Reddit Censorship Checker Available
Since this comment on u/creq 's now sticky'd thread and this daily dot article a lot of people have asked me to check various subreddits for different censured words.
Well now everyone can join in the fun and check all the subs you like! It took a little doing but I've made a fairly user friendly interface for the program I've been running to check reddit's subs and now you can download it from here.
How it works:
The java application crawls the pages of http://www.reddit.com/search for a given topic and compiles the karma points and links of all the pages it finds and puts them neatly into an excel file which is saved wherever the app is run.
to use the application...
-
run "RunRedditSearch.bat"
-
enter a subreddit name
-
enter the word or phrase you suspect is banned
-
select a time frame
-
let the app run
Most runs are completed in just a few minutes, if you select "All" as your time frame it might take 10 minutes or more (because it's indexing every link a sub has that's related to your search term).
here are some screenshots of the application 1 2
I've uploaded the source code to GitHub, so you can update it if you like. Give it one of those "window" interfaces everybody's talking about.
Once you've run the program, here's how you make a chart with that data.
There will no doubt be errors, I'm an amateur coder at best (and no doubt some of you can tell from the source code). But! If you encounter bug/error/crash, please let me know so I can (hopefully) fix it!
read the README.txt README (with spaces).rtf for more details on how to search.
edit: you guys are awesome
edit: thanks for the gold stranger
edit: for linux users here's u/creq 's guide on using this tool:
- Unpack the archive
- Call the directory you just unpacked
- Type the following into terminal the following
java -jar RedditSearch.jar
Protip: If you want to run it on Reddit anonymously use Torsocks
torsocks java -jar RedditSearch.jar
Code Edit 1: the program now supports special search terms, like:
site:rt.com
or if you suspect a user has been blocked:
author:username
Code Edit 2: space bug fixed
advanced functions (like the search operator OR) and multi-word searches now supported.
edit: [new report out by u/creq!](https://pay.reddit.com/r/undelete/comments/23ee42/meta_i_have_identified_a_list_of_domains_that_are/)
-
Trouble Shooting: "RunRedditSearch opened but then closed immediately"
Hit Start/Windows Key and type "CMD" and open cmd.exe, then type the following
Posted Apr 16, 2014, 8:17 AM UTC · edited
This revelation of censorship on what has become my primary source of news is unsettling. I don't know if this is the appropriate forum for my question, but what alternatives are there, if any exist, that would have equivalent access to news as reddit minus the censoring?
[deleted]
For me, what I liked about Reddit is that I would see news that wasn't at another place. I still do, but that is because of unsubscribing from certain subs and subscribing to others.
I still see those. Its like all the undelete subreddits have become a "bestof news"
Well, hindsight is 20/20. It was very easy to trust reddit when its very popularity and success relies on a seemingly transparent form of democracy and voting. Anyone who has tried to game the system knows how difficult it is.
Only after investing a considerable amount of time on reddit do you start to notice who holds power, who is abusing it, and who is exploiting the platform.
[deleted]
Reddit is hardly Democratic given the power and opaque nature of mods. Mods can do far too much and theres no voting them out.
As for gaming the system, it isn't necessarily hard. As power users use reddit more and more they eventually become mods then powermods. You won't get this status without already having an unusual amount of free time (which could be due to unemployment(hint)).
As for your last statement, i agree but would make a small change to that in saying, the system isn't being abused. The system is fundamentally flawed. A law/rule/idea that can't be enforced isn't really a rule/law/proper execution
In what way do you "rely" on the news?
He said that he relies on reddit for the news not that he relies on the news....
"Rely" seems like a transitive property; if he didn't rely on the news, then why would he rely on something that provides it?
But I see your point. I was just trying to point out that we often think of the news as something important in our lives without thinking about what (if any) meaningful effect it has on our actions.
I'll be honest, reddit is not--and has never been--the best source for unbiased news. The largest problem, of course, is that it runs on upvotes and downvotes for visibility. Due to how the majority (yes, I am assuming here) of reddit users vote, the articles that are the most interesting to a general public are most visible, NOT the articles with the most meaningful analysis or accurate insights. Generalizing a bit more, these articles are those that are sensationalist.
Of course there is no perfect alternative, but I use a few myself. Not all of these are decent, even by the above standards.
/rantoff
reuters (direct news source)
new york times (direct news source)
google news (news aggregator; you can choose what content you want. content is sorted by google's algorithms.)
flipboard (mobile only, it's customizable and quite similar to reddit. content is curated by admins.)
newsmap (pulls from google news, content is then sorted by article traffic volume.)
I will try out Google news and flipboard. The issue with nyt and Reuters is that they are only one source. I can appreciate the obvious shortcomings of the voting system on reddit and that no system is incorruptible. I'm just hoping to find a place that hadn't been compromised yet and hope to notice once it has so I can move on once again.
I don't understand your bias against actual journalistic news sources. Sure maybe they don't cover everything but the average article on there is of a supremely higher quality than the average article that gets attention on reddit. I see tons of blog bait get taken seriously on here.
