r/buildapc•
Error_X

4070 12gb VRam vs 6950xt 16GB VRam

Build Help

Hey there,

I want to upgrade my GPU later this year. Im debating heavily between the 4070 and the 6950xt.

4070 has way better power consumption, dlss3 and frame generation. It has 12GB Vram. I already dont have nearly enough Vram for all high presets with my 8gb 3060ti today.

6950xt has much more raw rasterization power, fsr but uses a lot more power. Its got 16 GB Vram.

I will admit Im a bit biased towards Nvidia as its all I have ever known PC wise and its my understanding that Radeon gpus only really became competetive the last 2-3 gens.

In your honest opinion, which card should I go for? Its my first PC system I ever built and bought myself and im basically on the higher end of the AM4 platform already. Meaning if I wanted to upgrade anything else Id be better off going straight to AM5.

Posted May 10, 2023, 8:49 AM UTC

741
Seilorenso•

I have the same dilemma and decided to wait until 7800XT comes out this month instead.

15
KlingKlangKing•

Yup. When that comes out, I will buy A gpu. Nothing more to wait for after that

2
VVilkacy•

Is it really coming out this month?

2
Seilorenso•

At the end of may, yes, it should.

2
joshuamenko•

I thought it was only the 7600 confirmed this month

2
Mathis_mbz•

Same !

1
joshuamenko•

Samesies

1
roidedcomputergeek•

In my honest opinion it is 6950xt all day. Much better in every aspect, yes power consumption not but have into account it's a much better card. As a matter of fact they shouldn't even be in the same category but Nvidia love to fuck the prices up

9
orbitalbias•

In every aspect? Ray tracing? 1440p? DLSS3?

5†
pugaviator•

RT is a gimmick outside of blender

3
DutchmanAZ•

Whoa man, I can get 20fps ray tracing with my 3060. It's why I bought it instead of the 6700XT. It's so friggin sweet. I see each individual image, with ray tracing!

/S

6
Cmdrdredd•

Ray tracing makes the biggest visual difference of any setting besides resolution. People are blind if they can’t tell that.

I still don’t think the 4070 is worth it but people who say ray tracing is a gimmick are coping because AMD sucks at it or they don’t have the right nvidia card to do it at their resolution of choice.

1
pugaviator•

A lot of "RT" in games is just increasing the shading quality and reflectiveness of surfaces. AMD does okay with RT since RDNA2 since they have RT cores (And actually, the 7900XTX has more RT cores than the 4080).

2
roidedcomputergeek•

Obviously in dlss not hahahaha that's only Nvidia thing. Either way the 6950xt is a flagship model of not so long ago so it's better in pure workload

2
GruffChris•

1 year today.

1
orbitalbias•

The implication was vs FSR

-1†
[deleted]•

6950xt is the better card without a doubt

9
ozdude182•

Pretty sure the 6950xt has better straight fps vs the 4070. If you like Nvidia maybe look at the 4070ti if possible?

8
ishsreddit•

If you are playing 1440p then 4070. Both of these cards kill it but the 4070 is more efficient, has RT, DLSS3 and CUDA.

If playing 4k then 6950XT because Vram. Even two years ago I noticed games consuming more than 10GB of Vram at 4k. It wasnt till recently where tester/ reviewers started actually pointing that out for some reason.

The other benefit you get is RDNA2 ability to undervolt. Simply change the power voltage gfx/soc via mpt a little, and decrease voltage in Adrenaline and you can probably cut power by 30-50w without losing perf. If you don't want to power mod, you can still use adrenaline just to lower voltage (SUPER easy and safe) but you will lose 1-3% of your FPS. You can also overclock and force 400w+ and possibly get this card within 10% of the 7900xt but unless you want your room to be a sauna forget about it.

I'm a 6800xt user and played around with it a fair bit. RDNA2 feels remarkably polished and premium. I came from the gtx 1070 and i do not regret changing back to team red.

3
mdred5•

if you already have 3060ti than for now reduce settings and play.

my suggestion is wait till december and decide....on nvidia side 4060ti with 16 gig of ram is rumored to launch in july

there are AMD 7700 and 7800 which are about to be launched(which will have better efficiency compared to 6950xt)

2
handymanshandle•

Ada Lovelace is much better at ray tracing than RDNA 2 is. Hell, Turing is much better at RT than RDNA 2 is. If that’s a priority for you, get the RTX 4070. Besides that, it’s significantly more power efficient, has a better video encoder (primarily with h264 video; it also offers AV1 encoding, which isn’t available on RDNA 2), and if DLSS 3 (and more specifically, frame generation) matters to you, that’s the card for you.

On the other hand, the RX 6950 XT is a much faster card for raw rasterization and can still hold its own in RT at lower resolutions, at the cost of power consumption. It’s also the obvious choice if you’re running any Linux distro, as the drivers are just far less finicky than Nvidia’s are on Linux. Both cards can use FSR, but RDNA 2 and 3 cards can use dedicated hardware on those cards to accelerate it (much like how DLSS uses the tensor cores of the RTX cards), instead of relying on the shader cores for FSR processing.

