D3VO_Lution•

Three weeks later, Professor Jonathan "Good Guy" Smith was arrested and charged with 334 counts of copyright infringement. He is survived by his wife, two children, and 334 disgruntled students. In lieu of flowers, the family requests that donations be made to the Textbook Deprived Students of America League (TDSAL).

248
Decyde•

This actually happened to me sort of. I typed up very great notes that were pretty much spot on for the professors exams. I emailed them to about 90% of the class and quite a few people paid me for them.

The professor tried to actually go as far as claiming copyright infringement because of it. After that, I MLA format cited everything and emailed it to the entire class. He was pretty pissed off and the dean just laughed at me when I was called back in there.

Also, the professor got a % of the book sales which was why he was pissed off about it.

42
aurochal•

At least at my school, professors were not allowed to require their own book for the class. If they did, their share of royalties went to the department rather than them personally.

Shameless self-promotion and encouraging us to buy the book was perfectly fine, though.

11
chrisd93•

My diff eq professor has his own notes, but he provides them free of charge, saving me about $300

7
Decyde•

This professor was NOT in any way affiliated with any materials in the text book. It turned out that he was getting a % of the book sale of a different book for years and that was why he was pissed.

I don't' remember who the publishing company was but that book cost $190 new and they published a new edition about every quarter. They were the exact same content wise with MAYBE 1 new paragraph added.

They mostly changed the order of the chapters.

The funniest professor I had made us read 1 chapter in a book. The book authors actually let him add like 1 paragraph to the book and that was all we talked about for 2 hours a night, 2 days a week. It was a very easy A.

5
ITALIANCOLOGNE•

Why the hell is it an accepted practice to get royalties from the book publishers? THis basically encourages corruption and bribery. Who thought this was a good idea? The US university book sector is completely fucked up. As somebody who studies in Europe and has to pay as much for an economics book as for my whole university career (no kidding) this kind of drives me nuts. 200 dollar for a book who basically just covers basic topics is crazy. No wonder why nobody buy them and copies every page in the library to share it with classmates.

1
aurochal•

Of all people involved in publishing a textbook, you don't think the people who wrote the damn thing are the ones who deserve to get paid for their work?

Granted, the textbook publishing industry is a huge racket, but the few dollars a professor gets from each $200 book is hardly the problem.

2
Disastrously_Dazed•

hey buddy what school do you go to? You know, for science.

4
CapAWESOMEst•

MU

4
rickscarf•

Monsters University? or Mizzou?

5
Decyde•

I graduate 2 years ago. I also "helped" write papers for money ;p

Funniest one about that was 10 people told me they were going to write their ethics paper themselves. It was 25 pages long and annoying as hell to write.

The professor passed back the papers during an exam and stopped and shook my hand because it was the best paper he ever read. Not shitting you, it was pretty much his 4 books cited with MAYBE 2 sentences tops between each citation. I knew that would make him give me an instant A because he was so full of himself and his ethical process.

Because of what he did, I had about 17 people pay me to proofread their papers and help them out. Every paper read almost the exact same and he loved reading each and every one of them.

2
CubbyRed•

Most universities prohibit payment for notes, be careful if you do this again as it can lead to expulsion.

3
Decyde•

This was more of a thank you and money. There was no talk of an exchange money for notes.

1
paleo2002•

When I was in school there was a well-respected notes-taking service near campus. They would hire students to take immaculate notes for large, popular classes and then sell the note packets. Of course, this was in the mid-90's before the IP/copyright craze.

Also, I'm not sure lectures and lecture notes can be claimed by individuals under copyright. Either the school's policies declare that class material is school property or lectures are basically considered publicly accessible.

2
randogen•

Depends on the country, in Canada a professor owns all of their material. It's actually the big thing that prevents universities from firing a prof after they develop a course and giving their material to a first year prof to teach it.

1
Decyde•

That's what I argued but the professor claimed they could be and I should be in trouble for it. When I pressed him on why he really gave a damn, he wouldn't agree.

When I asked him if he was receiving royalties from the book being sold and asked if that was why he was very pissed off. He started bringing up expulsion and everything else and I just looked at the Dean and apologized for what I had did.

On my second trip in there, the Dean looked at my notes and told that professor he had 0 reason to be upset. Any issues he had before were gone because everything was properly MLA cited and the notes were written in a report format.

It was a bit cleaver because it read like a report with a cover page and introduction page and even had a concluding page and works cited. I told people if they didn't care about that, just print off pages 3-18.

They liked it more because the footer included the page where the citation was from and it was easier to look up.

1
hansjens47•

It's okay. I got something for free rather than paying for it. Good guy Professor!

