r/Thief•
dashaaa

Never played a Thief game. Where should I start?

I'm a longtime PC gamer, and while I remember when the Thief games were released, I never played them. Now I'm thinking that I should start. Where should I start? Old graphics are not a problem for me, but dated gameplay and mechanics could be annoying (unless there is a community fix for all that).

Posted Oct 12, 2013, 11:36 PM UTC

512
Inimitable•

Thief Gold and/or Thief 2. You can get them from Steam or GOG (I'd recommend GOG).

I also recommend using the NewDark updates:

TFix (for Thief Gold)

and for Thief 2

10
dashaaaOP•

Thanks. I'll check it out.

1
[deleted]•

Start from the beginning. After modifying the controls in the options to be a bit more modern, the mechanics shouldn't feel too dated. The originals aren't even that expensive from Steam, especially if you pick it up on a seasonal sale.

But I can't think of a good reason to play it in any other order than from Thief: The Dark Project (or Thief Gold) and then Thief 2 followed by Thief Deadly Shadows.

9
Ecorin•

I started with Thief 2 first and when I tried to play Thief Gold, it was really hard to get used to, because it was more dated and the controls were a bit more iffy.

So I suggest you start from the beginning. After you've played through Thief Gold, you'll see the vast improvements once you start with Thief 2.

3
JokerFaces2•

I agree. I enjoyed Thief Gold but I was often frustrated, not knowing where to go and the controls were iffy. Thief 2 was, therefore, an extremely enjoyable experience since they tweaked many things.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
GeorgeTheCynic•

If you're new to stealth games in general too, I'd start with Deadly Shadows. The levels there are pretty straightforward,simple, and more forgiving, but you'll get the feel of Thief and will be ready for Thief 1 and 2. Thief 1 and 2 can have really complex objectives with huge confusing levels, so it can be really overwhelming to new players.

If you're used stealth games already, try it in order (Dark Project/Gold, Metal age, Deadly shadows).

1
BadWhippet•

I started with Thief Deadly Shadows (Thief 3) about a year ago. I LOVED it and have replayed it many times, but it makes the first two seem so dated that I cannot even get into them, which is a pity. They were only cheap (from gog.com) but I can't get anywhere with them - even with the mods. I guess that's what I get for starting with the last in the series.

1
dakkster•

You should REALLY try your hardest to get over the age of Thief 2. That game is a goddamn masterpiece and you won't regret getting over the hump.

2
GarrettTheThief•

I am the odd-man out but I'm going to suggest going with The Dark Mod first. You want your first experience with this series to be fun and not one where you're having to wrestle with a game designed for older machines on an older engine that hates multi-core machines. After that, play the series as normal.

1
dashaaaOP•

I don't think anyone will be having performance issues with this game though.

3
GarrettTheThief•

I just remember Thief Gold and II were a bitch to try to get running when I originally upgraded my computer with a multi-core processor and Windows Vista back in 2006. I don't know, do the Steam and GOG versions fix that? (Not that it matters to me since I still have my decade-old CD's still working fine for me.)

3
dashaaaOP•

I bought it on Steam and I'm seeing no issues so far with Thief Gold. I did use TFix though.

2