Dutch Cycling youtuber suggesting change to map, after major road redesign in Utrecht.

Posted Aug 2, 2023, 4:26 PM UTC

16
8spdOP•

Do we have any people familiar with the situation on the ground. I was watching this video out of interest in urban design, and making transport infrastructure less car-centric. I was caught off guard by the complaint about OSM, and the claim that google maps has the road mapped correctly.

1
scruss•

Does it, though? All I see in the transcript is at 38s:

Some maps still show the Utrecht inner ring road as a complete ring. Google no longer does, which reflects the current situation better.

OSM isn't mentioned by name, only by an image

1
janjko•

But OSM still shows it as a ring road:

https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=13/52.0852/5.1165

1
OkDimension•

Somebody recently downgraded parts of it from secondary to tertiary, I had to refresh my map to get tiles rendered correctly. I am not sure if I would map it anything less than tertiary, because it still seems a connector between city quarters and a collector for the secondary roads.

1
macumbamacaca•

That was my first thought. The second was that they should complain to the government that it is passing road update information to a foreign commercial company instead of updating open map data.

1
krijnsent•

Some maps still show the Utrecht inner ring road as a complete ring. Google no longer does, which reflects the current situation better.

As a local, this is indeed happening and mapped accordingly.
This street was done some year ago: https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=19/52.06590/5.12202 , it shows correctly as 2 split lanes with green in the middle, marked as "secundary road" - showing yellow on the map.

This road is being worked on at the moment: https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=19/52.10417/5.09069 , somewhere half-way the process. So it's still tagged as "primary road" (showing orange on the map), but might be downgraded to "secundary road" when the process of transforming it into a "city boulevard" is complete.

1