36
[deleted]•

He should of just made them aware that there is an online version. He shouldn't have been the dealer but more of the I know a guy guy

0†
school_o_fart•

I do this. I either show them much cheaper options or tell them to add PDF when searching for a text. The things you find...

1
godredditor•

And that's why we need Requeddit:

http://www.scribd.com/doc/186532585/Requeddit/

-1
Skuller•

haha the subtle thing is that his arrest and charge led to his death....

-6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
hansjens47•

Hopefully he found a legal version.

54
dangles14OP•

He did. I'm sure we could have found it on our own but it's a very nice gesture nonetheless.
EDIT: For clarification: I was sent a link that reads like an e-book.

41
hansjens47•

That's awesome. It's more than a nice gesture, there's always someone who doesn't think of looking for it online.

5
Vik1ng•

Might have been a system like http://link.springer.com/ which the university actually pays for. Were you able to access it off-campus?

3
dangles14OP•

Yeah I can open it out of my school email account.

1
iWriteBadPoems•

Do you go to laguardia by any chance? I think we might have the same professor.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
enzlow•

As a textbook author, I can assure you that if you did not pay for your copy, it's illegal. And you may think your professor is doing you a favor, but really he is putting you and your classmates in serious risk. While I agree that some textbooks are overpriced, straight up stealing someone's work is wrong and against the law. Shame on your professor for doing the wrong thing and putting his students in danger.

If you think that textbook pricing is ridiculous, I agree. The thing is, it is neither the Author's or Publishing companies fault. The cause of high prices is the used book market...

If I were you I would do the right thing and buy a legal copy of the book and encourage your professor to stop. Because you are accessing this text through a link, that is being tracked. You better believe that publishing companies pay people to track this kind of illegal behavior down.

-24
WorkoutProblems•

As a former student, fuck you textbook author and companies!

17
SchrodingersRapist•

As a current student, I feel they can take their overpriced books and shove them up their asses.

4
enzlow•

Fuck me for trying to make a living? No, fuck you and your entitled attitude. I work my ass off to write books and instead of you respecting that, you want me to hand over all of my hard work for free. How about I come around your place and steal your hard work...

-10
Justice-Solforge•

I was with you up until you tried the pathetic scare tactic of "we'll come after you and you'll get in trouble!"

Students will not get in trouble for this. If the publishing company "tracks this down", the most they will do is send a C&D takedown letter to whoever is hosting the illegal material and shut down the link itself. 0% chance they go through the enormous cost and trouble of suing the students.

6
enzlow•

Tell that to the people sitting in jail for this stuff...

-12
ArchAengelus•

The cause of high prices is the used book market...

I would state that if that's true, you've just described a catch-22. and possibly some failures to read the books they publish.

See, the reason students buy used textbooks, is because new ones are so absurdly overpriced (and so are the used ones, tbh), that it is more economically feasible to buy used ones that are the same product at a lower cost. Why would anyone pay more? From an economic perspective, it is a competing product that is nearly indistinguishable except for wear and use.

College Textbook publishers have it made. While I don't have ready access to production costs or royalties per copy, I can say with relative certainty that a 400-page hard-cover college chemistry book is sold at a several thousand percent markup, and some stores have even higher markups, like at college bookstores, compared to their competitors online. In order to capitalize on this captive market, there can be no competition from an online seller that sells the books at a reasonable markup. Therefore, all sellers of the new books sell them at approximately the same price. This is the supply side of the market.

Many students do not care if their textbook lasts them the rest of their lives, and want to recoup the cost of the item less the value they obtained from it. Some will trade it to their classmates for equivalent goods (other textbooks they need), while others don't have access to such a good barter, and will sell them to an online purchaser, their local college bookstore, or those guys who come to college campuses in vans to buy them for a pittance of their value. The van people, who buy a $200 texbook for $15, will then sell it back to the college bookstore for $120 for a "used" textbook. This is a wonderful profit motivator for them, so in the spirit of competition, many of these companies have sprung up, and become extremely organized groups, with warehouses moving books around to campuses across the country (especially in the U.S.). Several of my friends in college worked at these warehouses, and had no idea how much profit the companies were making.

If the publishers make the books more expensive to cover the loss of sales to used books (as they have done for the last 15 years), the resellers can then sell the used texbooks for more, and buy them for the same price (from the desparate or lazy students who sell at the vans), creating a larger profit, and therefore an even bigger market for used books. By continually raising their prices they have created a situation where buying a new book is economically the worst case scenario for the student.

