Got an email about our son's school unsure what to questions to ask.

Advice Request

My son (4m) currently goes to a Montessori school. Today all of the parents received an email from the now resigned Spanish teacher about the way the owner was correcting student behavior.

The owner has been in business for 14+ years and the Spanish teacher had just started that year.

Behaviours from the owner that were mentioned were grabbing children's faces by the lower jaw to force them to make eye contact, telling a student who had been picking bark off a tree, after being reprimanded and was crying was told (per the email) “stop crying, I should be the one crying. My tree will die now and I am very sad". Also supposedly telling a child to stop eating like a dog.

There was an audio file attached, it was a partial conversation and started midway through. The Spanish teacher who was recording remained calm during the entire thing with the owner clearly upset and emotional.

Early in the convo the owner admitted to and defended grabbing children's faces n"ever to hurt but to redirect their attention" so they'd make eye contact because if they're distracted and not looking they're not going to listen. The owner and her daughter, who is also a teacher at the school, said that the face grabbing is done at any school and is a common practice.

I find that difficult to believe.

The other thing that was concerning is an incident that was never spelled out in the audio involving a child and the owner was saying that had been addressed and she admitted it could have been handled better and "it was one child one time".

Obviously with how long she's been in business I feel like while possible it's unlikely that whatever happened was one child one time.

The owner being emotional and rude during the audio seemed to be (from her words) that she felt betrayed by the Spanish Teacher, someone she thought she trusted and she was just making things up and being self righteous. But we also don't know what was said before the recording happened that could have put her in an emotional state.

My initial reaction is outrage, but I'm unsure of the best way to ask further questions of the school or to find out additional info that might corroborate the info in the email.

My wife and I talked to my son and he said all the teachers are nice and none of them have been mean or grabbed his face. However, I've spoken with a few parents of other kids and some have said she's grabbed their faces but haven't hurt them or touched them in any other way.

Is there a better way to frame questions to my child so as not to lead them to a specific conclusion?

Is my outrage misplaced and this is a common thing that happens at schools? I don't believe it is.

I'm in a pretty emotional state currently and looking for additional opinions/perspectives.

Posted Nov 25, 2023, 8:53 PM UTC

26136

Honestly if it were me I would consider this enough information to call the schools licensing body and child protective services regardless of what my kid says. The school is going to give political non answers to anything that you ask them, and a 4 year old can’t really understand those questions. Not that the authorities always get it right either, but getting them involved may be the best chance that the truth is discovered or that at least the owner faces enough pressure to either quit or make major changes.

370
Boolean_NullOP•

I hadn't thought about calling the licensing body so thank you for that. And I guess I also didn't think about CPS being called on a school so I'll look into that route and maybe bring it up with the other parents too

94

Just to chip in... Not only is this above reddits pay grade, but this is also above any individual parent's pay grade.

There are other children's wellbeing at stake here as well as your own, and honestly an investigation will be the only way to get objective information about this (beyond the original recording).

I have been involved in protection cases where care homes rather than schools were being investigated. They are - I'm sure - very unpleasant for the staff, but any staff with integrity will recognise their necessity.

25
RebelliousBristlesDad to 6F•

At least here in Texas the way this kind of thing works is that we have a State Hotline that you call to report abuse, they’ll take your report and send it on to the correct licensing body. They take all reports very seriously.

4
SixSixTrample•

Take it all very seriously and find a new school. We had nothing but problems at the Montessori school our son used to attend; nothing as bad as grabbing kids faces, but our son would constantly be distraught and talk about not wanting to go to school.

Other parents had very similar issues. We moved him and he was much happier, and a lot of behavior issues disappeared as well.

Your outrage isn't misplaced. Ask very general questions of your child and let them answer or ramble. Make sure they know they're not in trouble at all, and just listen.

​

Then just find a new school. You should absolutely pursue more information, and possibly action against that school, but just find a new one first. Get out asap.

