Let’s solve the mystery of the ever-burning lamp
"Among the Cealdar there are legends of ever-burning lamps. I believe that such a thing was once within the scope of our craft. Ten years I have been looking. I have made many lamps, some of them very good, very long burning." He looked at me. "But none of them ever-burning." (Ch. 44, The Burning Glass. NotW)
To solve this mystery, we'll look at the following questions:
- Did such a lamp once exist?
- If yes, will Kvothe encounter one during his adventures?
- What's Kilvin's motivation for pursuing the ever-burning lamp?
- Can one be built?
"Ahhh," he said with fatherly pride. "My lovelies."
Kvothe’s first meeting with Kilvin provides a significant clue.
Kilvin was Cealdish, his thick shoulders and bristling black beard reminded me of a bear. "Right," he grumbled, folding his thick hands in front of him. "How would you make an ever-burning lamp?" (Ch. 36, Less Talents. NotW)
No formalities, just straight to the point. How would you make one? Period. Nothing about where to find one, or what its usefulness would be. In fact, eight more chapters pass before Kilvin elaborates on what little he knows about the legend of the ever-burning lamp. We're then left with a misleading conclusion: If such a lamp once existed, then it should be possible to create it again. It's misleading because we make the perfectly reasonable but likely false assumption that the ancient and modern worlds are fundamentally the same. They're not. Kilvin already knows this but we don't (yet). More on this in a moment.
"I admire a student who thinks in terms of durability... But a thousand years is a great deal to ask of stone, let alone metal."
The linchpin to solving the mystery of the ever-burning lamp shows up near the end of Wise Man's Fear when Kilvin reveals a nondescript pair of objects from long ago that he keeps locked away: the warding stones. When activated the stones manifest a seemingly perfect "thaumic and kinetic barrier." Kvothe marvels at this demonstration, noting that it's "far superior to my arrowcatch" (Ch. 146, Failures. WMF).
Put another way, the warding stones are a perfect arrowcatch.
But then Kilvin responds, visibly nonchalant, "Your cleverness we can repeat endlessly. This mystery we cannot."
Now let's put it all together.
| When was it made? | Does it work perfectly? | Can it be reproduced? | Kilvin's interest? | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Warding Stones | Ancient Times | Yes | No | He uses them, but they are "mysteries" |
| The Arrowcatch | Modern Times | It functions exceptionally well, but not perfectly | Yes | "He ran his hand over the top of the arrowcatch, almost petting it" or "clutching the arrowcatch like a child with a new favorite toy" |
| The Ever-Burning Lamp | Ancient Times | If the legend is true, Yes | If the warding stones are any indication, No | Occasionally he speaks of the legend as a source of inspiration |
| The NEW Ever-Burning Lamp | TBD / Modern Times | Likely No | Once built, Yes | He is EXTREMELY interested, it's a pet project he's been working on for 10 years |
Similar to our world, nothing created in the Four Corners works perfectly or lasts forever. All machines require maintenance and eventually breakdown. There's implied evidence in the books that this wasn't true back in ancient times. Things could break, but they didn't naturally deteriorate. Maybe this outcome was limited to shaped items? Or perhaps it was commonplace across Temerant? Or maybe the concept of time meant something else entirely back then? All of this is still unknown, and we don't need to solve that mystery here. All we need to know is that proof of these inventions survived, and that the world is now different.
I think it's clear by now that Kilvin isn't interested in finding an ever-burning lamp, but in building one. There's a difference. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if Kilvin has one locked away in his office somewhere, similar to the warding stones.
##"It is a wonderous thing. It is an improvement to the world. Every time a person sees such a thing, they will see how artificery is used to keep men safe."
Back to the questions.
Did such a lamp once exist?
Likely yes. Kilvin mentions "many reliable sources that speak of the ever-burning lamp." And we've seen real examples of similar objects.
If yes, will Kvothe encounter one during his adventures?
Also, likely yes. But to what purpose?
The ever-burning lamp's main function is that it burns forever. Okay? Artificers already build lamps and other reliable light sources to meet this need. Kilvin's current record is 75 days. What's to be gained by having it burn even longer? During his first admissions interview Kvothe was solving the problem along these lines when Kilvin cut him off for mentioning sympathy. "No sympathy. I do not want an ever-glowing lamp. I want an ever-burning one." (Ch. 36, Less Talents. NotW) This suggests to me Kilvin has something else in mind other than utility. If not to build and sell better lamps, then what?
What’s Kilvin's motivation for pursuing the ever-burning lamp?
Kilvin's the ideal teacher. He's a fair-minded authority figure who respects his students and desires that they work hard, learn, and ultimately use their cleverness to add good to the world. The question of the ever-burning lamp is a means to this end, not the end itself. Kvothe may not yet realize it, but he embodied the whole point of Kilvin's ever-burning lamp question when he invented the arrowcatch. The question is an intellectual primer.
Can one be built?
Let's be clear, building an ever-burning lamp within the constraints of the Fishery is impossible. I doubt any of Kilvin's schematics say anything about naming or shaping. But building a lamp that burns a long, long time is possible, as is building one that burns just a little bit longer. And a little bit more. And that's the point.
"... but never forget: cleverness and caution profit the artificer. We do our work in the realm of the real... Leave mystery to poets, priests, and fools."
Posted Jun 21, 2023, 3:09 PM UTC