Piracy of textbooks is not as common as one might think, as it is very hard to get the original content in electronic form, and only the most resourceful internet pirates ever find all their textbooks online, as many of the books I used in college were fairly obscure engineering textbooks. One very rarely finds a PDF of the right version of a textbook. When one does, they share it with their classmates, many of whom have already purchased the book, so there is no lost sale.

Textbook publishers have found some solutions to compensate for "lost sales" resulting from a booming used book market, which do make them more money. Two of them are:

  1. Make new versions of the books every year. This works very well, especially when example problem numbers change and chapters get moved around, forcing people to buy the new book, making the publisher a hefty profit, with minimal effort on behalf of the publishers.

  2. Charge more for the new textbook, since it is going to be recirculated for N years anyway.

The first option does a very good job of generating revenue, so many publishers have resorted to that for big name books for freshman intro classes, but all of the publishers have used number two, which creates the mindset of a capital investment.

I am no expert (I was an engineer in college, so take anything I say with salt). My best perceived solution is to propose the preposterous solution of creating textbooks that are cheap, like $30-40. This would severely limit the profit per investment in the used book market, and incentivize students to buy the new books, because they are readily available. It could also open the market to non-college students who are interested in the topic and choose not to pay for credit hours.

EDIT: I hate the enter key.

2
enzlow•

You sir/ma'am at least understand what is going on here... However there are a few elements I would like to introduce to you.

First of all, the textbooks I have authored are not marked up thousands of percents... My books (600-1000 pages) sell for around $100. Once you take the production costs, the editorial and testing costs, taxes, and author's royalty out, the publishing company is making no more than 15% of that $100.

Then, when that book is bought by a guy in a van for $10 and then sold for $90 the publishing company and author get 0%. The guy in the van gets $80. Then next quarter he makes $70, and so on. The total the author and publishing company made from that one book is under $30, while the guy in the van probably netted more than $250. THAT alone is the reason why new editions are always being created... They get their own ISBN number even though the differences are negligible. This is also why textbooks are being combined with one-time use things like access to a web service.

Used text books aside, the other factor driving the price of books is how publishing companies sell their products. The big companies like Cengage and Pearson have put a lot into the sales department. They generally have large sales forces that will offer to send your professor off to a 'workshop' in Las Vegas for a week. So, while your professor went with a textbook that is $300 per, he/she gets to go to Las Vegas and party for a week and you get to foot the bill. Sending educators on vacations like that is a common sales practice and generally costs a lot of money. All of that money is generated by charging $300 a book. My publishing company isn't big enough to use this tactic, which is partially the reason why the prices on our books is pretty competitive.

Also consider the roles of the individuals involved in the sale... There is the person selling (publishing company salesperson), the buying decision maker (professor who doesn't actually have to pay for the book) and the payer (student who has no choice in what book is used but has to pay the price). As you can see, the price of a textbook might be outweighed by the benefit of going to Las Vegas for a week because the educator isn't PAYING for the book.

The bottom line is that there is not a lot the publishing company can do to stop the used book gremlins from taking advantage of them and the content creators. If for example the guy in the van had to pay a percent to the publishing company and author, that would constitute a more fair allocation of profit. This would make new books cheaper and used books even cheaper. Everyone would win. Unfortunately I don't see that happening and so companies like Barnes and Noble are generating a hoard of cash while I'm barely making enough to scrape by.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ZombieBarney•

He found an open source one, right on the Pirate Bay. Heard that's where all the open source books are nowadays.

2
retardedwombat•

A legal download of an otherwise expensive book? Right... This guy shouldn't be teaching, he should be behind bars. What's next: 'my professor robbed a hooker to give us money to buy beer'?

-25
toastymow•

I had a professor create his own textbook and upload it to a website hosted by a colleague of his from another university. I had other professors point out all our readings where in public domain (ahh the joys of reading medieval texts), and I had another point out that our textbook was available via PDF from the school website.

Lots of it can be done legally. Lots of it can be done properly. Don't assume that it had to be illegal.

11
retardedwombat•

It was only a rhetorical question

-8
toastymow•

I'm pretty sure I did not directly respond to your question. I merely pointed out that its possible to provide free textbooks without violating copyright laws.

5
firedrops•

The last time I taught intro to cultural anthropology I assigned an ethnography that students could access for free via their library site. But it was a little confusing to get to so I made sure to send out a link so they knew they didn't have to pay for it. There are actually a number of books available for free to read online (no downloading - annoying format but free?) through many university library services.

2
Vemii•

"No can't do that, see it's not the right version! The newer one has a COLORED picture on page 587. This is not acceptable, you need to have the new one!"