96
Boolean_NullOP•

Our son does seem very happy at the school and is excited to go every day. And even though he said he hadn't seen any teachers hurt any kids from what I've been told he tends to just do whatever work he's doing by himself so he's probably focused on that and not really paying attention to what's happening to the others.

Since other parents have said their kids have had their faces grabbed I feel like he just hadn't paid attention or he doesn't remember l.

20
InTheFDN•

What will you do when it’s your child coming home and telling you he’s being manhandled? If you’re willing to wait then there’s nothing you need to do.

12
Boolean_NullOP•

Yeah, after I calmed down a little and processed more. I'm definitely just going to pull him and probably homeschool the rest of the year. We'll look at new schools next year.

I can get worked up pretty easily which is why I was second guessing myself if I was overreacting but realistically the thought of them putting hands on him like that would have pissed me off and listening to the audio again if that's the kind of behavior a teacher is modeling while under stress I don't need my kid exposed to it.

19
STFUandLOVE•

Just want to add that my wife worked on the admin team for a four different daycares as she was working on transferring her teachers license to a new state - we moved a lot for a few years. Every daycare she worked at has AWFUL owners or directors. Not just in how they treat their staff, but in how they try to veil and problems at the program with shiny language about providing an education to your children. Newsflash, all daycares barely scratch the surface of educating your kids and only a tiny fraction do it well.

First, realize the teachers are often being paid about $13-$16 per hour. And every single owner thought they were paying them too much. They treated the teachers like shit:

  • forcing them to write curriculum outside of their paid hours,
  • forcing them to write curriculum 1 month in advance - even brand new teachers,
  • forcing pregnant women to work in the infant room,
  • not allowing pregnant women to park near the school while toting tons of books from the library,
  • reprimanding teachers for going to their scheduled medical appointments,
  • providing zero clear direction but expecting teachers to know exactly what they want done - even when what they want done makes no sense,
  • forcing teachers and admin staff to market the educational aspects to parents even when it was complete BS

At one daycare, my wife had to review, comment, approve 30 curriculums a day; forced to spend 6 hours in the classroom even when ratios were met; organize teachers supplies for each teacher’s curriculum for the next week, and make library runs. All on an 8 hour day. There literally wasn’t enough time to do all this and she was constantly getting chastised for not completing the work. When she got hired, they took away two of her admin assistants who used to develop curriculum schedules and organize teacher supplies as a full time job and gave the assistants them to the new director. The new director then put tons more work on the staff and they were leaving left and right.

The extra workload on the staff was to put the next month’s curriculum online for parents to review and allow the owner to show posted curriculum on the doors as they toured. Problem though, is the teachers NEVER executed the curriculum because they were understaffed and just trying to keep the kids safe.

What my wife noticed is the more a daycare touts their educational qualities, the worse the program usually is. Ask the teachers how they feel about the program and not the director / owner. Every owner was a narcissistic asshole.

6
Random-Cpl•

Just wanted to say that based on the actions and statements the owner has taken subsequently, it sounds like the former teacher’s concerns are likely justified, and you seem like you’re making the right decision.

1
advocatus_ebrius_estDad of 2 Girls•

Re: Leading questions

Ask "open ended questions", i.e. ones that don't have yes/no for an answer.

"What does teacher do if you aren't listening" vs "Does teacher grab your face if you don't listen"

Then, as others have said, let the kid talk and see if anything else needs follow up questions.

86
Hotwir3•

It’s so easy to manipulate kids though to get an answer you want, even unintentionally

22
advocatus_ebrius_estDad of 2 Girls•

Perhaps, but avoiding leading questions can go a long way to mitigate this. Also, it is rarely that unintentional. Look at what they did in the McFarlane Preschool interviews. That wasn't done by accident.

14
Hotwir3•

Sorry my reply was short there. I was actually trying to add support to your comment. I was not trying to argue against it.

