CA Certificate Requests - Pointing to Wrong Server

Question

Cert Authority admin newb here

Some cert requests are being directed to the offline root CA instead of the subordinate CA.

I'm not certain how to direct all requests to only the subordinate CA, and any assistance would be appreciated.

(After burying myself in far to many configuration documents, I come to r/sysadmin for any potential assistance.)

Posted May 12, 2023, 6:18 PM UTC

29
_STYSecurity Consultant•

Do not join your root to the domain.

Do not join your root to the domain.

Do not join your root to the domain.

Do not join your root to the domain.

Do not join your root to the domain.

To answer your question; when enrolling for a cert using the certmgr or certlm MMCs you can specify which CA you would like to enroll from. If your root is an option to enroll from I only have one piece of advice:

Do not join your root to the domain.

5
xxdcmastSr. Sysadmin•

So youre saying I should join my root to the domain?

6
_STYSecurity Consultant•

Who let my clients in here?

3
RossDailyOP•

apparently i interpreted 'offline CA' to mean 'powered off' & not the correct interpretation of 'not domain joined'

2
_STYSecurity Consultant•

Well you're half right, it should be both.

Just adding here because my comment wasn't particularly useful; if you have any questions about PKI/ADCS best practice feel free to msg me. Setting up a PKI is trivial, setting up securely can be a career. Let me know if there's any specific concerns or questions and I'll try to help out.

4
FunOpportunity7•

100% this!

-1
pdp10heading for the nineties, living in the eighties•

You mean OCSP requests?

1
akadmin•

I'm not quite sure what you are asking but if you have a certificate template published on a particular CA then active directory will go there for certificate requests

1
RossDailyOP•

i made the mistake of joining the root/offline CA to the domain initially.

earliest commenter stated this & that is likely the issue that I am experiencing.

Thanks for the reply good human

2