RPGs without xp and levels?

Hi. I'm quite new to this subreddit (and reddit in general). I am very interested video game design - in particular innovating new designs and rethinking existing designs.

Right now I am interested in starting a discussion about an alternative take on the RPG genre.

A traditional core mechanic of the RPG genre is that you through gameplay gradually earns xp which occasionally increases your level and subsequently unlocks new abilities.

I think these level-based progression schedules are being a bit overdone these days, especially since RPG mechanics are seeping into other genres, for example FPS with all their gradual weapons unlocks and so on. These designs can be dangerous because they easily becomes grindy chores if one is not careful, for example if you purposefully want to acquire a specific gun and have to grind to unlock it.

I'm interested in discussing alternative ways to do progression. I have some thoughts, but I wish to hear your thoughts first, so they are not polluted by my input.

The question: Say we abolished the notion of experience points completely (and thus experience levels too). How would you design an RPG?

Notice skill points, etc. are still allowed, and they are allowed to increase through progression of the game - Just not based on xp.

Posted Apr 5, 2014, 10:31 PM UTC

1092
Niazik•

I'd say there are two options. Option one is creating that sense of progression through items. Option two is to have the player find their abilities in the world.

5
SpiderboydkOP•

I agree that those two options definintely are interesting possible solutions. Games like The Binding of Isaac took this route and it worked well for them.

Having the players finding their abilities through exploring or combat might introduce a lot of randomness though, and while randomly generated content is popular these days, it might not always be a desirable side-effect. Any ideas on how to make the progression less random and more predictable?

2
Niazik•

Take more of a Metroid/Megaman route and require certain abilities to get into the next area of the game. Sure a player might be able to get past the requirements with enough skill but it makes it far easier to progress with the ability

5
SpiderboydkOP•

Yes, I think soft boundaries like that might be a good idea to do it. It guides the player in the direction the designer intend while allows the player to stray from the path if they insist.

1
thomar•

Metroidvanias with RPG elements really bother me, since they usually resort to making you grind to buy stronger skills.

The DSi Shantae game was pretty bad at this, especially since you were never told how important the shop items were in combat. I hear that most of the Castlevania games have the same problem.

1
Niazik•

Nothing wrong with not liking grinding. But games like Metroid and Megaman don't really need grinding to beat the game, it just makes it easier on the player by allowing them to regain their health or ammo.

2
Borgmaster•

A static world maybe. Like what most mmo games do. You would just need to make items and ability harder to obtain.

1
SpiderboydkOP•

It would have to be linear as well then so the player discover the abilities in the order the designer intended.

1
Borgmaster•

thats not a real strong rpg element then. What if you made the abilities versitile? You don't necessarily need to learn magic bolt to learn how to use cone of cold.

1
Bwob•

Why? How is that in any way necessary for it being an RPG or even a fun game?

1
AnOnlineHandle•

I can't recall, but I don't think that Magicka had levels (though more of an action rpg), you just learned how to use the elemental combinations better, maybe gained new elements along the way or something.

Games like Alice Madness Returns, Minecraft, etc, are about getting better gear but remaining the same 'level' (though Minecraft did introduce some sort of xp, unsure what it does, something about enchanting I think).

Adventure games such as The Longest Journey, King's Quest, don't tend to have xp.

These aren't perhaps 'rpgs' per se, though the genre seems a bit hard to define. End game of an mmo generally doesn't involve xp any more at max level, and some people think that that is where the game truly begins.

4
SpiderboydkOP•

Yes, the genre boundaries can be a bit fuzzy, especially when tinkering with widely established mechanics like we do now.

Magicka is an interesting example. I don't remember if it has levels as well, but the focus is on exploring the combination of elements and memorizing those you want to use.

In modern Minecraft you gain xp and levels by defeating foes, but they treat levels somewhat unusual: they are a resource you spend to buy enchantments and repairs for your gear. While it has xp and thus falls outside this discussion it is still an interesting way of dealing with progression.

Unfortunately I'm not familiar with the rest of the games you mentioned, but I might look into them at some time.

