[WSIG] Help my wife and I with our collection (looking for 2 player+ games)

WSIG

Alright so I've been lurking this subreddit for quite a while and I must say...I love this place! Currently my wife and I are looking for games that can be played with groups but are still fun with just two players. Our collection is currently:

  • Small World

  • Smash Up! (with power level 9000 expansion)

  • Forbidden Desert

  • Elder Sign

  • Love Letter

  • Zombie Dice (with both expansions)

  • Castle Panic

  • Imaginiff

  • Cards Against Humanity

I'm interested in Pandemic, but they announced a bunch of new variants and I'm waiting on those to see how good they are...particularly Pandemic: The Cure. I thought about King of Tokyo but it doesn't look as interesting with only 2 players.

Only restrictions for suggestions are: must be fun with 2 players and shouldn't be more than around $35

Thanks in advance, everyone!

edit: Massive thanks to everyone! I'm going to look over every single recommendation with my wife to see what we should get.

Posted Jul 3, 2014, 2:06 AM UTC · edited

1235
[deleted]•

If you have any interest in trying out some Euro games, I've had great success introducing my girlfriend to both Carcassonne and Castles of Burgundy. She's not a gamer at all and is usually dismissive of those "spreadsheet games" that I play, but she really enjoys both of those. They are within your budget and play well with 2-4. Carcassonne also has a ton of affordable expansions if you enjoy the game and want to increase the complexity later.

9
a1blank•

I'd like to second Castles of Burgundy. It should handle 2 quite well and it seems like it handles scaling great.

King of Tokyo isn't great with 2 players. It only gets fun with 3+ and does really well with 4+.

Tiny Epic Kingdoms (pnp so far, coming out this fall) is fun for 2 players and scales up to 4 quite well. It's a micro 4x game with lots of food components. There are a few issues with the pnp version but it's still totally playable and quite fun and it sounds like they fixed the issues for the retail release.

Race for the Galaxy is worth checking out and I've enjoyed it quite a bit. It's a card based resource game sort of like a cross between 7 Wonders and Dominion. It plays 2 to 4 and an expansion bumps it up to 5. It's also simultaneous action which isn't as big of a deal with 2 players than with 4 or 5, bit it is still nice. In the games I've play, though, most people hate it after their first game. It usually takes a second playthough when people are more familiar with what to expect on the cards that they start to like it.

Dominion, imo, is best played with 2 players and is really fun. Maybe check out the standalone expansion Dark Ages for a pretty different feel with the same awesome base mechanics. The expansions are all fully compatible with the base game so you'd be safe with most of the standalone expansions or the base game. It's a deck-builder/drafting game sort of like a MTG draft. The game has a tremendous amount of replayability due to the large numbers of ways you can pick the cards to play with.

2
junk2saPanamax•

Thirding Castles of Burgundy. Plays really well with 2 people. One of my top games for two.

Dominion is also great with two and infinitely replayable. Lots of value in that box.

2
paullywog77•

While a few people on the Internet have SO's that like race for the galaxy, none of the gamers I play with have SOs that like it, including myself. It's an awesome game though.

I agree with Castles of Burgundy and Dominion. While dark ages is my favorite expansion, I'm pretty sure my wife wouldn't care for it.

1
SgtMaj_ObviousKing of the Corn•

Yeah my SO takes a little (sometimes a lot of) persuading to get to play games with me, but she love love loves Dominion.

1
NotexactlyseriousTerra Mystica•

Pandemic

Agricola (it's 30$ right now at Barnes and Noble! Clearance!)

Smash-up

Core Worlds

Coup

Star Realms

Seasons

Ticket to Ride: Europe

7
thejarvin•

I'd like to second Seasons, it is a brilliant game that plays well with 2. The base game has both intermediate and advanced cards and the expansions really add a nice layer of shine on an already amazing game.

6
tryDyingOP•

Star Realms looks really interesting - I'll have to wait for Amazon to have it at a reasonable price though. It's supposed to be about $15, right?

4
NotexactlyseriousTerra Mystica•

Yeah don't pay more then 15$ for it. It should be back in print soon. In the meantime check out core worlds or seasons. Or any of those other ones (it might be a few months).

3
RoxxorMcOwnageLegend of Soltar•

Hanabi is worth consideration. It is cheap, plays well with two and can be played in a group. Also, co-op.

