For those who think AGI is not coming this decade: Do you disregard everything about Q*?
There's been a lot of discussions lately how we're still far away from AGI. The main points I see people using is that LLMs and transformers are not enough to achieve this. The majority of people agree with this. But if things about Q* are legit, we might already have an algorithm that will lead to AGI and even ASI. The Reuters article, along with Sam Altman referring to it as an unfortunate leak, coupled with the shitshow at OpenAI, pretty much guarantees they have something significant.
I know Q* might turn out to be nothing. But if you believe AGI isn't coming this decade, you'd have to think there were no breakthroughs at OpenAI or any other company for that matter, and you'd also have to believe that no such breakthrough is coming this decade regardless of the insane progress in the last year and tons of money pouring into AI research.
Posted Dec 11, 2023, 7:05 PM UTC
I'm inclined to believe at least some of the Q* star claims, but the truth is, until I have the model in my hands to test it, it won't factor into my predictions.
Yup, all day long. Too much of that whole debacle felt like spin. Q* may be a big deal, may not. We'll see.
Could possibly be a myth created by OpenAI as damage control for the whole firing Sam thing.
IMO it being leaked around the same time as that debacle might've overhyped it - lots of speculation around it until we found out that the debacle was just more mundane board drama
This, do we even know all the details about Q* yet?
It's a leak. Leaks aren't false rumours.
Alright, but how do we even know the leak is credible? IIRC it came out of 4Chan, right?
It was called a leak by sama. If it wasn't based in truth he wouldn't have called it a leak.
Agreed. Trust but verify.
I wouldn’t even trust at this point, tbh. Skeptically follow is more like it.
Meh, I feel like that is a difference in worldview. Trust but verify. VS Verify to trust, where one indicates that most people are not lying, and the other indicates that most people are lying. I suppose in the business world, I tend more toward the latter than the former, so honestly your angle is probably best in this situation.
I specifically believe they are lying about Q.
How can you predct if the only thing you think about is what's currecntly available. That seems counterintuitive.
And how do you separate broader private tech investment, and the public's anticipatory interest in your products, which seems to live and die on the ability to sell basically a plausible dream not yet realized, from hype, lol? The hype may very well be real or justified, I don't think anyone would argue that it can't be, but the only one way of determining that is some kind of credible examination once an actual product materializes. Like idk how anyone can follow tech, any tech at all, for any length of time, and not be generally wary of hype and how it factors into the financial aspect undergirding all of these things. The whole history is littered with far more undelivered or at best only partially delivered promises than it is overt successes, because actually making groundbreaking things that can actually live up to our expectations is really hard, and our wanting them to be real or materialize, for various reasons, biases us towards a hastiness that consistently tends to overlook that.
Too many people/companies have came out and said “We’ve got this amazing thing!! Look at all these amazing things!” then it comes out and it’s meh.
Why should we believe this one?