Isn't it odd that Kvothe's "Heart's Desire" is still a mystery?

Everyone's got their theories but nobody knows for sure, right?

Compare this with what's in the Lackless Box, or in the thrice-locked chest, or behind the four plate door. We don't know for sure what those secrets are, but quite possibly they aren't obvious secrets.

Kvothe's heart's desire could be a number of things, but it seems to be an easily known thing. Does he want to destroy the Chandrian? Does he want Denna? Does he want to be an Arcanist? Does he want to know the Name of the Wind? Does he want his parents back, his troupe back? Does he want to play music forever? To remember his father's song? Does he want to be remembered himself? Does he want to be all-powerful like Taborlin the Great? I think all of these can be boiled down to: Does he desire love or power (revenge)?

And in book 3 we will surely learn what his heart's desire is. It's something that should be obvious from what we know about him, and yet it's still a mystery at this point.

What am I not seeing? What kind of reveal awaits us that will make the "heart's desire" question worth waiting for?

Posted Oct 11, 2023, 1:49 PM UTC

17
turnedabout•

I believe at the heart of the question of what Kvothe wants most is his family. He is Ruh to the bone, a trouper at heart, and the loss he feels the most keenly is that of his troupe, his family.

When everything is stripped away by the plum bob, he’s reduced to a sobbing curled up body of pain and grief over the loss of his mom and that he’ll never see or hear or touch her again.

I think the magic that he steals from the university, the dark magic/forces better left alone, relates to how to shape man/bring back the dead. I think this is also what Lanre learned and was related to the unexpected outcome and cost it exacted.

And i think it ties in with the desire burning unchecked in Lanre (akin to a plum bob), and the desire Auri is careful not to give in to, and the seeking of one’s Heart’s Desire, that must be countered with the Heart of Stone which seems to be what Lanre might be using to keep himself in check. No one else discusses or alludes to using Heart of Stone when wielding Alar.

We’ve been told that the barrow king of Vint is behind the four plate door iirc.

Rothfuss even revealed the name of the sleeping barrow king in question: Feija, the first king of Vintas who united a bunch of warring factions into the nation we know from the books.

newly minted Vintish coin that bears Feija’s likeness. The image is split down the middle: on one half we see Feija standing tall with his sword and a bunch of those lesser kings behind him. On the other, we see a skeletal-looking figure in front of some standing stones. “On one side, there he is Feija King Maker,” Rothfuss explains. “[A]nd here he is otherwise: Feija, king in life and king in death.”

Someone on the stream asked if Feija was still alive thanks to Necromancy, the oft-used fantasy magic that deals with raising the dead. Rothfuss had some strong feelings about it:

Necromancy is for f@#$ing wankers who play D&D. Feija is a dead king, buried in the proper way–a man with the will to make a nation. And a man such as that does not merely die if he does not wish to, he comes back as a draug. And not this bullshit Skyrim draug, like you’re a zombie with a different name. You come back as Wizard King Feija, first king, always king, in his barrow watching the lands. Necromancy my ass. Through his will alone does Feija continue to watch over Vintas.

So it sounds a little like a strong enough will, combined with a strong enough desire, can make passing through the doors of stone possible. Just likely not advisable.

I dunno, there’s my rambling thought for the day

2