What should have been a clear night started off with a few clouds, but quickly turned completely overcast. So this is what I managed.
The clouds created a few interesting effects. In the green channels especially, brighter stars ended up surrounded by a glow that I wasn't able to get rid of in processing. That gave me a weird 'rainbow' in the center of the Lagoon itself.
I tried processing this in PixInsight, but didn't have much luck. I was VERY impressed by how well the software merged my subframes considering how widely they differed in SNR and intensity. And they dynamic background extraction did an incredible job. But when I tried to bring the Lagoon's central brightness down with wavelets, the stars all generated awful black rings. I tried to generate a mask to keep that from happening, but never managed it.
In the end I went with Photoshop's "Highlights and Shadows". A little sharpening here and there might be nice, but I just couldn't find a way to do it that didn't trash things. If anyone else would like to try (especially with PixInsight), I'd love to see how things go with that!
With this image, I went with pure RGB. No luminance, no binning. I've started to run a focusing routine during my imaging, and the results are very promising so far. My stars are smaller and tighter than ever! Hopefully I'll get a clear night to run a better test sometime soon.
Frames were 5 minutes each. Before the sky clouded over I got 9 reds, 5 greens and 5 blues... but maybe 4 per channel were actually useable.
This was taken with a FLI Proline 16803 camera on a Takahashi TOA130 refractor, mounted on a beastly Paramount MEII mount (I love the thing, but if I don't get it a permanent home soon, it WILL ruin my back forever).
When I'm at home it lives on a wheeley bar, but I live in a white zone so I can only really manage narrowband from here. For color, I've got to go traveling.
I'm working on putting together a mobile observatory; something I can hitch to the back of a truck and drive out to the middle of nowhere. It should be fantastic when it's done, for imaging and outreach. But it'll be a few more months at last.
Yeah, I'll try it in PixInsight if you want. Feel free to either post a dropbox link or PM me a dropbox link for the stacked file - I'm assuming it's a stack of 4 each. You could also upload all 19 if you want, depending on your internet.
I think you used the Deconvolution step, based on your comment about the black rings. I get that with that process also. I haven't mastered it yet, it's a difficult process to learn, so it's not part of my arsenal. I'd probably have used Curves Transformation to bring it down, or maybe use Pixel Math to add a Range Selection mask (Atrous Wavelets to it to blur) to a Star Mask for a usable mask before using Curves Transformation.
I used this tutorial, starting at the multi scale layer processing step, on my Andromeda Galaxy. It also shows how to use Pixel Math like I mentioned above to create a nice mask. I really like how it brings out the color and detail, but the clouds may be interefering with yours.
I've posted the raw 3-channel FIT here. As you can see, the image was in some serious need of some color balancing.
The only real processing I did was a dynamic background extraction, SCNR to remove the green glow from around the brighter stars, and noise reduction with ATrousWaveletTransform.
I'd wanted to use ATrous (or even UnsharpMask) to sharpen the nebula details, but both procedures gave me those awful black rings around my stars. I wasn't able to create a mask that would keep that from happening. The tutorial you linked seems like it has some tips in that direction, so I might give that a try... but in the mean time, I'd love to see what you come up with from this! (Or anyone else who wants to try, for that matter).
Deconvolution is something I'd love to learn, but I've never managed to get the parameters quite right to produce an improvement. Maybe someday!
Thanks, downloaded it, it might take me a day or two, work has been busy lately and my bathroom remodel is behind schedule (wife not happy about that). I'll probably do it tomorrow night. I'll repost here.
I've never had black rings using Atrous, interesting. My problem with Atrous is that I get blotchy backgrounds when I go overboard on the noise reduction. I usually use a luminance mask, clipped to make it a little brighter. Yeah, deconvolutin is on my to-do list but I need to set some time aside to learn it.
Ok. Here is the dropbox link to the processed fit file. It's taking about 5 minutes to upload, so give it a five minutes from this posting uploaded. Let me know if it won't download, you should be able to just left click on the link and it should auto-download.
Here is the imgur version for quick viewing while you download the fit file.
I don't think you needed to crop it at all, I like that red part at the top. The colors did need some balancing, there was a gradient that was removed with DBE, and I used SCNR to remove the green cast which wasn't so bad after the histogram was balanced. I then separated out the nebula from the stars using Pixel Math and worked on the nebula a little, bringing up the saturation and colors and stretching the histogram a few times, then recombining them using Pixel Math. I also used HDR once on the core to bring it down a little. I did go a little overboard on the saturation of the nebula, and dialed back a bit. I liked this version, but you may think it's still oversaturated, YMMV.
Overall, I think it's a great image. You've got some great detail in there, and I'd kill for that equipment. It was actually pretty easy to process given the equipment. I'd frame it if it was mine.
Thanks for giving me something to do on a cloudy night!
Accuweather lied to me!
What should have been a clear night started off with a few clouds, but quickly turned completely overcast. So this is what I managed.