3
thomar•

Magicka doesn't have levels. It does have gear (one sword and one staff) which you can pick up, but you lose gear if you die. New spells that do non-elemental things, like raising dead allies or changing the weather, are acquired by picking up spellbooks hidden in each level.

3
Naethure•

While it has xp and thus falls outside this discussion

I'm not quite sure it does. It really doesn't matter what something is called so much as it matters what it does or how it's used. Sure, they call it "xp", but it doesn't work in the way that "xp" is generally used (or in the way you described xp in your post). They could easily have called it "enchantment points" or something and there would be no debate whether or not the game has xp.

Likewise, a game could call their experience something else (maybe skill points or learning points or whatever), but it could still function as xp -- these games should be excluded from a discussion on RPG's without xp, not RPG's that use the term "xp" to mean something completely different.

1
SpiderboydkOP•

By experience points I mean point you receive merely from defeating enemies, but I admit it's a corner case. By this definition it's xp.

As I said it's still interesting how it works regardless of whether it fall outside the discussion topic or not.

1
Naethure•

That's really not a valid definition for experience points, though. Most RPGs give experience for many things including quests (many of which don't involve defeating enemies at all), exploration, crafting, and gathering/collecting items, amongst others. Also, most RPGs give a lot of things from killing enemies: items/loot, currency, reputation/faction, achievements, etc.

By your new definition of "xp" currency is a form of xp. In fact, just about anything that is gained en masse is!

A better definition of "xp" would involve what it's used for.

2
kilkonie•

You might have a look at how brogue tackles this. Brian (the author) has been focused on streamlining gameplay to the essentials and the discussion about it on the forums has been interesting.

From the wiki:

XP has been removed from the game, as it was decided that rewarding the player for killing rather than bypassing monsters did not fit with the overall spirit of Brogue, and unfairly penalized stealth-based play.

4
SpiderboydkOP•

I've never heard of Brogue, but it sounds interesting. I should look more into this. Thanks for the tip.

2
kuury•

If you take the wheels off of a wagon, is it still a wagon?

3†
Bwob•

Arguably, the only thing required for a Role Playing Game be an RPG is a focus on role playing.

17
kuury•

You're being too literal.

By that definition, every game that allows direct control is an RPG. They're called RPGs because of an ancestry with tabletop RPGs, and include the focus on visible stats like them. But they've changed and evolved in the last 20 years. What we consider an RPG is different than what Disco Pete would.

5
Bwob•

Arguably, a lot of people consider things to be RPGs that aren't actually RPGs. :)

I think the problem is that many RPGs often include things like XP and skill points and levels, so people start to imagine that those are somehow integral to the experience. But Diablo, for example, isn't really much of an RPG, even though it has both levels and xp and skill points.

5
kuury•

I can't comment on Diablo since I've never played it. But from what I do know, it's just an RPG that places an increased emphasis on equipment and drops compared to levels and experience, right?

Anyway, yeah, definitions change over time. That's how language works! In the end, the current accepted lists of genres aren't useful for a whole lot anyway, so I wouldn't worry too much about nitpicking them.

0
Trucidar•

I would argue that it is not. Traditional 'RPG' games do not have you play a role any more or less than any other genre that has you play a single character. There is little role-playing in the RPG genre.

In fact, I would say a shooter where you play one character has more role-playing than an rpg where you control many characters. Nowadays, RPG as a genre is pretty much is any game with character growth/customization.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Bwob•

I would argue that what makes an RPG is character progression,

So then... Battlefield, Doom, Quake, and Gradius are RPGs then?

1
NeverQuiteEnough•

he's asking for alternative forms of progression, do you really feel that an exp bar is critical to the rpg experience?

you could easily do something like, having achievements unlock new abilities. kill 20 enemies with a single attack, do 3x your own health in one strike, you get to choose a new ability.

there is still progression, customization. it is an rpg. no?

7
SpiderboydkOP•

Well, is it? Is xp such an integral part of the RPG genre, that it ceases to be an RPG if you remove xp?

