The real Inquisition
nationalreview.com/comment/madden200406181026...Posted Mar 19, 2007, 11:01 AM UTC
Posted Mar 19, 2007, 11:01 AM UTC
The author, Thomas F. Madden, focuses his research on being a christian crusades apologist.
Interestingly, he simultaneously slags Bill Clinton for speculating about religious retribution in the September 11 attacks ...
Clinton: "Terror-the killing of noncombatants for economic, political, or religious reasons-has a very long history, as long as organized combat itself. . . . Those of us who come from various European lineages are not blameless. Indeed, in the first Crusade, ..."
Madden: "(T)he fashionable but nonetheless contemptible assertion that people today ("those of us who come from various European lineages") are responsible for what other people did in the distant past ..."
and defends the crusades as a retribution for Arab empire building in Asia Minor that had started 3 centuries earlier.
According to this source,
Not until 1808, during the brief reign of Joseph Bonaparte, was the Inquisition abolished in Spain. An estimated 31,912 heretics were burned at the stake, 17,659 were burned in effigy and 291,450 made reconciliations in the Spanish Inquisition.
"...only about 1 percent of those brought before the Spanish Inquisition were actually executed."
I think even one single person was too much.
Well, yes. But the inquisition didn't execute them, it merely turned them over to the secular authorities - which is where they would have been in the first place if it wasn't for the inquisition. The secular authorities in the middle ages weren't very secular, religious dissent was seen as a threat to the stability of the nation (sort of reasonable, if you know what they fought over those days) and as a direct threat as they thought it would incur divine anger if unpunished (not that reasonable, but not suprising either, if you've read the OT/Hebrew Bible). The popes were a bit more enlightened.
For people who lived during those times, religion was not something one did just at church. It was science, philosophy, politics, identity, and hope for salvation. It was not a personal preference but an abiding and universal truth.
this religiosity has been replaced, in the modern western world, with nationalism and the "rule of law." so if those who break, or are accused of breaking, modern laws are equated with those who broke canonical law during the Inquisition, and the 2004 arrest rate in, say, the U.S. was over fourteen million, and one percent of those were executed as per the Inquisition, there would have been one hundred and forty thousand executions, just in the U.S., in 2004. this, however, isn't weighted for multiple arrests of the same person but it sure makes for a fine polemic against those who say the Inquisition was a trifle.
The Catholic Church investigating The Inquisition. Gimme a break. Someone investigating themself doesnt have an interest in finding out the truth.
HAte to go all Godwin, but replace "Inquisition" with "Holocaust" and you've got some of the usual Holocaust-denier rationalizations. "Things were bad all over"
"It was a smaller percentage of the population than you think"
"There was a war on" etcetera... I remain skeptical.