TheOneFreeEngineer

u/TheOneFreeEngineer


r/AskHistorians•

I recently came across a claim that Turkish Jews were also targets of the Turkish state during the period of the Armenian genocide like the Greeks and Pontics were. I've never heard anything about this and would like to know more. I was under the understanding that Jews left Anatolia and Rumelia in waves in the 1930s and 1950s to Israel but I'm unaware of any migration waves during the last days of the Ottoman state.

What was the Turkish Jewish relationship with the state like during the 1910s? How different was it to the relationship with the Turkish state in the Levant during the same period?.

20

r/AskHistorians•

I once heard a story about the Islamic expansions that claimed there was some sort of disagreement between the Island of Cyprus and the Eastern Roman Empire in the 600s and the Islamic armies pushed the Roman armies out of Cyprus but left the island both independent and under Christian rule. It sounds like some medieval polemic by Muslim sources and not a real event. Could someone explain the history of the island of Cyprus during the 600s and early 700S CE? Thank you

52

r/AskHistorians•

In the recent heating up of Israel/ Palestine conflict, I saw a user on reddit mention that there was a referendum that went in favor of Israel in the 1917. I find this odd because the Ottoman empire still controlled the region at this time. What is this user talking about?

15

r/badhistory•

http://www.np.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/29ju47/isis_vows_to_destroy_meccas_kaaba_kill_those_who/cilm7op

The idea of wanting to destroy the Kaaba has a long and interesting precedent. Throughout history, Arabs who have traditionally hated Muhammad have expressed their desire of doing so, probably out of spite of what Muhammad represents. Yazid bin Muawiya of the opposing clan of the Ummayads, who massacred Muhammad's family including Muhammad's grandson Hussein at Karbala, also attacked the Kaaba with catapults. Previously, Muhammad's grandfather Abdul Muttalib organized the defense of the Kaaba against another attacker named Abraha who arrived with a cavalry of elephants. In the c

7589

r/AskHistorians•

I found an article recently that claimed that the traditional historical claims that Muslim rulers destroyed thousands of Hindu temples are not supported by the evidence. Specifically that one researcher could only find 80 temples that had been destroyed.

The researcher claims also that Aurangzeb, who is famous for being a fanatical Muslim ruler, built temples in Bengal.

The site I found it on is obviously biased, but I was wondering how accurate the claims presented in the article were

I found the article here: http://www.loonwatch.com/2013/12/its-a-myth-that-muslim-rulers-destroyed-thousands-of-temples/

Also I found somewhere that claimed that while Aurangzeb re-instituted the Jizya t

160


r/AskHistorians•

I have heard some contradicting claims about the brutality of each system compared to the other. Could anyone give a general idea of the numbers of slaves in each system, the primary years of the system, and a comparasion of the American system to specific periods of the Arab system (because I know it stretched a long period), like pre-Islamic, Abbasid caliphate, and Ottoman Turks?

I know that slaves in Islamic regions could become very powerful in their own rights, but was that just a select few that people like to point at now, or did the stratification of slave society mirror free society?

67

r/AskHistorians•

I've heard a couple claims around reddit, that the young turks were intimately involved in the Armenian Genocide. How true is that? Also I have heard claims that many of the Young Turks were "Crypto-Jews" descendant from followers of a jewish messiah of the 18th century that converted to Islam. How true is that?

146

r/islam•

http://www.indianexpress.com/news/islamic-seminary-darul-uloom-deoband-issues-fatwa-against-tattoo-use-of-perfume/1040887/

"Muslim women working in offices as receptionist is un-Islamic because Muslim women are not allowed to appear before men without veil," it said.

I'm not going to argue about the tattoos or alcohol based perfumes being haram, but the logic behind fatwa against Muslim women working as receptionists seems to equate working as a receptionist with women not observing Hijab, which is false. I was curious about r/islam's thought's on the logic of the fatwa against Muslimahs working as recpetionists. To me it seems faulty.

137

r/askscience•

What is the scientific relevance of the mitochondrial eve? I'm confused becuase the Wikipedia reference has this quote:

Each ancestor (of people now living) in the line back to the matrilineal MRCA had female contemporaries such as sisters, female cousins, etc. and some of these female contemporaries may have descendants living now (with one or more males in their descendancy line). But none of the female contemporaries of the "Mitochondrial Eve" has descendants living now in an unbroken female line.

So there were other females as this "Eve's" comtempories with descendants, so why is this one ancestor of any importance scientifically?

96

r/islam•

A number of times the Quran says to command what is right and forbid what is evil or wrong, But I have a question on what is "evil" in this context. Is the Arabic word used connected to the term haram? If not what type of things need to be forbidden? What is evil in an Islamic context or rather what does the term translated as evil refer to?

115

r/islam•

I have a very very basic understanding of hadith and feel I am doing a disservice to following Islam but not fully understanding Hadith science, especially when I feel like I am hearing scholars or "scholars" come to differing opinions, especially since I just found a fatwa saying covering hair is not mandatory for muslimahs based on Hadith science.

Could some of the more knowledgeable brothers and sisters lead me to some trustworthy books (English please, as it is the only language I know well besides Latin and I doubt there is anything in Latin :P) or internet sites on Hadith Science/St

118