5
kuury•

Not necessarily, but I think most people wouldn't identify it as an RPG.

An RPG has two major elements that make it feel like an RPG. Progression/feelings of accomplishment or progress, and customization. Experience points allow for the former by making sure that every second the player puts in places them further towards their goal. Nothing is wasted, and they are in control. It accomplishes the latter by acting as a gate so that you're not just choosing a character and rolling that way.

Is it possible to do it? Maybe? But no one would call it an RPG anyway. Then it'd be an "action game" or a "strategy game".

4
SpiderboydkOP•

If I recall correctly Dungeon Siege used a system, where you gained specific amount of points in a skill everytime you used that skill, so if you wanted to a high skill level in a healing spell, you had to cast the healing spell a lot of times.

While this can be thought of as a kind of experience points, if surely differs from the traditional notion, where you gain skill points to spend when you have earned a sufficient amount of xp.

I think that despite Dungeon Siege is a bit unusual in this regard, it is still widely regarded as an RPG.

But you are right that some games might lose their RPG feel if you remove the xp part - I imagine especially those that are very combat focused and have a lot of power creep would be vulnerable to this, for example like Diablo.

2
kuury•

I...really don't think that's different at all. At least not for the purposes of this discussion. Every RPG handles exp differently.

3
JoystickMonkey•

Absolutely not.

1
4dseeall•

Chrono Cross did something exactly like what you're describing. It's one of my favorite RPGs of all times, but it still has the classic "raise your stats to get stronger" trope.

Another way to get rid of character levels is to have technique levels and character stats. This way, the character is only as strong as the level of their abilities. Maybe this is still too close to exp though, since you'd be grinding and using techniques for exp instead of just winning battles.

3
SpiderboydkOP•

The way you increase your stats and get stronger is pivotal to this discussion - not whether or not you have number-based skills and stats.

I'm asking for ideas to alternative ways to raise your stats than gaining some sort of points through combat.

1
4dseeall•

It seems to me like you're asking how to get stronger without actually making training a part of the equation. That doesn't make much sense to me, in a game or real context.

What would be the point of combat in such a game? Just a time-sink to make the game last longer? That's already what they are, but with the benefit of making the game easier after a long period of grinding.

I guess you could have a completely separate system of character growth related to training or gyms or something. Maybe get stats through minigames or something.

1
derpderp3200•

RPG stands for "Role Playing Game", levels and XP have zero to do with RPG as a genre.

It's not like getting rid of levels gets rid of all progression, it's not like it get rids of any progression - I'm not sure that planning out when to give the player skill points works out well, because then that feels like an artificial shortage, but you could always have most of the skills similar in power, perhaps some stronger but at a higher mana cost, and just let the player unlock them by training, learning, or doing quests, and instead of plain "stronger", make them more specialized against X(firebolts kill trolls, fireballs kill swarms of weaker enemies, ice bolts kill water elementals, thousand fists wrecks unarmored enemies, spear power throw pierces armor, etc. etc. etc.).

Personally I would argue that this approach has essentially just pluses - with less steep power scaling, everything stays viable, compelling players to check out more content, low level areas don't become irrelevant - you can reuse them, achievements are more personal, and players have much more left to their preference - they will not have to ditch the badass sword they like in favor of a hammer that has four times the dps.

EDIT: How I'd design such a game: lots of unlocks, most skills have weak points, making even similar skills sometimes relatively viable, fighting styles for different weapons/unarmed, where you unlock new moves as a tree, perhaps try to make the game repayable with unlockable races and classes.... then again that's getting a bit far from an RPG, and closer to a roguelike or something.

2
SpiderboydkOP•

Very interesting comment. I agree completely with the fact that xp can be completely unrelated to progress.

Personally I think that the traditional xp mechanic feels a lot more artificial than basically all suggestions in this thread.

Your suggestion is a good one. I tried to come up with disadvantages, but I thought of none, which couldn't be trivially countered.

