The Young Turks and the Armenian Genocide

I've heard a couple claims around reddit, that the young turks were intimately involved in the Armenian Genocide. How true is that? Also I have heard claims that many of the Young Turks were "Crypto-Jews" descendant from followers of a jewish messiah of the 18th century that converted to Islam. How true is that?

Posted Dec 16, 2012, 10:22 PM UTC

146
TiakoRoman Archaeology•

Well, the Young Turks, or the CUP, were in charge of the government at that point. It is worth noting that there is no reason to suspect Ataturk as masterminding, or even being involved in, the operations.

The Armenian Genocide is a matter of a certain amount of difficulty, in no small part because it is basically politically impossible to talk about it due to the intense nationalist interest on both sides of the issue. It is generally best to ignore most anything you read about it unless it is from a trusted source.

7
glaughtalk•

The claim is made by the Armenian National Institute.

To consolidate Turkish rule in the remaining territories of the Ottoman Empire and to expand the state into the so-called Turanian lands in the east, most held by Iran and Russia, the CUP devised in secret a program for the extermination of the Armenian population. From the viewpoint of Ittihadist ideology and its new and ambitious foreign policy, the Armenians represented a completely vulnerable population straddling an area of major strategic value for its Pan-Turanian goals.

1
TheOneFreeEngineerOP•

What is the CUP? What does Turanian mean? What does Ittihadist mean?

3
glaughtalk•

Turanian means a conglomerated nationality composed of Ottoman Turks, Azeris, Kazakhs, Uzbeks, Kyrgyz and Turkmen. These people speak Turkic languages. CUP and Ittihadist refer to the Committee of Union and Progress.

At the center of the Young Turk Revolution stood the Committee of Union and Progress (CUP) (Ittihad ve Terakki Jemiyeti) formed in 1895. Its members came to be known as Ittihadists or Unionists. The most ideologically committed party in the entire movement, the CUP espoused a form of Turkish nationalism which was xenophobic and exclusionary in its thinking. Its policies threatened to undo the tattered fabric of a multi-ethnic and multi-religious society. Taking advantage of the political confusion reigning in the aftermath of the First Balkan War which the Ottoman Empire lost in 1912 to its former subject states, the CUP seized power in a coup d'etat in January 1913. As it led the empire to a partial recovery in the Second Balkan War, the CUP monopolized political power domestically by bringing the Parliament completely under its influence. It also began to steer away from the long-held Ottoman foreign policy of alliances with Great Britain and France, and forged a stronger military cooperation with Germany. Moreover, the CUP compensated for the Ottoman retreat in the Balkans by promoting Pan-Turkism, an expansionist program designed to challenge Russia in its southern tier. By the time World War I broke out in August 1914, the CUP constituted a chauvinistic band which had subordinated the Ottoman state to its Turkist ideology. It also propelled the country into war against its better interests by entering into a secret accord with Germany.

And here's an article at The History Place.

3
lngwstksgkModerator | Jacobite Rising 1745•

From the link the previous poster provided:

At the center of the Young Turk Revolution stood the Committee of Union and Progress (CUP) (Ittihad ve Terakki Jemiyeti) formed in 1895. Its members came to be known as Ittihadists or Unionists.

A quick Google search leads me to believe that "Turanian" in this case relates to territory presumed to belong to an ancient ethnic group tied to the Turkish nationalist movement. See turanism.

1
gingerkid1234Moderator | Jewish Studies•

Also I have heard claims that many of the Young Turks were "Crypto-Jews" descendant from followers of a jewish messiah of the 18th century that converted to Islam. How true is that?

That's talking about the Dönmeh, a group who continued to claim a guy named Shabbatai Tzvi was the messiah and converted with him to Islam. Tons of Jews thought he was the messiah (though not all--lots of Rabbis opposed him, which cause conterversy then), but very few weren't convinced otherwise when he converted to Islam and died. The wikipedia page on them references them being prominent in the Young Turk movement.

See this guy for an example of that.

1