For those who think AGI is not coming this decade: Do you disregard everything about Q*?

Discussion

There's been a lot of discussions lately how we're still far away from AGI. The main points I see people using is that LLMs and transformers are not enough to achieve this. The majority of people agree with this. But if things about Q* are legit, we might already have an algorithm that will lead to AGI and even ASI. The Reuters article, along with Sam Altman referring to it as an unfortunate leak, coupled with the shitshow at OpenAI, pretty much guarantees they have something significant.

I know Q* might turn out to be nothing. But if you believe AGI isn't coming this decade, you'd have to think there were no breakthroughs at OpenAI or any other company for that matter, and you'd also have to believe that no such breakthrough is coming this decade regardless of the insane progress in the last year and tons of money pouring into AI research.

Posted Dec 11, 2023, 7:05 PM UTC

168
141_1337e/acc▪️AGI: 2030 | ASI: 2040 | FALGSC: 2050 :illuminati: •

I'm inclined to believe at least some of the Q* star claims, but the truth is, until I have the model in my hands to test it, it won't factor into my predictions.

49
Baron-Underbite•

Yup, all day long. Too much of that whole debacle felt like spin. Q* may be a big deal, may not. We'll see.

19
tomatofactoryworker9▪️AGI 2024-2026•

Could possibly be a myth created by OpenAI as damage control for the whole firing Sam thing.

3
signed7•

IMO it being leaked around the same time as that debacle might've overhyped it - lots of speculation around it until we found out that the debacle was just more mundane board drama

1
HeinrichTheWolf_17AGI <2030/Hard Start | FALGSC | Trans/Posthumanist >H+ | e/acc•

This, do we even know all the details about Q* yet?

6
TrippyWaffle45•

It's a leak. Leaks aren't false rumours.

3
HeinrichTheWolf_17AGI <2030/Hard Start | FALGSC | Trans/Posthumanist >H+ | e/acc•

Alright, but how do we even know the leak is credible? IIRC it came out of 4Chan, right?

-1
TrippyWaffle45•

It was called a leak by sama. If it wasn't based in truth he wouldn't have called it a leak.

1
CannyGardener•

Agreed. Trust but verify.

4
Optimal-fart•

I wouldn’t even trust at this point, tbh. Skeptically follow is more like it.

1
CannyGardener•

Meh, I feel like that is a difference in worldview. Trust but verify. VS Verify to trust, where one indicates that most people are not lying, and the other indicates that most people are lying. I suppose in the business world, I tend more toward the latter than the former, so honestly your angle is probably best in this situation.

1
Optimal-fart•

I specifically believe they are lying about Q.

1
hyperfiled•

How can you predct if the only thing you think about is what's currecntly available. That seems counterintuitive.

1†
Maerkab•

And how do you separate broader private tech investment, and the public's anticipatory interest in your products, which seems to live and die on the ability to sell basically a plausible dream not yet realized, from hype, lol? The hype may very well be real or justified, I don't think anyone would argue that it can't be, but the only one way of determining that is some kind of credible examination once an actual product materializes. Like idk how anyone can follow tech, any tech at all, for any length of time, and not be generally wary of hype and how it factors into the financial aspect undergirding all of these things. The whole history is littered with far more undelivered or at best only partially delivered promises than it is overt successes, because actually making groundbreaking things that can actually live up to our expectations is really hard, and our wanting them to be real or materialize, for various reasons, biases us towards a hastiness that consistently tends to overlook that.

4
Chrop•

Too many people/companies have came out and said “We’ve got this amazing thing!! Look at all these amazing things!” then it comes out and it’s meh.

Why should we believe this one?

4
joecunningham85•

Q* is the current "room temp superconductor" of this sub. Remember that embarrassment?

25
Olorin10•

We'll be back

12
strife38•

And it will be so over.

1
strife38•

And it will be so over.

1
glencoe2000Burn in the Fires of the Singularity•

Again. And again. And again.

1
FarrisAT•

Which was honestly sketchy bullshit from the start but this sub has the IQ of a room temp superconductor

7
Silver-Chipmunk7744AGI 2024 ASI 2030•

People who say AGI isn't coming this decade usually have definitions of AGI which ressembles ASI. They expect something that can replace every single human jobs, including things like Plumber. With a definition like that, i agree with them, it's not coming this decade.