1
derpderp3200•

There's two - it's harder to design, and it's less addicting. Arguably, the latter only matters for MMO games, and otherwise is hardly a disadvantage.

1
therjkessler•

In RPGs, experience and levels serve a single purpose: acquisition of new "stuff", whether that be stats, skills, items, access to new areas, etc. If you're going to abolish experience and levels, you just need to devise a new way for acquisition to happen.

Coincidentally, this acquisition is what creates the feeling of progression and advancement, which is why RPGs and progression are often cited to be inseparable. Experience and levels are simply one method, or medium, by which progression can happen.

Example alternative 1: Capsules that are strewn about the world, whether as one-time pickups or random drops off of creatures. Think of Materia in FF7. Whether equipped onto gear or consumed or whatever, these capsules could grant skills, stats, etc. Real examples include Zelda and Metroid.

Example alternative 2: Story-based progression. You are granted certain skills/characters/etc. at specific points of the story and that chapter of the plot must be played with that combination of skills/characters/etc. Subsequent chapters could grant new skills and/or take away old ones. A real example could be Portal.

2
SpiderboydkOP•

I find it interesting that xp is so ingrained in the genre that it's the major choice of preference on how to do progression.

RPGs are usually strongly narrated, so one would think that the progression of story would more or less automatically be tied to the progression of the game (like your second example) and thus an xp system wouldn't be paramount.

5
vaunred•

Remember that RP part of RPG stands for something: Role Playing. Gaining levels, earning experience points, finding attribute bonuses are mechanical shorthand for character growth.

Experience points are, in essence, a quantified measure of how much insight, understanding, or wisdom a character gains from overcoming a problem. A character gets more powerful because it's learned something, grown in some way, and is better able to handle future problems.

Video game RPGs are the products of tabletop ancestors and while D&D and Chainmail may have had a focus statistics and tables, RPGs don't. After all, what is an RPG? A game where players become someone else in a fictional setting. That's it. The other trappings and tropes are tools that work well enough and have become so ubiquitous as to be synonymous with the concept itself.

If you want to explore different ideas for RPG systems, broaden what RPG means. Hell, broaden what "game" means. I have a very liberal definition - you know how improv actors play games to warm up before a show? Those are RPGs. Kids pretending to be X-Men in their front yard? An RPG. LARPing? Definitely an RPG. Fiasco? Half-life? Red Alert 2?! RPGs.

There's nothing sacred about "RPG" as a genre or classification. As much as it may frustrate some, any game that lets you control another person can be called an RPG.

The question I think you're asking, without knowing you're asking it, is: How do I mechanize character growth or development without levels, experience points, and similar numerical minutia?

That is a different can of worms entirely and the answer depends on the elements of character growth on which your game is focused. If your game is about becoming more powerful to overcome challenges then the traditional leveling system is probably your best bet. You can freeform it some if you remove levels and make the experience points, or whatever you decide to call them, a currency used to buy powers, skills, attacks, influence, or whatever. It's still the same basic idea, just shuffled a bit to remove structure.

Is your game about something else? Emotional maturity? Learning from the past? Accepting responsibility? These bits of character growth are tricky to mechanize, at least directly. Braid explores the idea of learning from the past as a mechanic to solve both immediate puzzles and the larger puzzle of the protagonist's life. The Stanley Parable uses exploration of a game world to examine free will and determinism.

Are they role playing games? I'd say yes. I'm not myself, I'm somewhere that isn't real, and I'm in a game.

But you need to decide what the definition is for you and what mechanical tropes are essential, if any.

2
SpiderboydkOP•

That was a very insightful comment. Yes, how to mechanize character growth without resortint to experience points is exactly what I ask.

I agree that it wouldn't hurt to widen the current genre definition, but if it is widened as much as you do it applies to almost every game and that makes the definition useless.

I didn't think of the fact that what alternative mechanics is appropriate depends on what the game is about. I agree with you on this though, as some of the best games seems to have a strong, but natural connection between the story, theme and "feel" of the game, and what underlying mechanics is governing the gameplay.

