RPGs without xp and levels?
Hi. I'm quite new to this subreddit (and reddit in general). I am very interested video game design - in particular innovating new designs and rethinking existing designs.
Right now I am interested in starting a discussion about an alternative take on the RPG genre.
A traditional core mechanic of the RPG genre is that you through gameplay gradually earns xp which occasionally increases your level and subsequently unlocks new abilities.
I think these level-based progression schedules are being a bit overdone these days, especially since RPG mechanics are seeping into other genres, for example FPS with all their gradual weapons unlocks and so on. These designs can be dangerous because they easily becomes grindy chores if one is not careful, for example if you purposefully want to acquire a specific gun and have to grind to unlock it.
I'm interested in discussing alternative ways to do progression. I have some thoughts, but I wish to hear your thoughts first, so they are not polluted by my input.
The question: Say we abolished the notion of experience points completely (and thus experience levels too). How would you design an RPG?
Notice skill points, etc. are still allowed, and they are allowed to increase through progression of the game - Just not based on xp.
Posted Apr 5, 2014, 10:31 PM UTC
I'd say there are two options. Option one is creating that sense of progression through items. Option two is to have the player find their abilities in the world.
I agree that those two options definintely are interesting possible solutions. Games like The Binding of Isaac took this route and it worked well for them.
Having the players finding their abilities through exploring or combat might introduce a lot of randomness though, and while randomly generated content is popular these days, it might not always be a desirable side-effect. Any ideas on how to make the progression less random and more predictable?
Take more of a Metroid/Megaman route and require certain abilities to get into the next area of the game. Sure a player might be able to get past the requirements with enough skill but it makes it far easier to progress with the ability
Yes, I think soft boundaries like that might be a good idea to do it. It guides the player in the direction the designer intend while allows the player to stray from the path if they insist.
Metroidvanias with RPG elements really bother me, since they usually resort to making you grind to buy stronger skills.
The DSi Shantae game was pretty bad at this, especially since you were never told how important the shop items were in combat. I hear that most of the Castlevania games have the same problem.
Nothing wrong with not liking grinding. But games like Metroid and Megaman don't really need grinding to beat the game, it just makes it easier on the player by allowing them to regain their health or ammo.
A static world maybe. Like what most mmo games do. You would just need to make items and ability harder to obtain.
It would have to be linear as well then so the player discover the abilities in the order the designer intended.
thats not a real strong rpg element then. What if you made the abilities versitile? You don't necessarily need to learn magic bolt to learn how to use cone of cold.
Why? How is that in any way necessary for it being an RPG or even a fun game?