve more narrative intrusion. And more frequent unreliability in the narration. There's also more dynamic retrospective stuff—e.g., a first-person adult narrator recounting their childhood experiences, vividly rendering a child's interiority but with counterintuitively sophisticated diction and mature awareness. (Then, maybe the adult narrator will pause mid-recollection and get carried away in an almost expository digression, causing more nonlinearity.) I've also noticed lot more shifting in verb tenses, indicating a layered narrative consciousness that's sort of... I dunno, split? Simultaneously occupying disparate temporal perspectives?

In contrast, while novels' narration can include any of these characteristics, it seems to be more straightforward on the whole. Also maybe more third-person narration.

I guess I'm just wondering (1) whether this pattern is real, or whether it's just a coincidence specific to my reading, and (2) if it is real, where it came from. For example, could it be related to the American influence on short stories? Could it somehow involve short stories' publication history in magazines?

Posted Apr 8, 2023, 2:22 PM UTC

161
vortex_timeRussian: 19th c.•

You might look for Boris Eikhenbaum's essay on O. Henry (I think it's called something like "O. Henry and the theory of the short story"). It's been years since I've read it, but he talks about specific narrative features of short stories. The one I remember is the idea of short stories being "end-weighted"--that is, they build to a big punch right at the end instead of the rise and fall of a novel.

Edit: While I'm thinking of Russian scholars, also check out Bakhtin's discussion of the novel as a polyphonic genre. It might give you something to argue against or a way to refine your argument about how exactly short stories can be more complex.

5