2
vaunred•

Glad you liked it. I like the question you asked, it's one I wrestle with, so I had some form of an answer prepared.

Is this where I say something as predictable and cliched as "Genres are arbitrary selection criteria anyway, and nearly any game/movie/book/album/artist placed into one can be placed into a dozen others?"

I think the definition is already useless because it doesn't tell us much about what to expect from the experience - "you will be role playing a game!" Duh. I think "First Person Shooter" is best genre term we have because it tells you exactly what it is. Unfortunately, the genre allows for little growth or expansion.

I'd prefer genres organized around emotions - usually there are one or two emotions at the center of whatever experience or piece that one is observing - and the names for emotions tell you what to expect from it. They prime you to try discover why the diction is done the way it is, why there are certain shots or takes, or why the game is designed the way it is. But this is a tangent to your original question.

Back to point, I like looking at mechanics, camera shots, diction, paint color, blah blah as metaphors or mechanisms to instill in the audience a specific emotion or thought. Ask "why did Ozu shoot it like this and not some other way?" or "why is Bioshock Infinite first person and not third, or isometric?"

Thanks for question. I hope you got some good answers.

1
WorldWarDooDoo•

I recommend having a look at how character progression works in a tabletop RPG called Runequest. It involves improving certain abilities and skills not by adventuring, but by visiting towns and learning from the masters. This seems to kind of make sense, but I don't know if you will find that satisfactory. There was definitely a hint of this idea in Skyrim, with stats that got better with use, the only problem I saw with that was obviously the ease of exploitation. It seems certainly reasonable that you should get better at something the more you do it, but numbers are just numbers. What would be really cool would be to act out this training. Actually making learning a new spell or attack or any other skill meaningful, mechanically and with respect to role-playing. It also seems like a common balance is to make getting better at something harder as you extend to some established capacity. But then there lies the problem of grinding, which isn't really a problem if it's fun. I think when it comes down to it, an rpg without levels would be awesome as long as the system is designed to be fun for the player. Skyrim did feel a little grindy for a few skills like black smithing, but it sort of seemed a little cheap and repetitive that the player can just spam iron daggers to get to daedric smithing. That being said, if that repetitive experience were made fun, or more dynamic ( I like to think there are some cases where repetition is fun), it would have been much more fun to play around with. Granted it was just my experience, some other player could have really enjoyed it or found a better way to level up smithing. I think gear can also scale with stats, which is the route most RPGs take I think, but I definitely like the extra layer dark souls took with stat requirements for certai weapons, which incentivizes improvement, but this dynamic could be taken a step further by increasing the effectiveness of gear over time, weapon might, speed, etc. Which I actually think is implemented on dark souls 2's magic system. So there are plenty of systems that don't used levels, or have a lot of depth in addition to levels, that makes for a fun system. I think as a final remark the problem I've wondered about is the lack of the glamour of levelling up. Getting tons of bonuses and new skills upon levelling up seemed to be expected by a lot of players. So it seems like effort to make a non-levelling system just as exciting along the way would really go a long way.

2
WorldWarDooDoo•

Sorry, the recommendation was only if you're interested, I didn't mean to force an idea on you or anything.

1
SpiderboydkOP•

Don't worry, you are not forcing anything. :-)

1
SpiderboydkOP•

I am a little familiar with tabletop RPGs, and I like GURPS a lot, which - concidentally - doesn't have character levels, experience points per se. The GM hands out skill points now and then when he thik the party has earned it.

What you also seem to discuss is the problem with exploiting progression mechanics, being it mass fabricating iron daggers to achieve an in-character somewhat unrelated skill like smithing another material, or being old-fashioned gridning. There are two options: avoid it or embrace it, and either one could work depending on your approach.

You could embrace it by making grinding fun, like you mentioned. I think Final Fantasy do this really well. It's basically 50 hours of alternating between combat and cutscenes.

Regarding the problem with the loss of glamour from leveling I think this might be substituted with other kinds of bonues for example new equipment or vanity items or similar.

