Got an email about our son's school unsure what to questions to ask.
My son (4m) currently goes to a Montessori school. Today all of the parents received an email from the now resigned Spanish teacher about the way the owner was correcting student behavior.
The owner has been in business for 14+ years and the Spanish teacher had just started that year.
Behaviours from the owner that were mentioned were grabbing children's faces by the lower jaw to force them to make eye contact, telling a student who had been picking bark off a tree, after being reprimanded and was crying was told (per the email) “stop crying, I should be the one crying. My tree will die now and I am very sad". Also supposedly telling a child to stop eating like a dog.
There was an audio file attached, it was a partial conversation and started midway through. The Spanish teacher who was recording remained calm during the entire thing with the owner clearly upset and emotional.
Early in the convo the owner admitted to and defended grabbing children's faces n"ever to hurt but to redirect their attention" so they'd make eye contact because if they're distracted and not looking they're not going to listen. The owner and her daughter, who is also a teacher at the school, said that the face grabbing is done at any school and is a common practice.
I find that difficult to believe.
The other thing that was concerning is an incident that was never spelled out in the audio involving a child and the owner was saying that had been addressed and she admitted it could have been handled better and "it was one child one time".
Obviously with how long she's been in business I feel like while possible it's unlikely that whatever happened was one child one time.
The owner being emotional and rude during the audio seemed to be (from her words) that she felt betrayed by the Spanish Teacher, someone she thought she trusted and she was just making things up and being self righteous. But we also don't know what was said before the recording happened that could have put her in an emotional state.
My initial reaction is outrage, but I'm unsure of the best way to ask further questions of the school or to find out additional info that might corroborate the info in the email.
My wife and I talked to my son and he said all the teachers are nice and none of them have been mean or grabbed his face. However, I've spoken with a few parents of other kids and some have said she's grabbed their faces but haven't hurt them or touched them in any other way.
Is there a better way to frame questions to my child so as not to lead them to a specific conclusion?
Is my outrage misplaced and this is a common thing that happens at schools? I don't believe it is.
I'm in a pretty emotional state currently and looking for additional opinions/perspectives.
Posted Nov 25, 2023, 8:53 PM UTC
Honestly if it were me I would consider this enough information to call the schools licensing body and child protective services regardless of what my kid says. The school is going to give political non answers to anything that you ask them, and a 4 year old can’t really understand those questions. Not that the authorities always get it right either, but getting them involved may be the best chance that the truth is discovered or that at least the owner faces enough pressure to either quit or make major changes.
I hadn't thought about calling the licensing body so thank you for that. And I guess I also didn't think about CPS being called on a school so I'll look into that route and maybe bring it up with the other parents too
Just to chip in... Not only is this above reddits pay grade, but this is also above any individual parent's pay grade.
There are other children's wellbeing at stake here as well as your own, and honestly an investigation will be the only way to get objective information about this (beyond the original recording).
I have been involved in protection cases where care homes rather than schools were being investigated. They are - I'm sure - very unpleasant for the staff, but any staff with integrity will recognise their necessity.
At least here in Texas the way this kind of thing works is that we have a State Hotline that you call to report abuse, they’ll take your report and send it on to the correct licensing body. They take all reports very seriously.