r/yugioh•
GoneWithLaw

Weekly Hub and Meta Talk Thread: Week of July 27th

Updated: 7/29

###Important Links

###Subreddit Events

  • Banner Contest - Deadline for entries will be extended through the end of July 28th. Including today, that's two extra days to make a banner! Voting will go up on the 29th
  • Tournament - Currently at Round 7
  • Tournament is in Round 8
  • Tournament is in its Final Round!

###Updates and Community Feedback

We got a lot of good feedback in the last thread, and we'd like to do some follow-up on it this week.

##R/F Submission guidelines and community expectations

There some concerns voiced over the quality of a good number of R/F submissions. The opinions on a potential Casual/Competitive split in standards were, well, split, so we won't be going forward with that for not. That said, there was a consensus among those who posted that there should be more done to help promote the quality of R/F submissions across the board. We have Super and Ultra R/F posts already, but if the community has any further suggestions for improving R/F posts, bring them up here!

Additionally, there was also mentioned the possibility of adding incentives for providing good commentary and fixes on R/F submissions. We'll be working on how to reward good contributions here, but more community feedback here will also be appreciated!

##Recognition of quality posts: "Trophy Case"

u/shatnersprodigy brought up the excellent idea of having a "Trophy Case" of quality posts of all types. He further brought up in this comment having the community nominate these posts in a weekly series of threads. I personally like this idea, but would like some feedback on how you would best like to see this implemented, or perhaps Super and Ultra R/F threads could be incorporated into this.

##Mod Suggestion: Multiple Submit buttons

Several subreddits have these, but how would you feel about multiple submit buttons in the sidebar? What I mean is that clicking a different button will take you to either a different weekly thread, a different subreddit, or a general submit page with pre-made text. For example, the buttons could be the following (with better phrasing!):

  • General link submissions
  • General text submissions
  • Submit a basic question (Q&A Thread)
  • Submit a ruling question (Rulings Thread)
  • Submit your Trades (/r/YGOBinders)
  • Submit your Sales (/r/YGOSales)

##Thoughts on AutoMod so far

There were some minor bumps with AutoMod on the first day (totally my fault for forgetting to change some settings from my test subreddit), so sorry about that! Otherwise, we'd like to hear your thoughts on your experiences with AutoMod so far, and if you feel any changes are necessary. Additionally, any further thoughts on our previous AutoMod discussion would also be appreciated.

##General Subreddit improvements

If you have any suggestions for promoting quality submissions, cutting down on crap, new features, designs, etc., this is the place to post and chat about them! If we mods come up with stuff ourselves, you guys will be the first to know.

Posted Jul 27, 2014, 8:39 PM UTC · edited

57
Loading comments…