1
fleegle2000•

It seems to me that the single greatest weakness of computer RPGs compared to paper-and-pencil ones is the lack of opportunities for the player to really take on and own the role they have chosen/been given, which after all is the whole point of role-playing. So, instead of XP, skill points, etc., perhaps progression should be based on the less tangible character attributes, how the player chooses to interact with NPCs, etc. The roles wouldn't be the traditional warrior/wizard/rogue etc. since those are mostly combat-oriented classes. Perhaps they would be based on profession or personality-type - a real-life or futuristic setting would probably work best.

Edit: I just realized that The Sims, love it or hate it, is perhaps one of the best candidates for a computer game that has approached paper-and-pencil RPGs in terms of being able to really own your role. Now if the Sims had more traditional gameplay elements and you had direct control of the Sim, you might have what you want.

2
Nick_Cliche•

Ultima Online comes to mind. The great thing about it is (was?) a character could become a master blacksmith without once having to wield a sword in anger.

2
crawsome•

Historically, this approach has been taken, and yet, the XP system is still very popular. But here is what I've seen:

Abilities level up the more you use then. If you're beaten within an inch of your life, your HP goes up, if you use bows, bows go up.

An item or a passive ability that increases stats by area explored

Item drops that buff stats instead of levels

1
SpiderboydkOP•

Yes, there are games now and then that have tried something else, but I still think a discussion like this is relevant. One might learn from past experiences and iterate that approach, or one might come up with a completely novel idea, or one could merge two or more seperate solutions into a new thing.

Just because a mechanic is widely popular doesn't necessarily mean it's an inherently good mechanic, like skinnerbox techniques (which btw. are particularly ubiquitous in the RPG genre).

It's a nice list though. :-)

1
bebobli•

Deus Ex is exactly what you need to check out.

1
SpiderboydkOP•

I've never played it, but I've heard about it many times and it seems to be acclaimed. I'll be sure to keep it in mind.

1
Badrobinhood•

It's not a bad game but it doesn't really do what you are talking about. Different levels in the game have multiple -short- branches that require slightly different skills to navigate. You still earn skill points in a way very similar to experience.

1
bebobli•

No, it's much more common to receive 'experience points' through battle, but Deus Ex rewarded exploration by giving points when you find a sneaky way around, find a secret, get to a certain point, hacking or picklocking new areas.

1
chicmonster•

Well the answer lies in how exactly players are going to measure their progress without experience points. The easiest thing I can think of is transferring the "levels" of difficulty into material objects that the player then seeks. In this manner, there's still a natural progression, but it has more to do with what you find and interact with than what you kill.

Terraria kind of did things like this by forcing the player to make better armor and weapons for herself, and life crystals that increased your help would only be discovered after exploring the map extensively, and everything that progressed the game in one way or another had to be found or made by the player.

1
SpiderboydkOP•

Yes, ideas for alternative ways to measure progress is exactly what I seek with this discussion.

As you said, Terraria took the item route, where you progress by getting better gear. Besides that Terraria is heavily tiered, where a set of armour from one tear is obviously superior to armor from a lower tier.

A tiered system like that has pros and cons. What if the system was tierless?

1
chicmonster•

well, then we'd probably gravitate towards actual player skill getting better. In that case, the fighting mechanics of the game would have to be very fine tuned so that you can only get far in the game if you're really, really good at it. You can include customization and material items that are tierless, and have it be up to the player to decide which set of items is actually best for them. Games like these are very difficult to make, though. They require months of playtesting at the very least.

If you want to make a game like that, I would look at something like Spelunky, which again is not quite an RPG, but operates on this principle in a 2d platformer setting, and most items aren't really tiered (you get them randomly times so there's no natural progression). There's also DarkSouls which uses difficulty to scale progress in the game.

1
SpiderboydkOP•

Depending on player skills definintely is an option, but there are other options too.

As you seem to briefly touch on, you could also make progression itembased and make sure the items are incomparables (i.e. it's not obvious which item is best - depends on circumstances). You are right this is very hard to balance, but it can be done. This is how most TCGs work.

