How much of a difference is there between lower and higher end load cell pedals?

:question: Question

I have CSL Elite v2 set that I've been using for 10 months or so, originally coming from G29 pedals. I have a friend who also upgraded around the same time to Clubsport V3 pedals. We're both curious what the biggest differences between our pedal sets (which seem to be the lower end of loadcell pedals) and higher end ones, such as Heuskinvelds, VRS, Asetek, VNM, etc.

Obviously each of these different sets have their own feeling to them, but is there an explainable, overarching difference between the lower and higher end loadcell pedals? We both are considering upgrading but have held off since we have no experience using pedals nicer than the ones we have.

Posted Sep 23, 2023, 1:29 AM UTC

19
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
SammoNZL•

Generally you would get:

Higher rated load cell

Bit nicer brake feel

Better adjustability

Better build quality

Nicer clutches and throttles

Damper / hydraulic options

Performance wise probably not a high amount unless you’re the reincarnation of Senna.

Pedals get pretty gnarly, checked out some simtrecs the other day - oh boy 🥵

1
SteelCogsOP•

Yeah I guess performance is what I'm most curious about. I also really only play iRacing and it generally feels like the next logical hardware upgrade is a nicer pedal set. From time to time I notice others are somehow able to out brake me, seemingly easily, in cars without ABS. I'd just hate to drop $600+ on a new set only to realize my braking consistency was already bad on elite v2's lol.

1
adam389•

Performance wise, a higher brake pedal face force allows you a little more control at the upper end of the braking spectrum. The load cell rating itself is arbitrary and just stupid marking garbage.

Remember - the load cell doesn't really matter, because the pedal is a fulcrum (a lever like a pry bar), and depending on how it's designed, the load cell could see 10kg or 200kg. "Give me a lever long enough and I can move the world" a smart guy once said.

1
turntable_eyes•

I upgraded from CSL v2 to heusinkveld sprints and the different was huge. For me, the nearly fixed position of the v2 didn’t agree with me. The adjustability probably did not net me time per se, but it probably made me more consistent and definitely more comfortable. YMMV

1
adam389•

100% agree with this. I was fortunate enough to go VNM out of the gate, but I'm glad I did - they're very clearly going to be on my rig forever. I have angles and travel and tension, etc all adjusted on mine, and it's been really nice to have the ability to do that.

1
SottLimpaUsing Simucube on an Ikea table•

Me and 3 teammates experienced this transition last 2 years. We play ACC and all of us are lfm top split drivers.

Me: TLCM to Simgrade VX-Pro

Friend1: TLCM to Heusinkveld Ultimate

Friend2: Fanatec V3 to Heusinkveld Ultimate

Friend3: Fanatec V3 to VRS

We are all improved, we are all so satisfied with our purchases. The main difference is you are able to have more precision on the brake pedal. You want to give 5% input then it's 5% do you want to give 88% then it's 88% it's just in there. With Fanatec and Thrustmaster loadcells this were not so accurate. You don't feel small tiny inputs, you have hard time to keep it on the exact amount of the brake. Resolution, feeling of the elastomers/springs are just not enough to have precision. For beginners they're miles better than position reading pedals but for experienced drivers they're not enough.

And the throttle pedal. Oh boy you'll love it. Those hall sensor sponge throttle pedals on entry level loadcell pedal sets are nothing in comparison with a decent loadcell throttle pedal. Your throttle input will improve too. And I paid only 400eur including delivery to my pedals. Simply great.

1
SteelCogsOP•

I hadn't even considered extra precision on the throttle. Now I'm interested in feeling the difference with that too!

You put the brake pedal explanation really well. I kind of assumed it would be more precise, but didn't think of it as being able to feel tiny inputs. I can definitely tell from time to time with my Elite V2's that I don't have the most precise trailbraking taper mid corner.

I'm generally pretty mid pace at lower-mid splits on iRacing, so any improvement would be helpful. There's nothing worse than somebody overtaking in a car without ABS when I feel like if I took that line I would 100% lock up and go flying off track lol.

1
Conrad_Hawke_NYPDDD1 | Heusinkveld U+ | Clubsport SQ | Reverb G2 | P1-X | iRacing•

Went from fanatec v3s to HE ultimates, I am significantly more accurate with the ultimates and am much more able to apply a small amount of pressure. They're also much more customisable and easy to change.

It's a big difference but not as much as non loadcell to loadcell.

1