40
Drsnuggles87•

I had a scumbag Professor who updated his book, which was a requirement for the class and cost about 90 bucks + 70 for the advanced book(also required), every year in such a fucked up way so 2000+ students had to buy it every year

7
Lancaster1983•

That would be a great Scumbag Teacher meme.

2
SixSpeedDriver•

That's been beaten to death, actually.

4
FUCKING_HATE_REDDIT•

The horse is never quite dead enough.

5
ShawnSaturday•

Nothing ever really dies on the internet.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
heyyo129•

And then you have this problem.

12
reoll•

If you're already that deep in, you might as well download Adobe Acrobat Pro and apply OCR so you can search through it.

4
flint_mi•

Can you tell me a little more about this?

1
AtlantaFalcon•

OCR stands for optical character recognition. I'm not an expert, but since nobody has replied to you yet, I'll give it a go. This past semester my English professor gave us PDFs to read for various assignments. I couldn't search them with CTRL+F or highlight individual words though because she just scanned them. A simple scanner won't be able to recognize individual characters--just the copy as a whole.

Thankfully, my school's computers have Adobe Acrobat Pro on them, so I just altered the files there. I just entered into Google something like, "make PDF searchable," and I found some step-by-step instructions on how to convert the PDF file using OCR within Acrobat Pro.

3
flint_mi•

Awesome. I'm looking to save some money this semester by downloading the books, rather than buying them (if I could be so lucky). I haven't searched for any of them yet, but I'm sure I'll run into a few "non-searchable" PDF's. Thanks for the info.

2
scubsurf•

I had a professor once who, on the first day of class, handed out our syllabi, and and then said, "Alright! Who bought the textbooks already?"

A few people raised their hands. I had bought them but didn't raise my hand because I was 3edgy4that.

Then he said, "well, you wasted your money. Go return them after class if you can."

Then he paused and turned to walk over to the blackboard, giving everyone a minute to look at each other like "dafuq?"

He wrote the web address to some file-sharing site and proceeded to say, "I have uploaded here every book that I use for this class. You can go to this website if you want the texts for free. If you don't want to print out a bunch of piss-poor scans of the texts, then instead of buying what I put in the syllabus, go to abe.com and buy [xyz]. The books will each be about a dollar on that website. The administration here forces us to use updated versions of each text, even though it is totally and entirely frivolous, due, in part, to a contract they have with the book store and some of the publishers. Also listed in the syllabus is my book. You can buy that if you want to, but don't buy it for this class, you won't need it, but if I see you pretending to read it and look interested I might give you extra credit."

This same professor, later in the quarter, canceled class one day during the student protests (related to tuition increases) and gave us all credit for whatever would have been assigned that day, gave anyone permission to leave that wanted to, and spent the rest of the class period talking to us about why students were protesting and why we should all be pissed off about what had been going on at the time. He also told us he would be joining the protests after class and that any of us who were free were welcome to join him.

He was a pretty fucking cool guy.

8
LaMoula•

Sounds like something a Political Science teacher in Quebec would do.

2
scubsurf•

Honestly, I thought the same thing at the time, but he was a Literature professor teaching a course on the study of science fiction.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
scubsurf•

The used market drives up the cost of new textbooks.

Not sure I agree on that one.

Sure, it reduces demand that isn't artificially enforced, which in turn reduces supply which ultimately increases price, but that's kind of backwards.

The used market should reduce the cost, as they adjust pricing to compete with used. Instead, used is viewed as losses by default, so they increase prices to make up for the losses.

Any system in which an increased supply and increased competition results in an increased price is a broken system that is failing to adapt to its environment. Yes, they are still raking in money for now, but these kinds of issues will drive the motivation for innovation or legislation, and either one is far more likely to upset their market than simply adjusting their pricing to meet the environment at hand.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
scubsurf•

While you've got a point, I work in copy editing/graphic design/printing.

I can't speak to the costs involved in publishing textbooks, because I would imagine there are all kinds of overhead that I wouldn't even know about. I can tell you that a ~250 page 8 1/2" x 11" high quality color spread with hard bindings does not cost $300 dollars in materials, nor do I think that it would amount to that including distribution costs.

They can only go down so much, sure, I accept that, however I think it is less a case of prohibition by expenses and more a case that they are afraid to injure their profit margins.

1
WhatLawSchool•

My law professor just did this on a $350 book. He's amazing.

6
Freek1N•

Can I have the link?

-4†
WhatLawSchool•

It's an internal link. He downloaded it then uploaded it to the school site for our class

2
steven-glansberg•

Isn't there already a meme for good guy profs?

