I (25m) have lost a friend because she (27f) got back with her ex, whom she knows is not right for her.

Non-Romantic

I made a thread not too long ago about how my friend was recently dumped and how sad and depressed she was and I was trying my best to be there for her. Well this past week she decided to wait for him in hopes of coming back. For the week she told me a little more about this guy that I had previously not known, he has two failed marriages, 2 children and his second wife still lives with him (plans on moving out in July apparently though), among other things that would raise a ton of red flags.

She kept coming to me for advice on the matter and every time I would voice my opinions and concerns (when she asked) she would always brush my feelings aside. Now this initially didnt bother me much, I shouldn't be the one making her decisions, however she told me Wednesday night that the main reason she is waiting is because she doesn't want to be lonely. When she told me this I explained to her that wanting to be with someone simply because you're afraid of loneliness is a horrible reason. She got quiet upset by this and basically told me that if I were really her friend I'd support her no questions asked. The thing is, I had been supporting her emotionally for the past two weeks or so, I constantly had to hear about how sad she was and stuff. Her other friends basically told her to grow up and move on, and she thought I'd be more understanding. I was quiet hurt by this and left her apartment without saying much. The next day she tells me that her and her ex are meeting up Friday night to talk things over. I didn't respond because I was still upset about what she said. Later that night she tells me that I'm clearly not the friend she thought I was since I'm just ignoring her. I didn't want to start a fight or anything, so I told her that I want to be there and be supportive as a friend but I can't sit by and watch as she potentially sets herself up for heartache with a man who will likely never be fully committed to her. I told her she was like a sister to me and that I'd always love her and care for her, but that I can't be her constant crutch emotionally because it was draining me emotionally.

Last night, after two days of not speaking she informs me she got back together with this guy. When I read the text I literally shook my head and felt a wave of disappointment go through me. I asked her why, after everything she told me about this guy, after all the heartache she went through, why get back together? She told me that I truly didnt understand her, that a true friend would be happy for her and that I'd understand her decision without having to ask. When she said this I realized that I can't sit by and watch someone I care about put themselves in a situation that will likely end with her getting hurt again. I listed all the reasons she gave me for why she felt he may not all that great for her (she gave me these reasons days after he dumped her), I reminded her how much it hurt when he dumped her.

She basically told me to fuck off and that she can make her own decisions and doesn't deserve criticism from someone like me.

Also before anyone says, I am not in love with her, but yes, I do love her. I have been seeing a wonderful lady for the past 2 weeks as well.

TL;DR: Friend gets dumped, comes to me for support, give her my full support, starts to get mad when I disagree with her decision to wait for her ex, breaks off friendship with me after getting back with her ex and me disapproving of it. I feel lost and hurt.

Posted Jun 22, 2014, 3:22 PM UTC · edited

720
Afronaut0•

Honestly, you should just back off. Adults make stupid decisions all the time, but the consequences will be on her, not you. If you want to waste time and energy acting as a emotional parachute, then go ahead. But don't get salty when she throws you out for her man.

Don't worry about her.

14
uFlo•

This is sound advice.

1
FreeFallFormationOP•

Yeah I know, it's just the fact that a 6 year friendship has ended because of who she is with angers me.

-6
uFlo•

Well then it's her lose, you didn't do anything wrong from what I can see and I'm sure plenty would do the same in your situation.

0
concernedbitch•

I (25m) have lost a friend because she (27f) got back with her ex, whom she knows is not right for herI was presumptuous and paternalistic about choices she made that I didn't agree with. Learn from my mistakes, Reddit!

Fixed!

3†
FreeFallFormationOP•

If I kept throwing my opinion at her sure.

0†
concernedbitch•

Which is what you did.

2
uFlo•

He threw his opinion at her once when she didnt ask for it it seems. She came to him for advice. He may not agree with her, but to tell someone to fuck off when they've been there for you at your lowest is childish.

4
concernedbitch•

Yeah, so after tallying up how many times this dude said he "explained" something to his friend and how much he hated her coming to him for advice while still continuing to do it and setting no boundaries, I have run out of fucks. Neither of these people seem honest about their motivation for continuing the dynamic and his martyr complex isn't any more attractive than her emotional vampirism.

-1
Mindgate•

She sounds as if she has very low self-esteem. When she said that a friend would support her no questions asked you should have said that this is not what friends do. Friends help you avoid bad decisions with advice, and don't just tell you what you want to hear.

Honestly I agree with Afronaut. If she can't accept advice and criticism that goes against her view of things she needs to make her own mistakes. All you can do is be there and catch her fall when she gets out of this mess again, but if she won't listen, there is noch much you can do. You can't force her to do the right thing.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
FreeFallFormationOP•

I see your point. I do see her as a third sister to me and I want to be her friend still, but time apart is most likely the best thing for both of us. I want her to be happy of course and I never meant to come off as some sort of an asshole. If and when things fall apart again I'll be there for her, but I'll have to keep my feelings in check. It's funny though because the girl I've been seeing said I should just allow whatever happens happens and my friend will most likely understand in time I was only looking out for her because I care, but that I can't always make someone see what I see, even if in my mind it's right. Thanks.

Oh I have done the same to a male friend, he eventually dumped her about a week later because he realized that things weren't going to change between them. He thanked me for voicing my opinion, but was glad he got back with her because he learned a valuable lesson. He also told me today that some people basically need to be hurt multiple times before they realize that it's best to walk away and move on and that I should still be there for her if she wants to talk. (He's also friend's with her, but didnt want to get involved with her breakup since he has feelings for her).

1
anusah•

You sound exactly like my friend and let me tell you that it's exhausting. As a friend you should advice her, but also support her through the good AND bad decisions, and certainly not criticize her like you did.

-1†
uFlo•

Sometimes people need to hear criticism when they're setting themselves up for heartache though. She came to him for support and advice, you can't just blindly agree with someone all the time. It doesn't seem like OP did anything too wrong either, just looking out for someone he cares about.

2
anusah•

That's true, he shouldn't agree with everything she says. I still think he should support her through bad decisions though, and that his response to her getting back with her ex was a bit too much.

-2
uFlo•

He didnt say she was dumb or anything. He used examples the she gave to him as to why she felt her ex wasnt a good match. If he just flat out said something like wow you're fucking retarded for going back with this guy than that's different.

Also keep in mind she ended the friendship, not the other way around.

5
anusah•

That's a extreme case..

-2