5
tryDyingOP•

We are definitely looking into Hanabi now! Thanks :)

1
Sixtiesdude64•

My girlfriend and I are currently obsessed with Quantum. We have had so much fun with it two player that we haven't even played with friends yet.

4
whygookPower Grid-Korea•

Flash Point- Cooperative fire fighting game. Works well with two people. You can even take extra roles and each play two characters.

3
gkgThrough the Ages•

Ascension

3
Twopiearr•

Stumbled across an interesting 2 player recently called Dungeon Heroes. One player builds the dungeon 4 tiles at a time, the other player gets 4 actions among 4 party members trying to find the treasures without uncovering the traps or monsters. Once you're out of tiles to place, you start flipping over monsters, and they become meeples you can use to chase the heroes. Amazon has several copies in stock for $30 and if you have an ipad, you can try it out for $4.

3
mdillenbeck•

Ooophf, that budget. I thought Pandemic was $40 - and if you play that a couple of times and like it then I recommend On The Brink immediately (adds a ton of variety to a game that can get stale quickly). That makes it basically a $75 game.

I avoided Pillars off the Earth: Builders Duel for a year, but after getting it as a Christmas gift I find it is an excellent 2 player game.

It is over your budget but Brass is one of the few competitive games my wife enjoys, but you have to get 2 player rules from boardgamegeek. She also likes Seasons, Flash Point Fire Rescue, Quarantine, and Castle Panic quite a bit. I really enjoy Eldritch Horror (again, I'd you like it get the expansion quickly to greatly increase variety or the game will get stale). Amerigo scales from 2-4 players.

Way out of your budget I like Star Trek Fleet Captains and Wear of the Ring. My wife likes Fortune and Glory.

Really in budget we find Bohnanza to be an okay game (and great to play with her mother). Carcassonne the Castle is a decent game also. My wife doesn't like spending lots of time tweaking decks, but Lord of the Rings LCG is played occasionally (she prefers Pathfinder Adventure Card Game). She likes Dungeon Twister the card game also. Agricola All Creatures Big and Small is well designed for 2.

There are tons of games out there, but I find a budget of $50 to $60 opens up a lot more good games than a $30 to $40 budget. However, wait for the holiday sales or shop with $100 at Coolstuff Inc for free shipping will get you games at a discount. I prefer my friendly local game store because they have an excellent staff, plenty of stock, and a decent library to try before you buy.

3
xandrellas•

Brass FTW.

It really begs for 3/4 players but yeah the 2p variant works

2
RussNPMice And Mystics•

Splendor is my current favorite with the wife. It is the only game she has actively asked to play again days later without any prompting from me. I have yet to have anyone not like this game who has played it. It plays very well at 2, 3 or 4.

She also likes pandemic but prefers to play 2 characters each when it's just the two of us playing.

3
Hardbodi3sPuerto Rico•

I'd like to recommend A Few Acres of Snow . Its for 2 players only , and I just recently picked it up and have been really enjoying it. It is a war game where one side is the British and the other is French fighting to take control of Quebec in the 1700s. I find the artwork beautiful and the game very enjoyable , and I picked it up because like you I was looking for a 2 person game. I was not disappointed.

3
simiansaysboardgamerecommender bot author•

Hi! I'm the guy who recently posted about the game recommendation program I wrote. I thought I'd try it out on you. Plugging your loved games into the engine returned the following recommendations.

The numbers to the right are basically a quality score out of 10, where 10 is what it thinks you would like the best. Interestingly, King of Tokyo scored the highest on both scales: confidence of recommendation (they are in ascending order in each list) and quality score. Interestingly enough, the engine has no notion of min/max players but almost exclusively recommended games that have a "recommended with" of 2 players. I weeded out the few that were not recommended for 2 players.

Hope you find this helpful and appreciate any feedback you have!

