needanewOPMarine•

Anyone know if this is a common problem? 2012 E450 6.8l.

Really aggravates me that I had a mechanic test the cooling system, said it was building pressure fine. Got it home and started checking it out myself.

1
bgb111•

A water pump doesn’t create pressure, it creates flow. The heat of the engine causes the coolant to expand and that’s where your pressure comes from.

1
Shaex•

Pressure and flow rate are always proportional, pump is doing both. Heat contributes of course, but a pump can't create flow without creating a pressure differential.

1
MinorComprehension•

Pressure and flow are always proportional when you have a relatively static thermal operating environment. If the cooling system did not experience thermal expansion then you'd be correct, the amount of pressure would be proportional to the pressure differential across the inlet and outlet of the water pump during operation, and flow would be affected, or vise versa.

If thermal dynamics didn't have a primary effect, the pressure in the cooling system would drop to zero, or the initial pressure, the instant the motor was shut off and the water pump stopped. Anybody who's opened a hot radiator cap, with the motor off, empirically knows it's not the pump creating the majority of the pressure in the cooling system. In automotive cooling applications, the water pump serves only to circulate coolant to avoid too much thermal expansion and pressure increase, it does not provide the pressure itself. In fact, the rate of flow through the cooling system helps reduce the pressure due to thermal expansion - in simplistic terms anyways, assuming the rate of flow is balanced to the thermal rejection capabilities of heat exchanger devices. In this specific case, it's clear is the water pump was pumping minimally if at all, proving that flow is not always proportional pressure in a thermally dynamic system.

1
SubiWan•

I was one the recipient of that empiric knowledge. I thought the pressure had finished releasing. I didn't know the radiator cap gasket had partially melted to the radiator neck. I got a 200 degree shower. Fortunately it was only water.

1
erikwarm•

Yup! Pressure is just the resistance a flow creates when it flows trough something

1
needanewOPShade Tree•

I understand that.

How are you supposed to test flow rate when there is no radiator cap?

1
conaan•

How would you test for flow in a DIY friendly manner in this scenario? Not speaking specifics to a model, just a general idea for my knowledge

1
dego_frank•

This was your bad, not the techs. You could just rent a tool to pressure test the system. If you wanted them to diagnose a cooling issue, that’s different and their bad

1
Inveramsay•

A yes, the ninja throwing star water pump. Excellent quality workmanship

1
buzzonga•

Water pump evolved to water mover arounder.

1
needanewOPShade Tree•

Became more like a restrictor plate.

1
STEWARTkush•

Can’t really restrict flow if there is no flow to begin with.

1
Zogaderzischer•

Volkswagen idiots used plastic rotors that were directly molded onto a barely knurled steel shaft. The rotor would likewise be dragged by the shaft or not. Random overheating and normal function would follow each other.

1
uglyugly1•

I was an auto tech for almost 20 years, most of it spent in fleet. Most of the vehicles I worked on during that time were Econolines with the 5.4 or 6.8 engine. I've never seen a water pump impeller come off of one before. I would have been scratching my head over that for a bit, too.

I'm sure the pressure test was fine, because the system is free from leaks. I'd be frustrated too, but it's not necessarily the tech's fault (unless you asked him to figure it out and he didn't).

1
needanewOPShade Tree•

I don’t really blame him, it was more like check for anything obvious/ dangerous, I need to get home tomorrow. And I paid for an oil change too.

1
SmokinGreenNugs•

That’s a cool ninja star!!!

1
Breddit2225•

It's always the last place you look.

1
Mx5-gleneagles•

It’s always the last resort when diagnosing a overheating problem and when you finally take it off its usually ok !!

1
needanewOPShade Tree•

I was half afraid that would happen. I guess I’m just glad now it’s an obvious problem.

1
apocaloptomist9214•

Strange failure. That impeller didn't just fall off, the shaft it was riding on is sheard off. As far as checking for flow, in a car with a radiator that you can look into take the radiator cap off (with the engine cool) start the motor and watch the coolant in the radiator. When the coolant is up to operating temperature the thermostat will open and you will see coolant flow through the radiator. No water pump, no flow. No matter how hot the engine gets.

1
needanewOPShade Tree•

No radiator cap on this Ford.

1