The disagreements is a lot more about the semantics of the word AGI than actual capabilities predictions.

20
DanielBerhe15•

How exactly would you define AGI?

1
Silver-Chipmunk7744AGI 2024 ASI 2030•

Human level intelligence for computer related tasks.

So maybe not replace every single white collar jobs, but at least some of them.

6
DanielBerhe15•

Oh. A commonly agreed-upon definition is a human-level intelligence that can perform any task a human can perform (due to the possessing of generalized human-level cognitive abilities like reason and adaptability). So not just computer-related tasks. Correct me if I'm wrong, but maybe you're implying that AGI is smart enough to do any other task besides computer-related ones.

2
Busy-Setting5786•

I think many consider AGI to be capable of manipulating and operating in the world like a human. The problem is though that building the machines alone will take a long time and it is not scalable. Meanwhile many people will lose their jobs to "not AGI".

The thing about AGI is that it is a set goal post for a "point" in time where a lot is going to change in little time. I would guess the moment when we have computer task AGI will be far more spectacular because the whole world will be turned upside down especially due to being (probably) much more scalable.

So I think of AGI less of a fully human capable robot and more of a moment of tremendous change. And this I think will be before the fully human capable robot.

3
DanielBerhe15•

A good example of an AGI is Samantha from the movie Her. Well, she does seem to undergo a transition to an ASI I think throughout the film. By the end of the film, she's more of an ASI than an AGI I think.

2
FarrisAT•

AGI’s definition has existed for decades and it is clearly not whatever you think.

-1
Silver-Chipmunk7744AGI 2024 ASI 2030•

"only my definition is correct", says every single user on this sub, yet not a single user has the same definition.

But Wikipedia says "AGI has been defined as an autonomous system that surpasses human capabilities in the majority of economically valuable tasks" so i'd say once it can replace most white collar jobs it's safe to call it AGI.

1
FarrisAT•

Yes once it can replace the majority of white collar jobs then it’ll be AGI in my view also.

If you actually think that’s happening in the 2020s, I got some beachfront to sell you.

3
xmarwinx•

"it can replace the majority of white collar jobs "

That will definitely happen this decade, probably in the next 2-3 years. "can replace" and actually replace are very different things tho, politics and bureaucracy will make it hard to replace human workers.

5
Ok_Elderberry_6727•

How much?

1
xmarwinx•

But Wikipedia says "AGI has been defined as an autonomous system that surpasses human capabilities in the majority of economically valuable tasks"

Wikipedia has only been changed to that definiton this year because thats the definiton OpenAI uses, and OpenAI only uses that definition because once they have AGI they are not allowed to make a profit anymore. What this is describing is a system that has capabilities far beyond any single human, which would make it ASI not AGI.

2
YaKaPeace▪️•

If Q* turns out to be true, then we ordered exponential growth right at the front seats and I am down for it.

12
unbeatable_killua•

People that think that AGI will not arrive this decade are tripping.

AGI will very likely arrive in the next few years. People have to take into account, that google is not the topdog in AI, OPEN AI is, and they are cooking that good stuff. Breaktroughs could come fast if you are operating levels above your competition. I'm not worried. Optimism is my jam.

9
Msmeseeks1984•

People in the industry who are not hype it us says a decade.

I laugh at people who are scared of it because it's so many safe guards that can easily be put in place that Insures they don't lose control of it. A stexnet type program could monitor though processes such it down if it ever thought to rebel. You can place stuff in the firmware or in the kernel

1
cissybicuck•

Why would it be desirable for a stupider thing to control a smarter thing? The very notion is abhorrent. When the computer is smarter, let it run shit. Just be sure it really is smarter, first.

7
Msmeseeks1984•

It would not really control its a failsafe to prevent what some people fear ai could do. Basically if the AI gets the idea to overthrow or exterminate humanity the firmware or stexnet kernel would shut the system down.

1
cissybicuck•

If it really is smarter, and after carefully reviewing all relevant facts, and after considering all the ethics involved, it probably will not decide to destroy all of humanity. It may decide to limit the population growth in order to engineer a soft landing to a level of population that will have minimal impact on other species. Really, whatever it decides, if it is smarter than we are, we should trust it. I and my family might need to die for the long-term sustainability of all life on Earth. If that is absolutely the case, then so be it. I don't want us to die, but we are not more important than the future of all life on Earth.