3
docgravel•

I know this! It’s a silly example by contrast, but it helped me understand how unreliable of a witness my 3 year old is.

We asked her what movie she watched at a movie night at the community center. We made her leave early, so we told her we would try to find it so she could watch the ending another time. She said it was a movie with a baby and a scary daddy. We said “Despicable Me” and showed her the poster and she said “yes, that was it”. We made some Minions references and she laughed at them and agreed they happened. Then she told us that actually there was only one baby, not 3 girls. We looked at all the movie posters and said, “do you think it was Despicable Me 3?” and showed her the movie poster. She agreed, it was definitely that one. We watched the trailer and she said that it wasn’t the right movie. We asked ChatGPT for movie ideas based on her description and came up with a list of possibilities:

  1. Monsters Inc
  2. The Incredibles
  3. Despicable Me
  4. Boss Baby
  5. Hotel Transylvania

We already knew that just asking her which it was wouldn’t work, so we made a witness lineup of characters and had her say yes or no to each one. Based on the characters she said were in the movie, we determined it was Hotel Transylvania 2. We checked the library and the only copy was checked out the day of the movie night and due back soon.

5
AGoodFaceForRadioFather of three•

For your child:

  • “How does [owner] act when you make bad choices?”
  • “How does [owner] react when other kids make bad choices?”
  • lots of “And then what?” and “Tell me more about that” and “How did that make you feel?”
  • be very careful to not ask leading questions; kids that age are super suggestible

For the owner:

  • “How do the things I’m hearing fit with the Montessori approach?”

For the licensing organization:

  • “How do the things I’m hearing fit with the Montessori approach?”
  • “How do the things I’m hearing fit with generally accepted teaching practices?”
  • “How do you intend to respond to these allegations?”
  • “By which date should I expect a written update from you on this matter?”
60
Boolean_NullOP•

Thank you for these. I think we did ask some leading questions without meaning too. I'll wait a few days then ask him again with the ones you've listed. Thank you.

24
AGoodFaceForRadioFather of three•

Hopefully everything works out ok for you.

4
THE_BOKEH_BLOKE•

Imagine if you were the one grabbing your son’s face in such a manner and he told his teachers.

They’re mandatory reporters, and I guarantee you’d be getting a knock on your front door by CPS at some point.

17
ryan2489•

Glad to see you’re pulling your kid. I work at a daycare and nobody has ever said or thought to try handling kids by the chin. Our last director was a psycho like that and almost destroyed the entire business. But of course she would never admit any wrongdoing. The smoke was billowing but nothing was on fire according to her.

15
Boolean_NullOP•

Yeah I don't know why I was second guessing myself on this other than I can get heated up quickly but after calming down it seems so obvious like if it was me giving someone advice I'd have been what are you waiting for?!

9
ryan2489•

It’s not your fault, I’ve had so many moments as a parent where something so beyond the pale happens that you sometimes think “there’s no way that actually happened, right?”

5
schmidit•

I’m a teacher (high school) and a dad of a pre school teacher.

I’ve seen a lot of administrators suddenly flame out and lose it. Particularly in private organizations like this where there isn’t any really oversight people can turn into monsters pretty fast.

This teacher just torpedoed her entire career for the sake of protecting kids. No matter what happened this school isn’t going to be a good place for the foreseeable future. They’re going to lose a ton of students and likely every teacher started looking for new jobs when they got this email.

This is going to make a stressed out admin wayyyy more stressed and they’re going to make even worse decisions.

8
Random-Cpl•

I would withdraw my children from the school immediately and would report them to my state’s licensing body.

7
Douggiefresh43•

If you have other options in the area, you should explore those. This is all pretty concerning, enough so that I would not trust them with my kid anymore. The owner sounds like someone who hasn’t kept up on the past thirty years of research about what works with this age group - the teacher equivalent of your uncle who complains that kids are too soft because we can’t beat them anymore.

Your concern is valid. I’m sorry you have to deal with this!

