Cultivator 2.4 - Not a huge update, but big changes!! Yell at me here!
reddit.com/gallery/12kuca2Posted Apr 13, 2023, 4:15 PM UTC
Posted Apr 13, 2023, 4:15 PM UTC
Hi again. Here is another update. I've focused on some mentioned problem areas so I'm ready for more CONSTRUCTIVE criticism. Will pay in upvotes, good or bad.
Change Log
Core Class
Added Influx to main ki abilities
Updated Ki incarnate to not be negated by own healing
Updated Ki Incarnates language
Removed uses from Aura Infusion
Removed ki cost from Of Sound Mind...
Updated reforge the body for long rest change
Aura Mastery changed to short rest and clarified language
Increased Bonus from Breakthrough
Cultivation assault regains uses upon dropping creatures to 0
Taiji
Combined int to attack and damage
Reworded ability to add int and str to damage as an option
Changed Elemental Hurricane to Elemental Void
Ki Caster
Clarified aura cast to replace weapon dam and be affected by mag bonuses
Updated Brake arrow language and added reactions
Updated language on mesmer arrow
Iaijutsu
Removed Ki cost from 3rd internal stance ability
clarified Kennokabe
Falling Phoenix
Clarified 1st external stance ability to only cultivator things
Four Winds
removed ki cost from External stance
Added option to replace an attack with an ability instead of using it as a bonus action
Ki Fortress
Clarified Shield Legerdemain ki cost
Clarified Str dam to force shields
Soul Arms
Changed Forms from weak/strong to Lesser/Greater
Removed BA from 2nd internal ability and made it affect only 1 attack per ki point
Changed Ranged form greater to once per turn and removed BA
Clarified Versatile Lesser
Dark Thralls
Removed Ki cost from 2nd internal stance ability
Fulminis Soul
Changed Conductive to clarify you can spend sparks gained over the maximum
Updated wording on Fulminant to make lightning damage indiscriminate
Let's goooo
Question about Soul Arms. Unless I misread, it doesn't say any way to summon/swap the weapons you attune to unless you swap stances, which takes a bonus action. That would be fine if it didn't mess with the Barrage trait you get at 11th level, which also uses a bonus action and is reduced by how many times you've swapped during that turn. If I'm missing something here, I apologize, but if you use your bonus action to swap, you cant use Barrage, right?
No you're right. I got confused. You're supposed to be able to swap weapons every time you roll to attack. It was supposed to say it in soul arms, because I removed an old ability from the stance that said so.
I intended to have weapons be quick swappable in both stances instead of just internal. I'll add it on. For now just pretend it says you can swap whenever you switch stances or roll for attack.
I figured it'd be something like that. I noticed while looking through cause I was real interested by the subclass and was confused by it.
So I have some, but comparatively small knowledge on Xianxia themes, my DM having way more. But isn't one of the most common cultivation types being your body? The kinda people who have like bodies of steel and the like. If so, is there a reason none of the subclasses focus on this too much? Or maybe I'm misrecalling
That trope is common through almost all cultivator fantasy. I represented that with breakthrough. It's more applicable to say some focus on defense. I did the shield class for that.
I always have to be loose when creating cultivation stuff for DnD because it doesn't always translate. While you're not wrong, it's too broad a thing to just mention "strong bodies".
That is fair, the main reason I brought it up at all is the dm is using your class here as a gestalt type system for gaining and learning the Dao. I myself am playing a feral, physical type of character and was sad to see the larger focus on the spiritual side. it's still wonderfully done, and I eventually settled on the Soul Arms subclass. I appreciate your answer :>
You are probably looking for a more wuxia themed class then. Xianxia means that even the most martial characters have magic like powers. Wuxia is heavy on barely supernatural martial arts.
Think the difference Crouching tiger hidden dragon movie, and like Naruto. Even martial characters like rock Lee had overtly supernatural powers.
I don't mind supernatural martial powers by any means, after all this is a dude who has grafted monster parts into himself and can hit creatures several thousands of feet tall and force them to move. But yeah I get what you mean
Fiddlestics has made the following comment(s) regarding their post:
Hi again. Here is another update. I've focused on...
So did I misunderstand that or read that wrong - but on falling pheonix - the third level feature - it just doubles basically create bonfire damage? So at level 5 create bonfire would deal 4d8+int mod damage, 6d8+ int at level 11 and basically at level 17 it would deal 8d8+15 damage since at that point basically every reasonable caster has 20 as their main stat, most likely even at level 5 they have 20 int lol. If thats the case thats kinda busted lmao. You basically have BETTER free blight once per turn... or even higher damage dealing one version of it... Maybe do half of int mod as damage since that is too much damage anyways. And I dont really get what is the point of the third level feature for it anyways...? Since it only rolls for fire damage for 2 features - the create bonfire and the last level feature... so it doesnt really even do anything besides give the subclass way too busted cantrip damage dice, which feels even more weird since the class gets extra attack anyways which is useless for this subclass since 99% of the time you just wanna spam the mini-nuclear fire blight on your enemies.... (and technically yes the burning hands as well then, which is anyways then free 4th lvl version of it always)
If thats the case The Iajutsu subclass seems waaaay too strong... just having 3d6 free damage on ALL attacks even at level 17 is just too strong imo. The damage increase is just too big on higher levels. the lower levels one is fine but id do lower damage on the higher levels since you can just way too easily cheese that to having 3 or 4 or 6 attacks per turn and dealing like 6d8+18d6+30 dmg on nova turns and 3d8+9d6+15 on average turns which seems way too high for a martial damage dealer.
Empowered body is worded a bit strange. I assume you mean that if you have proficiency it becomes expertise but the way it's written sounds like if you already have +2 from proficiency you add ANOTHER +4 for a total of +6. I would leave it at "add your proficiency bonus. You can use this even if you are already proficient"