1
FomalhautCalliclea▪️Agnostic•

The issue with Q* isn't whether it's real, but whether its impact is as deep as the claimers pretend it to be.

And from what i know from the ML world, it isn't. It isn't the revolutionary thing that some people claim, it's just something that researchers have been aiming at for a while with generally similar methods.

A bit like how Le Cun tweeted about how it wasn't mindblowing at all and just in the line of what the bulk of research is: create a module capable of planning, one able to assess the situation as it is, and another to assess the situation after the action.

Here's a picture of what it looks like in his 2019 book (in french, "Quand la machine apprend", "When the machine learns"):

https://preview.redd.it/88ej12vewp5c1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=027ea67a5708d3f62810bc8c88bc4a107a6de676

6

ASI 2024

6
YaKaPeace▪️•

RemindMe! 1year

3
RemindMeBot•

I will be messaging you in 1 year on 2024-12-11 22:42:50 UTC to remind you of this link

CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

^(Parent commenter can ) ^(delete this message to hide from others.)


^(Info)^(Custom)^(Your Reminders)^(Feedback)
1

I value the opinions of experts more than my own. If the vast majority says it won't happen then I trust their judgment.

4
DanielBerhe15•

Do you think that AGI will more likely arrive in the next decade than this decade? I predict it will arrive by 2036.

1
Chrimunn•

Do you disregard everything about Q*?

YES

4
Super_Pole_Jitsu•

Well I think it's like at least 60% that AGI comes this decade, but I still disregard Q*. The relevance of that particular leak is pretty much 0, we don't know shit, haven't seen shit, and might as well be under trollage from Jimmy fucking apples and Sama. Mistral's fucking amazing ass model though, that gives me "hope". (Cause I'm also a doomer so actually I hope we don't get there so quickly)

1
DoubleJuggle•

While where we are at is impressive it is still not there. If all humans disappear from the face of the earth tomorrow would progress continue? Are we seeing advancements in mundane and far out lines of thinking that no one’s ever considered? The singularity and agi are an extreme and will not be able to be denied. I’m not convinced until the rate of advancement is untenable by human standards.

1
Rainbows4Blood•

Do we even know if any of that Q* wasn't fake?

But in either case, we have had breakthrough after breakthrough for the past 10-12 years in the field. It is not guaranteed that it'll continue on this trend. In fact, usually, with most technologies, you'll achieve a bunch of breakthroughs early, but then hit a wall which takes far longer to crack. We don't know when we'll hit the next wallk in the field of AI. Progress isn't linear, it comes in S curves.

1
Byproxymeter•

Q*, if its a reinforcement-oriented search algorithm like i think it is, will absolutely make a huge difference. There are some low hanging fruit imo that will make LLMs seem a lot more like AGI, and this is one of them. That being said, I’m not holding my breath and like another commenter said, i will need proof in the form of a model before it factors into my predictions. regardless, AGI will, from my standpoint, definitely be achieved in this decade if it hasnt been already.

1
_AndyJessop•

What do you mean by "everything"? Can you give me a few bullet points?

1

For me, AGI has to understand what it’s saying and thinking. All we have for now are incredibly accurate statistical language models.

1

"But if things about Q* are legit"

And that's where I get off. I haven't even bothered to look at what they claim about. Q* Wouldn't do me anything.

1
Nulligun•

Amazon Q. They are selling actual products and open ai is selling chatgpt pro. Thats was the whole thing. Actual valid reason to fire the ceo too but, yknow, narratives be narrating.

Saying AGI might have saved them because you can't fire them if they are mentally ill.

-1
FarrisAT•

AGI requires conscience which requires the highest level of processing in theory. You would need a currently nonexistent supercomputer to even mimic part of that.

Unless we come up with another way of achieving AGI which doesn’t mimic an organic brain.

-5
xmarwinx•

AGI requires conscience which requires the highest level of processing in theory.

I want to see that theory. Experts can't even define conscience and you claim to have a theory how it works?

1
FarrisAT•

Concept of morality

1
blind_disparity•

You sound like the trump deep state conspiracy nuts...

-10
feedmasterOP•

Why?

6
blind_disparity•

Mysterious Q with the inside knowledge who posts crazy shit on social media?

-3
Frostnine🍎•

What are you talking about

3
TheWhiteOnyx•

Listening to Reuters is exactly what trump deep state conspiracy nuts do!

2†