Theory: Lost From Light translates to Chain Breaker

Theory

The actual connection between True Names and Fate aren't really elaborated on in most cases; we know of 2 of them specifically. Those being, Changing Star = Star of Ruin and Song of the Fallen = doomed to watch as humanity is fated to perish before dying herself (probably. Her visions showed the date and time of her own death, if I remember correctly).

We know that fire can translate to light, or the sun, or similar concepts, but I also suspect that Lost From can translate to Free From or Slayer Of, I don't have any real supporting evidence other than "it feels right" and that both of these concepts are inextricably connected to Sunny's aspect - he's the successor of Shadow, it makes sense that his Fate is tied to using his "authorities." (I use the quotes because he's a Saint, he doesn't have any real authority over death or freedom yet even though he likely will at end of book.) But I do think that there aren't any other concepts that really tie into Lost From like that.

This also ties into that vision Cassie had at the beginning. Do we really think a sleeper could change that, or that Nephis falling into total darkness really counts as a hungry shadow devouring the sun? I think that prophecy only got cancelled when Sunny got severed from his fate. His True Name, then, could be alluding to how he is the only shadow who would kill his own master - the Light Slayer (not the same as Revel), the Shadow who is free from the Sun, etc. Hence, the Chain Breaker, who would free those, including himself, from their chains, even the ones that they want.

But what got me actually thinking about this is the end of the 3rd nightmare. In chapter 1571, Sunny looks at the mural of what really happened at the end of the Void War. In the ancient stories, all we previously knew is that the gods used their weapons and laws to seal the Void. But here, it's actively described as a net of golden flame. The gods are described as radiant, but only this net is described as aflame.

So I think Lost From Light will end up freeing Dream. This might actually be the real reason why Weaver's giving Sunny so many OP buffs and skewing the nature of his power towards the Dream bloodline. It's because Weaver found a Fate that is actually capable of slaying the fire of chains and freeing his tortured parent, and wanted to manipulate that Fate in that direction.

Now that Sunny lost his fate, who knows what will happen? Maybe Weaver's the biggest liar of all time and Sunny didn't actually lose his fate. Maybe Sunny will take his fate back. Maybe Sunny/Cassie actually succeeded at breaking Fate. Maybe this entire theory is about to be nuked by the author, wouldn't be the first time that's happened. But I do think that this makes the most sense about what Sunny's True Name and original Fate actually meant.

Posted Feb 9, 2025, 6:44 PM UTC

769

Comments aren't archived yet

This post had 9 comments on Reddit. Comments for this period haven't been loaded into the archive yet.