r/buildapc•
Rahms

[Build Ready] Builds* ready. i3 vs FX6300 help please!

Hello. CPU/mobo are the differences. Finding it hard to decide between FX-6300 which I can OC, or an i3 which I can upgrade (but possibly wont: looking at older generation i5/7 the prices barely seem to drop. since I won't have z87, can't OC upgrades).

The most demanding things I'll be doing are playing games, some CAD and maybe some modelling software like ANSYS, which is why I'm leaning towards the FX-6300. But then if I decide to upgrade, I'll need a new mobo...

PCPartPicker part list / Price breakdown by merchant / Benchmarks

TypeItemPrice
CPUIntel Core i3-4130 3.4GHz Dual-Core Processor£79.19 @ Aria PC
MotherboardASRock H87M Pro4 Micro ATX LGA1150 Motherboard£58.72 @ Amazon UK
MemoryCorsair Vengeance 8GB (2 x 4GB) DDR3-1866 MemoryPurchased For £54.99
StorageSamsung 840 EVO 120GB 2.5" Solid State Disk£65.99 @ Amazon UK
StorageWestern Digital Caviar Blue 1TB 3.5" 7200RPM Internal Hard Drive£42.47 @ Aria PC
Video CardGigabyte Radeon R9 270 2GB Video Card£134.37 @ Amazon UK
CaseAerocool DS Cube Red Edition Silent Cube MicroATX Mini Tower CasePurchased For £65.90
Power SupplyCorsair CSM 550W 80+ Gold Certified Semi-Modular ATX Power SupplyPurchased For £61.80
Optical DriveSamsung SH-224DB/BEBE DVD/CD Writer£11.92 @ CCL Computers
Total
Prices include shipping, taxes, and discounts when available.£575.35
Generated by PCPartPicker 2014-02-08 15:25 GMT+0000

and the AMD:

PCPartPicker part list / Price breakdown by merchant / Benchmarks

TypeItemPrice
CPUAMD FX-6300 3.5GHz 6-Core Processor£80.39 @ Aria PC
CPU CoolerEnermax ETS-T40-TB 86.7 CFM CPU Cooler£27.84 @ Amazon UK
MotherboardGigabyte GA-78LMT-USB3 Micro ATX AM3+ Motherboard£35.94 @ CCL Computers
Total
Prices include shipping, taxes, and discounts when available.£581.61

I deleted all the duplicates which is why the total looks confusing. The i3 will cost 85 too, because I won't be buying from aria!

My thought is to go with the FX-6300, then if I upgrade I'll go to an overclockable i5/7 with new board anyways. Years from now...

Thanks for reading!

edit: obviously feedback on the rest is welcome, but I'm pretty comfortable with those choices!

edit again: for anyone with the same i3 vs 6300 question, this thread is brilliant, as well as the link from u/oostdykr

edit one more time: potentially stupid question but are "empty" pins on my modular PSU an issue, or is that just because the standard adaptors have more connections than is necessary. see pics: http://imgur.com/a/wMe6U

they have no wires going to them so i'm probably just being antsy

Posted Feb 8, 2014, 3:36 PM UTC · edited

611
oostdykr•

Both are solid options. Neither would bottleneck the GPU.

The difference is single-threaded performance vs multi-threaded performance.

Here is a pretty detailed comparison.

4
RahmsOP•

Thanks. The 52% increase in single-threaded stuff seems monstrous. Not sure anything I do will strain the CPU enough for me to see that, but whatever.

I think I'll go i3. If multithreading becomes the norm, I'll upgrade in a few years. The mobo has a few nicer frills, too. Thanks.

One final question: if I decided to crossfire a 2nd R9 270, would the i3 hold it back? I have no idea how to find a resource that can indicate whether a CPU will bottleneck or not

3
IndigoMoss•

Do you plan on doing any overclocking? That i3 build won't OC, where as you can get some pretty massive overclocking on the FX-6300 (4.5 Ghz is really easy on most). New games like Battlefield 4 seem to be loving more cores, so more cores + high OC might be worth it.

Here's some benchmark reviews that introduces some massive overclocking, as well as real world applications. http://www.hardwarecanucks.com/forum/hardware-canucks-reviews/57615-amd-vishera-fx-6300-fx-4300-review-17.html

1
RahmsOP•

The only reason I didn't instantly buy an FX-6300 is that the mATX AM3+ motherboards are garbage. The best thing available (i.e. heatsink on VRM) is a gigabyte with a 760g chipset. Theres an ASRock 880GM LE-FX but it has no heatsinks and is still very lacking in features (SATA 2, no USB 3).

So if I did get that and OC, I'd not be getting amazing results: about 4.2GHz seems reasonable, from reading around: the board wasn't really designed for the high TDP chips, I don't think it could even take an FX-8xxx if I had that extra cash to throw at it!

I really liked the idea of having 6 cores and being able to OC, but I'm not sure I'd need it, and the drawbacks are definitely going to annoy me (SATA 2 for my SSD mainly).

1
IndigoMoss•

Ouch, I didn't realize you were going the mATX route. Yeah without a 970/990 FX board, ti's going to be hard to get those awesome overclocks from the FX line of processors.

Definitely go with the i3 or if you can, spring for the non-overclocking i5.

2
fp4•

You could get a cheaper motherboard for the Intel build if you wanted, the only downside would be less ports but still enough for your build.

2
RahmsOP•

I'll have a look, cheers. I'm probably going to be limited in that I want to keep a second PCIe lane, even if it is only x4.

edit: although it seems x4 will severely bottleneck a second card anyways...

1
fp4•

A second R9 270 or similar wouldn't even fit with the motherboard and case you have picked currently. You need a PCIe 16x rail in the 3rd slot not 4th.

Cheapest option for that possibility: http://uk.pcpartpicker.com/part/asrock-motherboard-z87mextreme4

2
RahmsOP•

is that just because of the room for the faceplate? Hadn't thought of that.

Think I'll get this. Buying the extreme4 just aint worth it!

edit: wrong link! http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B00FXBTZCK/?tag=pcp0f-21

1
fp4•

That case only has 4 expansion slot openings and in the fourth slot there would be no room to screw down the second slot on the card.

Even this board would work for your build:

http://uk.pcpartpicker.com/part/msi-motherboard-h81me33v2

1