1
SuspectIntent•

Flavor-wise World Of Warcraft associates levels with time. For example, they call it the "80th season of adventure" or whatever. The concept being that levels are a representation of time spent in the world. The levels and xp are the system used to convey that information to the player.

Anyway, what if levels/skills were just given to the player as time went on? Like at the start of a level, or at certain story points (in a more open-world level-less design). I've played a few games with similar systems. The more I think about it, something like this could really open up design space. That way the player gets to play the game the way they want, and skills could be designed to accommodate multiple play styles.

1
DaveSilver•

This is kind of similar to the way my friends and I used to play DnD. Whenever our dungeon master felt we had accomplished enough that we should level, he would simply say, "You guys gain X levels, start distributing stats". It was cool because it prevented us from having to worry about XP we gained, it prevented level gains and stat distribution from distracting us during major parts of the story. It gave a stronger focus on story and "gameplay", and less on character building. Every level felt more like an achievement since it was directly linked to an accomplishment or event, and less like a single step on a staircase since it rarely happened at a random moment.

3
SuspectIntent•

That's another reason why I like this idea. You just banished the Skeleton King forever you get ...some xp. Then thirty seconds later you kill some random demon and the fireworks go off.

2
SpiderboydkOP•

That is a really interesting idea, which I have never heard before, and I agree with you on it's possibilities. I imagine several forms this mechanic could take.

If you have a heavily narrated game, the skills could be tied closely to the story.

If you wish to cater to the speedrunners you could have the skills gradually become stronger over time and then the objective is to beat the game in shortest possible time.

I think a positive side-effect might be that power creep may be easier to control.

1
SuspectIntent•

Your comment on power-creep is spot on. It is a lot easier to design a challenge for a specific number rather than a range of levels or skills.

I also like how it actually supports more open-ended gameplay: Stealth mechanics, advanced dialogue options, skill related shortcuts, etc. All solutions/playstyles are created equal as far as how they impact character growth.

1
SpiderboydkOP•

I don't understand why timed skill progress better cultivate open-ended gameplay than xp-based skill progerss. Could you elaborate on that?

1
SuspectIntent•

It's more of a balance issue. Let's say that the game has wildly different mechanics that are used to complete quests/missions. Using previous examples, let's say combat vs stealth. If one method is strictly better balance-wise, then the game basically holds the players hand to complete the game using that method. Or, worse, a player gets xp for damn near everything and then they talk to everyone twice, hunt for secrets, sneak around, talk to everyone, kill everyone, talk to anyone who isn't dead, hunt for secrets, then complete their actual objective.

It's really easy for "take any path" to turn into "take every path" or "take the path that's strictly better than the others."

2
DaveSilver•

I think removing levels would work if you create strong player stats. In theory you could have the stats themselves progress as you use skills/abilities associated with them, similar to what you see in Elder Scrolls games. What would be cool though would be to also remove xp as a factor in stat growth. Instead you could make it that the stats simply get better every time you use them, but the amount that they increment or improve with each use decreases over time. So instead of each action you take giving you xp which is linked to a specific stat or bringing that stat closer to a 'level-up', the action actually increases the stat by a small amount. Maybe jumping increases your Dex by .05 and rolling increases it by .08, etc. So with each action you take you are improving some amount instead of getting closer to the next imporvement. Over time, after stats reach certain thresholds/levels(I know the point was originally to remove levels but at least the player doesn't have an overall level right?) the amount that an action impacts the stat would decrease or have a modifier applied to it, and eventually it would max out.

The cons of this system are that individual "levels" for each stat don't feel as important or interesting since your stats are just always increasing. This also means you never get that individual moment of success where the stat reaches the level you wanted as instead of going from 19 to 20, it simply goes from 19.99 to 20. On top of that, a system like this would probably be very hard to balance since one action which gives too much or too little could easily destroy the whole progression for a stat. The pro to this though would be that changes would feel more natural since you'd have a true progression of each stat over time, and not just movement from one plateau to the next.