---OLDER GAMES YOU MAY ENJOY---

Vampire: The Eternal Struggle (1994) (7.0)

Puerto Rico (2002) (8.9)

Race for the Galaxy (2007) (8.4)

Legend of the Five Rings (1995) (8.0)

Stone Age (2008) (9.0)

Ticket to Ride (2004) (8.7)

Pandemic (2008) (9.2)

The Downfall of Pompeii (2004) (9.0)

Citadels (2000) (9.4)

Hey, That's My Fish! (2003) (9.4)

---NEW GAMES YOU MAY ENJOY---

Lords of Waterdeep (2012) (7.9)

Merchants & Marauders (2010) (7.6)

Alien Frontiers (2010) (8.4)

Defenders of the Realm (2010) (8.6)

Ninjato (2011) (8.7)

Seasons (2012) (8.9)

Sentinels of the Multiverse (2011) (10.0)

Forbidden Island (2010) (9.3)

King of Tokyo (2011) (10.0)

3
tryDyingOP•

Wow this is very impressive. You mentioned a bunch of games that we already had our eyes on. Puerto Rico, Pandemic, Seasons, Sentinels of the Multiverse, Forbidden Island, and King of Tokyo are all games we have considered.

1
simiansaysboardgamerecommender bot author•

Cool! Hope it helps!

2
damnimrunningout•

Gloom is a good one.

Morbid but a good laugh also. I love the story telling aspect of it also

2
MoronLessOff•

My wife and I love gloom. It's definitely a go to for us. We don't really elaborate in the story telling, but maybe mention how the bearded man was a dumbass poking hives with a stick...and now he's wounded by wasps...it just seems like a redneck thing to do.

2
howboutme•

I have most of the games that you have so we probably have a similar likes and requirements to get them to the table.

It's hard to go wrong with Hanabi. It plays well with two players but can pace a little rough. It is certainly easier with more players. It is also quite a different co-op than those you have listed. If you get it, just throw the rainbow cards in right away. It does make it a hair more difficult, but just play them as their own suit. It's probably my filler of choice.

I would suggest you play Pandemic before you buy it. It is a bit close mechanically to Forbidden Desert. It's a better game than Forbidden Desert, but it will likely scratch the same type of itch. It's also not much better.

Splendor is my current couples game of choice. It's a competitive yet simple engine building game. It has a variety of playstyles that work with it. For example, you can focus on getting out cheap but no point cards in order to do a run on the nobles, you can focus on point giving cards, or do any type of hybrid play. I wish it was a bit more thematic, but as it is, it is good.

2
Agen7_0range•

Dominion, 7 Wonders (2P variant), Ticket to Ride, Qwirkle, Pandemic, Forbidden Island/Desert, Marvel Legendary....just a few from my wife and my 2+ collection and wish list as well.

2
SgtMaj_ObviousKing of the Corn•

While I'm not a huge fan of the 7 Wonders 2 player variant, the game is a great part of any collection simply because of its scalability. It plays up to 7 players in about the time it takes to play any other number of players. Definitely one to consider when looking to expand your collection.

2
ultrapingu•

Of the ones I have/have tried:

Small World; No comment, some people really like this, I can't put my finger on why but I don't like it.

Forbidden desert; This plays a lot like pandemic, which I personally prefer over it. If you already have pandemic then you'd just be getting a game with a different thematic.

Love Letter; I would highly recommend this. It plays quickly, and we've had a lot of fun with 2, 3, and 4 players. I'd say it plays best with 2.

Zombie dice; I had fun with this, but it is incredibly light weight. Had no fun with it 2 player, but I can imagine it is more fun with more players.

Cards against humanity; Tons of fun, but I'm not sure if you can play with two players. If you can I can't imagine it being much fun. For playing in a group or at a party though, it is excellent.

As someone else mentioned, carcassonne is a really good 2+ player game. I'd consider this essential to my collection.

2
[deleted]•

I can't recommend Cards against Humanity for 2 players...but for more than 2 it is great.

4
timotab•

have you had a look at the two player recommendations section of our wiki?

1
tryDyingOP•

I did. That's where I saw Pandemic which caught my attention...but after looking up more info on it, I think I would rather wait to see if I would prefer one of the new ones instead.

Summoner Wars, Mage Wars, and Memoir '44 look great but are a bit out of our price range at the moment.

I looked at all the suggested games in the wiki. Actually that's how we ended up buying some of the games in our collection :)

2
[deleted]•

Mage Wars is on of the best 2p games I've ever played. There's so much depth.

1
nimbyard•

Maybe you could just look at one of the other thousand identical posts, but asking again is okay too.

-8
a_stale_pancake•

your attitude sickens me, mister!

3
nimbyard•

So I guess you are completely fine with this sub not advancing itself in any way?

-1