The clouds created a few interesting effects. In the green channels especially, brighter stars ended up surrounded by a glow that I wasn't able to get rid of in processing. That gave me a weird 'rainbow' in the center of the Lagoon itself.
I tried processing this in PixInsight, but didn't have much luck. I was VERY impressed by how well the software merged my subframes considering how widely they differed in SNR and intensity. And they dynamic background extraction did an incredible job. But when I tried to bring the Lagoon's central brightness down with wavelets, the stars all generated awful black rings. I tried to generate a mask to keep that from happening, but never managed it.
In the end I went with Photoshop's "Highlights and Shadows". A little sharpening here and there might be nice, but I just couldn't find a way to do it that didn't trash things. If anyone else would like to try (especially with PixInsight), I'd love to see how things go with that!
With this image, I went with pure RGB. No luminance, no binning. I've started to run a focusing routine during my imaging, and the results are very promising so far. My stars are smaller and tighter than ever! Hopefully I'll get a clear night to run a better test sometime soon.
Frames were 5 minutes each. Before the sky clouded over I got 9 reds, 5 greens and 5 blues... but maybe 4 per channel were actually useable.
What sort of setup were you using? (scope, camera, mount, etc?)
Ah! Sorry about that.
This was taken with a FLI Proline 16803 camera on a Takahashi TOA130 refractor, mounted on a beastly Paramount MEII mount (I love the thing, but if I don't get it a permanent home soon, it WILL ruin my back forever).
I'll <cough> give it a permanent home. :)
Have you thought about using a wheeley bar? Might make it easier to move around if you can't get it a permanent home right away.
When I'm at home it lives on a wheeley bar, but I live in a white zone so I can only really manage narrowband from here. For color, I've got to go traveling.
I'm working on putting together a mobile observatory; something I can hitch to the back of a truck and drive out to the middle of nowhere. It should be fantastic when it's done, for imaging and outreach. But it'll be a few more months at last.
Yeah, I'll try it in PixInsight if you want. Feel free to either post a dropbox link or PM me a dropbox link for the stacked file - I'm assuming it's a stack of 4 each. You could also upload all 19 if you want, depending on your internet.
I think you used the Deconvolution step, based on your comment about the black rings. I get that with that process also. I haven't mastered it yet, it's a difficult process to learn, so it's not part of my arsenal. I'd probably have used Curves Transformation to bring it down, or maybe use Pixel Math to add a Range Selection mask (Atrous Wavelets to it to blur) to a Star Mask for a usable mask before using Curves Transformation.
I used this tutorial, starting at the multi scale layer processing step, on my Andromeda Galaxy. It also shows how to use Pixel Math like I mentioned above to create a nice mask. I really like how it brings out the color and detail, but the clouds may be interefering with yours.
I like this image, though. Nice job!
I've posted the raw 3-channel FIT here. As you can see, the image was in some serious need of some color balancing.
The only real processing I did was a dynamic background extraction, SCNR to remove the green glow from around the brighter stars, and noise reduction with ATrousWaveletTransform.
I'd wanted to use ATrous (or even UnsharpMask) to sharpen the nebula details, but both procedures gave me those awful black rings around my stars. I wasn't able to create a mask that would keep that from happening. The tutorial you linked seems like it has some tips in that direction, so I might give that a try... but in the mean time, I'd love to see what you come up with from this! (Or anyone else who wants to try, for that matter).
Deconvolution is something I'd love to learn, but I've never managed to get the parameters quite right to produce an improvement. Maybe someday!
Thanks, downloaded it, it might take me a day or two, work has been busy lately and my bathroom remodel is behind schedule (wife not happy about that). I'll probably do it tomorrow night. I'll repost here.
I've never had black rings using Atrous, interesting. My problem with Atrous is that I get blotchy backgrounds when I go overboard on the noise reduction. I usually use a luminance mask, clipped to make it a little brighter. Yeah, deconvolutin is on my to-do list but I need to set some time aside to learn it.
Ok. Here is the dropbox link to the processed fit file. It's
taking about 5 minutes to upload, so give it a five minutes from this postinguploaded. Let me know if it won't download, you should be able to just left click on the link and it should auto-download.Here is the imgur version for quick viewing while you download the fit file.
I don't think you needed to crop it at all, I like that red part at the top. The colors did need some balancing, there was a gradient that was removed with DBE, and I used SCNR to remove the green cast which wasn't so bad after the histogram was balanced. I then separated out the nebula from the stars using Pixel Math and worked on the nebula a little, bringing up the saturation and colors and stretching the histogram a few times, then recombining them using Pixel Math. I also used HDR once on the core to bring it down a little. I did go a little overboard on the saturation of the nebula, and dialed back a bit. I liked this version, but you may think it's still oversaturated, YMMV.
Overall, I think it's a great image. You've got some great detail in there, and I'd kill for that equipment. It was actually pretty easy to process given the equipment. I'd frame it if it was mine.
Thanks for giving me something to do on a cloudy night!