It would be similar to the difference between walking up a hill, and walking up staircase. Normal leveling would be a staircase, and this system is the hill.

1
SpiderboydkOP•

Very good comment and I agree with your analysis of pros and cons.

I think this suggestion could be interesting to combine with some of the other suggestsions in the thread.

1
kitsovereign•

Most RPGs already have this - monsters drop EXP cash; after you appease the plot you can go to the next town's shiny new shop and purchase level-ups better equipment. But that's boring.

The Mario RPGs do a good job in showing progression in ways other than EXP, though they still use EXP as well. (For analysis, let's look specifically at Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door.) New moves and increased offense are only tied to progressing the plot or exploring the terrain, not fighting battles. The stats you gain from leveling up - Heart Points (HP), Flower Points (mana), and Badge Points (playing with more buffs/special moves at once) - technically never have to be used; they just make things easier and/or more fun. (It's possible - though implausible - to dodge every move in the game and take no damage.) Likewise, you gain partners through progressing the plot (duh), and they each only level up twice, by finding Shine Sprites throughout the landscape.

The other aspect is that more difficult enemies have traits other than bigger HP and attack. They require more specialized tactics (how do you defeat a flying enemy with spikes on its head?), inflict nastier status conditions, and have attacks with more confusing dodge timing.

In short: Give the player buffs at set times/places, instead of through clearing random encounters. Make more difficult battles require more of the player, instead of just more of his characters' stats.

1
SpiderboydkOP•

This definintely seems to be a viable approach you could take. I'm not familiar with Paper Mario, but I'll keep it in mind in case I stumble upon it some time.

2
jayemjee2•

I have often considered this kind of thing, and I personally agree that leveling mechanics in RPGs are way overdone. I was considering an idea for a roguelike without levels. I was considering basing progression around collection of weapons (which would work more like "side-grades" than upgrades) and increasing your skill with particular weapons the more you use them. That latter part gets dangerously close to leveling up, though.

1
SpiderboydkOP•

Sounds interesting.

If you want to stay completely away from xp-like mechanics, you probably want to think of another way of progerssion.

For example you could spawn a trainer on every other level, which gives a point on your three most often used skills or something like that once per trainer. You still tie the skill progression to the actual player activities, you can limit progression as you wish, and being trained by a trainer can aid with immersion.

1
vagol942•

RPG stands for role playing game; so is basically a game where you simulate to have another life, this is the barebones definition.

Just like in real life, you make decisions and you grow an get experience from things you do like cooking, studying or driving.

This is translated into most rpgs has "leveling" and that made a lot of sence when RPGs were mostly though has pen and paper games, has you has the player could not really get better at the things your character did, you just took strategical decisitions and roll a dice.

With videogames the concept is a lot more interesting, has you, the player, can actually get better at playing your character, just like after 1000 hours in dota you stop sucking, because in a videogame you can actually simulate to do something, not just decide what your character do.

For example, imagine a game where you are a mage, you know some basic spells, but you don't magicly learn new once after sometime, you need to learn the new ones somehow or invent some in another way.

And this new spells are "harder" to cast than the previous onces. By harder I mean that somehow the player has to input some aditional inputs to the game to cast. That could be something like stupid has a strange button smashing combination or something crazy like pluging a brainwave detector onto the players head to see if he is really focusing in casting.

That way the character doesn't get better, you get better, and if someone else takes control of your character they will probably not be as proficient as you on it. Of course for such things to exist there is still a lot technological advancement to be made, but it will eventually happend.

1
Quantumtroll•

Stalker is exactly that sort of RPG (I think, because I didn't play it for very long). IIRC, your character progresses by finding better equipment, interacting with factions to get access to new areas, and the player just getting better.

System Shock 2 is another good example. The player receives cyber-modules for accomplishing various objectives or just searching around in nooks and crannies. The cyber-modules are then used to upgrade skills and abilities.

Then there are a slew of "action-RPG's" (or sword-fighting adventure game) where you got better equipment as the game went on without any skill progression. Rune is one example.

1