Me personally? I’d get the RX 6950 XT. I play at 3840x2560, and while I can stretch a card’s VRAM to work at that resolution well enough, I can’t stretch the performance far enough unless I actively want a game to look worse than it should. If you’re playing at 1440p, I’d argue that the RTX 4070 is the better buy as you can lean into that card’s features more effectively without worrying about hitting a VRAM wall like you might at 4K.

2
lokol4890•

The 6950xt should be the better buy between the two. That said I'm having a hard time believing you're running out of vram quicker than compute power on your 3060ti. Are you sure you're not mistaking vram allocation for vram usage?

2
PapaBePreachin•

Honestly, just wait 2 weeks to see what gets announced and/or prices drop further. The 6950XT is a great value now, but I guarantee AMD will have some feature (FSR 3) that'll either be *locked or disproportionately skewed toward their upcoming lineup

​

*As in, certain features - e.g., frame generation

2
Cmdrdredd•

I don’t think the 4070 is worth it’s asking price myself since a 3080ti beats it in many situations. DLSS3 with frame generation is great but for me it has a niche use case and where it makes the most sense to enable frame generation isn’t a situation where I think a 4070 is good enough anyway (think cyberpunk at 4k with psycho or higher ray tracing).

2
papideplantas•

I always tell people to pick from FPS vs Quality

If you want your game to look pretty and look great you go with NVIDIA. With their upscaling software you can use DLSS to give yourself more frames at higher qualities anyway. along with this if you care about using any type of adobe product (photoshop, after effects, AI functions, 3D rending such as blender, or ANY type of creative work NVIDIA takes the cake.

if you're a gamer who only cares about getting the most FPS out of a game then you go with AMD.

This is something that I feel like is brushed to the side quite often with all the AMD fans but at end of day if you care about anything outside of FPS you should focus on buying a NVIDIA GPU.

1
huh--_•

4060ti is coming out with 16gb vram(rumor) should tell you something about going NV.

1
KlingKlangKing•

Just wait for 7800xt

1
Morghon•

Honestly, the 4070 would be a better drop in upgrade in your configuration. It has the same TPD as the 4070, so you wouldn't have to upgrade your psu, or deal with the crazy high transients of the 6950xt. It will be easier on your power bill. It will run quieter and cooler, especially if you get the ones with the beefy coolers.

A video, from HUB I think, showed NVIDIA DLSS was better than native raster and fsr in almost all games and resolutions. And it will also lower vram usage.

You will get better performance in ray traced titles too. And it really looks better, especially in CP2077. The lighting just changes the whole mood of the game. People saying they can't see the difference is probably trying rt outside, during day time or only in the benchmark section.

DLSS 3.0 seems to be a great feature for single player games, especially if you play with a controller.

And learning a different gpu and driver behavior or how to oc and undervolt them feels like a bit of a hassle.

With that said, 4070 is still overpriced at current prices. Needs to be at least 50$ off.

1
Morghon•

Keep in mind that the 4070 doesn't seem to scale well in 4k though.

1

I have a question about 6950. Will future driver updates lower its power consumption?

1
ArmyRetGuy•

I was recently in a similar predicament. I’ve been kind of an Nvidia guy. On my new budget build I looked at the 4070 and the 6950xt. I like Nvidia features to a degree, but also wanted more vram. The 6950xt was about $50 more, and I play at 1440p. I ended up grabbing a 6800xt, because it has 16GB vram, can run about even with the 4070 in rasterized performance, and is cheaper than the 4070.

1
dev044•

Dlss 3 is useless unless you play the 8 single player games jr supports. I have a 3080 12gb and never used ray tracing a day. The 6950xt is the faster card hands down and more VRAM. The only real debate is dlss vs fsr in my opinion. Are you actually playing games that support dlss 3 and ray tracing?

0
ozdude182•

May i ask what your 3060ti has issues with on high presets vram wise? Outside of the god awful TLOU and Hogwarts ports.

-2
Cmdrdredd•

Man Reddit is a bunch of children. You got downvoted for asking a question and mentioning very bad ports that have some performance issues. Those aren’t the only two with performance issues either but maybe those are the two most recent ones you played yourself?

1
ozdude182•

I wasnt even trying to start an argument lol. People just echo things they hear as the truth. I was really wanting to know what other games have issues with vram but oh well.

4
[deleted]•

[removed]

-12
Error_XOP•

Fuck off, sincerly, me.

8
Augustus31•

Kid.

4
[deleted]•

[removed]

-5
Augustus31•

lmao

3
buildapc-ModTeamMOD•

Hello, your comment has been removed. Please note the following from our subreddit rules:

Rule 1 : Be respectful to others

Remember, there's a human being behind the other keyboard. Be considerate of others even if you disagree on something - treat others as you'd wish to be treated. Personal attacks and flame wars will not be tolerated.


^(Click here to message the moderators if you have any questions or concerns)

3