Chocolate Porter tasting "alcoholic / hot" - what can I do?

I sanitized 4oz of cacao nibs with 4oz of clear rum (the general recommendation had been to use vodka, but I didn't have any, and I read that clear rum was an acceptable substitute), and then added both the nibs and the rum to a keg and racked the porter on top of it. It's been "set-and-forget" carbing for a couple of weeks and I tasted it yesterday.

It tastes great, but I can sort of taste the rum as part of the aftertaste (BJCP scoresheet would describe it as "warming effect of ethanol and higher alcohols.") Hydrometer readings (before adding the rum) showed an ABV of 5.6%, and the rum should have added another 0.2% or so for a total of 5.8%.

Was including the rum (or using rum in the first place) a mistake? Any way to fix it? Or RDWHAHB and age it longer?

If it is what it is and nothing is going to change that, is there a more appropriate BJCP category for something like this besides 21A?

Posted Jul 7, 2014, 6:33 PM UTC

26
ATXBeermaker•

What temperature was the beer fermented at? Could it be fusel alcohols from high fermentation temps rather than heat from the rum addition?

3
mrthedonOP•

64F using a fridge with temp controller. Safale S-04

1
Nickosuave311The Recipator•

It's probably not the rum's fault. I'm guessing you fermented too warm: Fusel alcohols (long-chained alcohols) bring a warming, alcoholic sensation and are produced by the yeast being too warm during fermentation. Anything above 68-70 degrees encourages their production in ales, so if you fermented any warmer than this (depending on yeast strain of course) then it's likely due to fermentation.

2
mrthedonOP•

Ferm temp was appropriate for the strain. I also tasted it before adding the rum and didn't detect the same "hotness".

1
BretBeermann•

How good was your rum?

1
mrthedonOP•

Bacardi Superior.

I'm not a rum connoisseur so I have no idea where that falls on the quality scale. :)

1