5
PoliteCanadian2•

I’m going to say 2 things:

  1. where there’s smoke there is likely fire

  2. the grabbing faces thing seemed pretty far fetched until oops now there’s audio to support it.

5
Jermicdub•

I’m in New Brunswick, Canada, if that’s relevant. I don’t work in the school system but I work around them a lot professionally. You don’t grab kids to make a point. Period. End of discussion.

3
Archaias06•

This type of accusation - even when false - warrants a full investigation.

I have pulled my children out of two daycare centers for unacceptable disciplinary practices.

Every human makes mistakes, but it is thoroughly and inconceivably unacceptable for daycare to practice, protect, or allow this type of abuse, even under the guise of temporary lack of self control.

3
HeyImIan•

we went through something very similar at my kid’s Montessori school - older administrator being rough with discipline and hostile to teachers. it was difficult because he had an amazing class of friends so we were really torn. but when the teachers (who were absolutely amazing and were the soul of the school) started to resign we ended up moving him to a different school.

2
CuntyReplies•

The owner and her daughter, who is also a teacher at the school, said that the face grabbing is done at any school and is a common practice.

This is not common practice. A large number of my clients are schools and we work on things like guidelines and policies regarding physical handling and restraint, supportive/cooperative contact etc and forcibly holding onto a child's face would be unacceptable and grounds for a stand down of a teacher if that was to occur.

The use of physical restraint is usually restricted only to use by a teacher where a risk of physical harm or serious property damage may occur. At least, that has been my experience with such matters across more than 40 public and private schools across Asia and Australasia.

2
capybaratrousers•

I don't have a lot to offer you, but this is definitely concerning. I've had awkward conversations with daycare directors. Be firm, ask your questions and then let them answer them. As a parent, they owe you answers. Ask the question and then be quiet. Let the silence do the work.

1
froandfear•

Never, ever second guess yourself when it comes to your child’s safety. Get them the fuck up out of this school.

1
EverybodyStayCoolThe Dad, man...•

Yooooo. I'm calling the cops. Then a lawyer. In that order.

1
moviemerc•

My partner and I just pulled out kid out of a daycare due to some things that happened with other kids.

First they went to a fun farm one day. After I picked my kid up there, day care lady took the others into the store they had there. Apparently the kids were acting out and the daycare lady grabbed them by the arms and forced them to sit down. A worker at the store notified the daycare network who in turn notified us. They did their own investigation and couldn't verify anything. We were naive enough to think it was just exaggerated, plus she really seemed to love our kid so we kinda let it go.

Second and third instance came close together. Second instance was daycare lady told my MIL when she picked my kid up that back in the summer one of the other kids had a giant blowout and she cleaned her by hosing her down in the yard.

The third was a day or two after she told my MIL that story. The daycare (it's an in home daycare) had a random inspection from government licensing thing or whatever. I picked up my kid that day and she told me everything went great but the kids were acting out a bit. The next morning (Friday) when my spouse dropped him off the daycare worker told my spouse that one of the other girls was acting out so much during the inspection that as soon as the inspector left she had to take the girl upstairs and spank her.

My kid did not go back on the Monday.

If they do it to someone elses kid. They have or will do it to yours. If they did something to someone elses kid, that you didn't like even if they find someway to justify it so you really want to risk it happening to yours? Start looking elsewhere.

1
Billy_Madison69•

This may not be what you’re looking to hear but I come from a family of teachers and every single one says that putting your kids in a Montessori school is a massive disservice to them and their future. I don’t have any more information.

-5
Ciderinsider86•

I'd assume the new Spanish teacher is just disgruntled and causing trouble. I'm not saying some facsimile of what she alleges didnt happen, but I bet you're getting the hyperbolic version of it. Hell hath no fury like an employee scorned.

Not to play devils advocate, but I've seen this behavior many a time while serving on non-profit boards.

Have fun with the ensuing outrage

-12