6
dynamitedolemite•

The college I attend here in CA has special school editions of the textbooks that include extra chapters/assignments. This prevents students from buying online/renting and forces us to go through the school's campus bookstore. This infuriates me because this is at a community college where students are obviously trying to keep their costs down.

4
naeve•

Fuck that noise. Download the original editions if you can find them, and photocopy whatever extra chapters/assignments weren't included in the library (where texts are usually placed on reserves).

My school used to have these magical machines. So whenever I couldn't download a textbook, I would sit at the library for maybe an hour tops, photocopying the chapters mentioned in the syllabus into a scannable PDF. Having a scannable version of your textbook is a real lifesaver for online quizzes/assignments, too. In my last two years of college, I think I only bought a textbook once, and that was only because it was $5.

3
dynamitedolemite•

my school has found a magical way around this, they put tear-out work book pages in the books so there aren't any used copies available, the important pages are torn out so the library does not "buy-back" used books at the end of the semester. also, they have a librarian monitoring the 2 copy machines available, and they are sure to remind you of copyright laws and threaten to report you to the dean if you are caught. Los Angeles education system at its finest. For an introvert like myself, its not so easy to approach random classmates to photo copy their books either, especially when you would need to take said books off campus to copy them. They have us all figured out.

2
Puppysmasher•

If you are in LA there are asian places you can go that will just copy a textbook for you. Copyright can suck it when it comes to textbooks.

4
kmpdx•

Dude. I chopped the spine off books, ran them through the top-feed scanners, PDF'ed them as chapters. I shared them with other students and then I 3-hole punched them and sold it cheap on Craigslist. It was a sort of civil disobedience to screw the book companies at the the above-mentioned fuckery pulled by switching problems, parts of chapters, etc. The "school" version is also a scam. They remove two chapters to "save students money", thus disallowing selling/buying the book on a national basis. I really think that books should become pdf or open source like Wikibooks, for example. If other costs are involved then there should be a reasonable "materials usage" fee. Sort of like a lab fee. Sharing digital books will force the book companies to see things our way!

1
50shdsofguey•

I'm stuck with "custom" editions this semester for all my books except one. School hasn't even started and I'm already pissed.

2
zogg18•

My prof accidentally sent all his students the past exam papers .

4
N007•

My university puts past exam papers on their website for all students.

10
anabundance•

I did this in a class I took and distributed it to everyone in the class. Free, legal to share version of two textbooks in PDF. Little did I know the professor got a kickback from the publisher on the $60/textbook print versions. He hated me the rest of the semester.

3
newfagniggerhitler•

Once GGP writes his own book(s), he will stop doing this and start using his book(s) as curriculum.

3
callmeRichard•

I had a professor who wrote the book for his class and wouldn't allow the bookstore to sell used copies. It also included a homework workbook that you had to tear the pages out of, photocopies were not accepted. So if you were unlucky enough to have to retake the class you had to purchase $400 book you already owned.

Whenever my school calls and wants a donation I bring up this story.... I haven't been called in a couple of years so I think they realized I'm never going to give that fucking place another cent of mine.

3
growamustache•

My asshole professor listed a book for us to buy (fairly expensive, no used available), and halfway through the course let's us know that he had to recommend a book, but that we wouldn't likely use it. Couldn't return it by then.

2
They-Call-Me-TIM•

I had a professor that sent a .pdf version to the whole class once.

2
indigonights•

Scumbag Professor: makes his own edition of the textbook so you have to buy it and he gets a cut of the profits.

2†
StarOriole•

Who should write textbooks, if not educators? Or, alternatively, who should observe students and get their feedback about how beneficial a book is, if not educators?

3
bobdolebobdole•

Are you seriously that stupid? Are you suggesting that top researchers not use their own publications in their classes? Even though they are most qualified to explain the content? You don't think that they have a bigger target audience than the 100-200 people they directly teach? Or do you just enjoy using stupid memes?

-3†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
TK102•

One semester I had a prof that said how ludicrously expensive a text book was and actually scanned and copied the chapters we needed week to week for us. Ultimate Good Guy Professor.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
derpandderpette•

My good guy Micro professor: "Knows textbooks are overpriced and students are poor. Doesn't require one"

2

In my major there's a student who I share a lot of classes with who pretty much always finds the textbook in PDF form. He always offers to share copies while the professor, whoever it is, says "I didn't hear this, la la la."

2
IndexObject•

My professor just had us pirate ours, because he'd been published before and was more than a little miffed that the $150 tome he'd helped write garnered him about five cents on every sale.

2
[deleted]•

You can't tell me people to not use the tools internet offers today. Especially cloud systems.

2