
Kit-Carson
u/Kit-Carson

Rules of Tak - Starting Play
Players alternate turns throughout the game. You must play on your turn – there is no option to pass. Tak is played with only orthogonal movement and connection; squares are not connected diagonally and diagonal movement is not possible. On each player’s first turn, they will place one of their opponent’s stones flat on any empty square of the board. Play then continues with players placing new stones or moving existing stones they control. (from https://ustak.org/play-beautiful-game-tak/)
I'm fully aware the Rules of Tak were devised post-Wise Man's Fear by several years, but I like to im
I believe he is.
The voice came from a man who sat apart from the rest, wrapped in shadow at the edge of the fire. Though the sky was still bright with sunset and nothing stood between the fire and where he sat, shadow pooled around him like thick oil. The fire snapped and danced, lively and warm, tinged with blue, but no flicker of its light came close to him. The shadow gathered thicker around his head. I could catch a glimpse of a deep cowl like some priests wear, but underneath the shadows were so deep it was like looking down a well at midnight. (Ch. 16, Hope. NotW)
I theorize the curse limits Haliax's power in some way by obscuring his eyes. Though he appears to have full
Everyone's got their theories but nobody knows for sure, right?
Compare this with what's in the Lackless Box, or in the thrice-locked chest, or behind the four plate door. We don't know for sure what those secrets are, but quite possibly they aren't obvious secrets.
Kvothe's heart's desire could be a number of things, but it seems to be an easily known thing. Does he want to destroy the Chandrian? Does he want Denna? Does he want to be an Arcanist? Does he want to know the Name of the Wind? Does he want his parents back, his troupe back? Does he want to play music forever? To remember his father's song? Does he want to be remembered himself? Does he want to be all-powerful like Taborlin
The one called Cinder sheathed his sword with the sound of a tree cracking under the weight of winter ice. Keeping his distance, he knelt. Again I was reminded of the way mercury moved. Now on eye level with me, his expression grew concerned behind his matte-black eyes. "What's your name, boy?"
I stood there, mute. Frozen as a startled fawn.
Cinder sighed and dropped his gaze to the ground for a moment. When he looked back up at me I saw pity staring at me with hollow eyes. (Ch. 16, Hope. NotW)
Fully acknowledging that Pat doesn't write one-dimensional, good-vs-evil characters, what is your take on Cinder showing Kvothe a moment of pity when they first meet? The passage
Specifically, the first one found Ch. 26 "Lanre Turned" though my question could apply to both.
Now in those days there was a terrible war being fought across a vast empire. The war was called the Creation War, and the empire was called Ergen. And despite the fact that the world has never seen an empire as grand or a war so terrible, both of them only live in stories now. Even history books that mentioned them as doubtful rumor have long since crumbled into dust. (Ch. 26, Lanre Turned. NotW)
Right near the beginning we're told this is a story and not history. But then after it's over, Kvothe and Skarpi have this exchange:
I started to leave, then stopped. ***"Is
"Among the Cealdar there are legends of ever-burning lamps. I believe that such a thing was once within the scope of our craft. Ten years I have been looking. I have made many lamps, some of them very good, very long burning." He looked at me. "But none of them ever-burning." (Ch. 44, The Burning Glass. NotW)
To solve this mystery, we'll look at the following questions:
- Did such a lamp once exist?
- If yes, will Kvothe encounter one during his adventures?
- What's Kilvin's motivation for pursuing the ever-burning lamp?
- Can one be built?
"Ahhh," he said with fatherly pride. "My lovelies."
Kvothe’s first meeting with Kilvin provides a significant cl

I call it an arrowcatch, same as Kvothe when he couldn't think of a better name. I agree that it's merely an OK name, but currently none are better. If not an arrowcatch, I would call it a 'clank.'
The ideal name should sound or feel like a shield or like it's stopping something dangerous. It shouldn't mention the word blood even in negation. Imagine calling a bullet proof vest a Bloodsaver. Similarly, Bloodless is too close to Bloodletting.
I do appreciate the theory that Elodin's chosen name is a way to call it a 'Kvothe' without calling it by Kvothe's name, which is what Kvothe originally considered but dismissed. But even by this reasoning it's still a terrible name. Maybe Elodin had
This post was inspired by a short conversation I had with u/nIBLIB and u/IslandIsACork regarding that pesky X on the map found in the Maer's lockbox. This isn't about the map exactly but in thinking about those who theorize the X corresponds to somewhere in the Fae I wanted to summarize how I visualize the Fae interacting with the Four Corners. I'm intentionally avoiding the time mismatch issue for now and only focusing on geography.
[Here's the Four Corners (4Cs) map from the NotW 10th Anniversary Edition.](https://preview.redd.it/pi7mab3ti80b1.jpg?width=1800&format=pjpg&auto=webp&v=enabl
I'm chasing a theory idea and I would like your opinion on this oddity I noticed.
The Maer's lockbox, the treasure box reclaimed from the bandit camp in the Eld, why does Kvothe insist it stay with him until he personally returns to Severen?
I can somewhat understand carrying it into the Fae accidentally, but after returning to his group and then deciding to accompany Tempi to Ademre, Kvothe still insists that it stay with him? Why? He even makes up an excuse that he promised the Maer that he'd personally return it but then admitted that wasn't true. He made Dedan the new leader of the group. Is it a trust issue?
This just seems dumb to me. There's no point to carrying it all around for
For some of you, this isn't a new idea. And some of you may even take it further arguing that, yes, he's all those people plus a few more. But I'm more interested in hearing from the readers who, like me for the past 10 years until recently, firmly believe that Jax/Iax and Lanre are separate individuals in the KKC universe.
And if you can argue your side without referencing Skarpi, then bonus points for you. I have reason to believe that Skarpi's version isn't simply one viewpoint, but intentionally misleading.
No voting buttons, just a quick yes or no and why. I'm especially interested in your "why". I think there's evidence this can go either way, and the repercussions of each outcome is significant.
Recently, while browsing Pat's earliest blog entires—reveling in the nostalgia of the good 'ol days—I came across this quote:
Them: So what’s your book about?
Me: It’s The Princess Bride meets Fight Club, with a little bit of Pirates of the Caribbean sprinkled over the top.
I didn't give it much thought. Yup, cool. KKC is medieval adventuring and fighting.
Then I started my latest reread and suddenly this scene between Kvothe and Abenthy jumped out at me:
"How much do you know about your father's new song?"
_"The one about Lanre?" I asked. "Not much. You know what he's li
I forget who I spoke to about this, but someone pointed out that in Temerant exact historical dates get less exact the further back you go. It was a cool observation and I thought at the time there might be something more there other than simply bad recordkeeping.
Recently, I was thinking about the various tales of those nameless unfortunates who are lost after getting pulled into the Fae. One story tells of someone returning years later after having not aged a day and another story tells of someone returning days later after having aged 50 years or whatever it was. I was trying to play out a logic experiment in my head of how this would work if both of these examples entered at the same t