My method of getting news is that I have a slightly right and slightly left news source that I read. And then I have reddit to randomly cover stuff people care about more than newspapers.
I don't claim to speak for Mr Sharkey, but for me, the NY Times took a huge credibility hit for their coverage of the run up to the Iraq war. I glanced at a Reuters article regarding the Bundy ranch thing and it was dripping with pro government position bias. All news sources have biases and agendas, and they should be treated accordingly.
As such, I treat all news sources equally...that is, with skepticism.
His sources aren't great. Reuters is OK and obviously NYT provides one side. The biggest problem is a lack of overall sources. There are so many factions vying for control over news that the only way to get anything close to decent exposure is by having a ton of disparate sources to compare semi-evenly.
Check out the site: memorandum.
It's an aggregator for american political news and general national news.
Now this site is fantastic and really keeps you on top of the pulse of what is going on by giving you first and second hand sources from literally all over. Whether its NYT, RT, AlJazeera English, Fox News, Paul Ryan's Facebook page, a tweet posted by Harry Reid's office, Ezra's new site Vox, etc etc.
This site has a ton of conservative/right wing sources. Hot Air, Red State, Wall Street Journal op ed, Fox News, WeaselZippers, Twitchy, TheBlaze, PowerLine, etc. This site doesn't force you click on conservative sources so you can still maintain a bubble, be careful
This site has a ton of liberal/left wing sources. ThinkProgress, DailyKos, NYT op ed, Firedoglake, Ringwingwatch, Liberaland, etc etc but again it doesn't force you to click on any of it so you can maintain a bubble, be careful
This site has a ton of direct sources and mainstream sources. Ukraine stories link things like kyivpost, AP wire stuff is commonly seen, and of course ABC, CBS, CNN, NYT, WSJ, Guardian, and even things like Business Insider and Buzzfeed, and any number of regional news organizations/newspapers, etc.
Check it out. It's incredibly useful for getting a pulse on what's important to each faction, how they're responding to each issue, what issues each faction ignores, and how each faction responds to one another regarding issues. It also helps to see which issues are getting tons of coverage and which are being sidelined.
getting rid of moderators entirely. I've always been shocked that the "front page of the internet" needs vanguards/gatekeepers to "protect" it's users and "optimize" the site functionality. everyone who uses reddit is well versed in Internet culture, so much so that they can adequately decide themselves which links/posts are relevant.
You're either very young or very naive. Show me a single example of a large, user generated content site that has high quality content with zero moderation. You won't find it because it doesn't exist. Even sites like wikipedia would fall apart within days without their admins and power editors. Digg has mods, fark has mods, slashdot has mods, mefi has mods, 99.9% of internet forums has mods.
Some large subreddits have tried to go modless. One subreddit was going to go a full month without mods but after a few days, the community broke down and literally begged the mods to come back. Your belief that reddit would be better off without them stems from an ignorance (or lack of foresight) of what would happen without them. It wouldn't be your bastion of freedom and NSA circlejerking, it would be full of porn, memes and other garbage.
We don't need the removal of mods, we need better mods.
r/worldpolitics says that it operates without removing anything, Here is the automod config that shows that at least automod isn't specifically set up for that. u/IAmAnAnonymousCoward could probably back this up with the mod log, or at least the list of removals. It should be more or less empty if he's on the up and up since the only Automod removal parameter is for zero karma accounts from specific blogs.
That said, r/worldpolitics has 110k users and most articles have few to no comments. Also right now in the subs front page there is a picture comparing jews to Nazis in WW2, a crosspost from TIL about the second bill of rights, and something from davidduke.com. Yeah... That David Duke.
also, lol @ shadowbanning an admin.
Fake edit: [Can't access the r/undelete automod config though.](http://www.reddit.com/r/undelete/wiki/automoderator), though maybe that's just a slip of the mind?
It's actually the only AutoMod non-automatic approval parameter.
Needs to be a limit on how many subreddits someone can mod.
Anyone with too much time on their hands can screw up too many subs.
There is a limit on the number of default subreddits you can mod, it's 3.
I think that mods should only be able to 'hide' posts, more like slashdot, where you can just click the faded minimized text to see it, unless it's illegal, in which case it should be marked as such and checked by admins periodically, especially on the defaults.
The reason for it being hidden should be mentioned when done so. ('Trolling', 'Broke Rule #X', 'Illegal', etc)
While this sounds neat at first to some, we need mods, we just need mods with accountability and transparency. Its harder to be a manipulative asshole when your actions are public and you can be voted out of your position.
There are a few alternatives
May I recommend Al Jazeera America, BBC, NPR, and C-SPAN radio? Taken individually they each have their own biases, but on the whole I tend to think that they balance each other out.
There's a new user-run news site that recently came out of private beta, but I can't remember its name. It takes various stories from social media posted by regular users, and makes it verifiable by everyone. Maybe someone else can chime in if they now what I'm talking about?
Edit: grass wire
Could it be one of the above I listed?
Nope.
[deleted]
Grass wire ?