ELI5: How can people not swim?

Explained

If you throw a dog in the pool, its going to start doggy paddling. It doesn't need classes or familiarity to water.

Personally, I'm not a very strong swimmer, but if I fall into a body of water, I can at least not drown.

Posted Aug 4, 2014, 3:50 AM UTC

023
Fishercat•

Lots of people who can't swim are afraid of drowning. If they fall in, they panic, do everything wrong, and end up aspirating water.

10
WavyGlass•

Just to back you up, I would say that I'm a non-swimmer. I am very afraid of deep water. Deep meaning anything over six feet. I can float on my back. Taught myself to. I can also kick my legs. If I realize I am in deep water I will panic and drop like rock. If I manage to calm myself enough to get to the surface and float I'm still so panicked that I forget to kick and start sinking and flailing again. I know it's irrational but it happens every time. I was at a water park this week and damn near drowned in the wave pool.

2
ragajagajingjong•

People who didn't grow up around water may have a fear of it. I'm a strong swimmer and former lifeguard, and I still get creeped out by being in deep water where I can feel things against my feet (like dead trees or reeds). Humans don't have an innate instinct on how to swim, and coupled with a fear of the unknown, this can lead to panic, desperation, and thrashing about.

5
helpawaythrowOP•

That's pretty interesting. Do animals not go into this panic mode then?

1
poopinbutt2014•

Animals can drown too. My childhood dog nearly drowned once when he fell into our neighbor's pool. Some animals seem to know what to do innately, others don't. Humans aren't born knowing how to swim either, we have to be taught or get the hang of it through practice.

2
clearliquidclearjar•

A dog drowned in my mom's pool. When they found him he was just sort of standing on the bottom, head down, dead.

2
AccioSud•

I believe it's because swimming is not a human instinct.

5
helpawaythrowOP•

Is this true? It just seems weird to me. My dogs can swim. I'm sure if I tossed my cat in a pool even he could paddle his way out.

4
Teotwawki69•

Cats and dogs are better balanced to naturally float at the surface -- their lungs are horizontal, and below their heads. When they hit the water, they naturally start walking, and this motion translates into the doggy paddle, so they're going to wind up swimming without thinking.

Humans are built differently and we don't naturally float. Thin people can sink because they don't have the buoyancy of fat. Fat people can wind up with their stomachs and/or asses floating while everything else sinks. Our natural walking motion also doesn't move us forward in water, it just keeps us in place. This is what "treading water" is, and doing that can be very tiring very quickly.

Finally, as others have mentioned, we know that we can't swim while dogs and cats don't, so we can easily panic if we fall into water, which leads to all kinds of flailing around, which also helps to make us sink and breathe in water and drown.

EDIT: Typoes*

^^* ^^I ^^know

3
helpawaythrowOP•

Thank you, I think this is the best explanation. :)

2
pobody•

Yes, humans can flail around and "not drown" for a short amount of time. But because they don't know how to efficiently move by default, if they are not near land or something they can grab, they will drown.

3
helpawaythrowOP•

Am I overestimating the amount of people that drown in pools then? I feel like I've read stories of people falling into pretty shallow bodies of water and drowning.

1
sobok•

Lolwat. I've never heard of that, with the exception of very small children who are unsupervised.

Remember, if it makes the news, it's probably an anomaly

1

For how long? Plane crash in the ocean ok? Large lake maybe?

But for people who just flat out can't swim, it's usually 'cause they never learned. People don't have the luxury of acting purely on instinct; our unique brand of consciousness gets in the way.

It's a lot easier to learn things that require physical coordination like swimming (dancing, acrobatics, sports stuff, etc.) when you're a little kid. If you grew up somewhere where there was nowhere to swim, you'll likely not know how to do it.

These sorts of things are much harder to learn as an adult, plus you throw good old-fashioned panic in the mix, and it's pretty easy for a lot of people to drown.

2
helpawaythrowOP•

I just don't believe that there's literally no instinct for that. I remember when I was a kid we had this dog that was as old as time. Blind, deaf, couldn't walk, no teeth and one day it fell into the pool and swam out on her own. How could an adult human being not be able to do that?

2
sobok•

An instinct is something that's ingrained to us at birth - by definition it can't be taught.

If we had any sort of instinct around water, small children being unsupervised around pools wouldn't be such a big deal

3
helpawaythrowOP•

I just assumed it was because they don't have motor skills. I mean, its an instinct to lift up our heads too, but babies can't do that. I don't think a puppy would be able to swim either.

1
sobok•

Throw a puppy in the water, they totally do. They move just like they should, human babies, even if they can crawl... Sink. Shit, even toddlers and small kids do

Humans are terrible at instinct survival, we seriously lack.

2

Didn't say we don't have instinct. Babies usually hold their breath and swim if you put them in water. Adults stop to think about it though.

If you throw an adult who can't swim in water they're damn sure going to try to swim, but they'll be thinking about how they're moving their arms, how they're moving their legs, wondering when they're supposed to breath, etc. They'll probably swim a little bit, but those who don't fall naturally into the act of swimming will wear themselves out so fast they won't get to the edge of the water.

Panic is also a game-changer. If you throw someone who knows they can't swim into a lake, they're going to panic. They'll flail around, freak out, hyperventilate, and eventually inhale enough water to kill themselves.

As a practically non-swimmer, I was told by lifeguards in the Army, Hawaii, and some other Pacific islands that if I ever found myself in deep water I should float on my back and slowly backstroke to shore. It's the easiest way to keep breathing and it doesn't matter if I get tired 'cause I can just float. If I hadn't been made to practice that though, I'd try to swim like everyone else does, face down. Non-swimmers don't get very far doing that.

Floating isn't even 100% reliable in natural bodies of water. The smallest waves can still wash over your face when you're floating on your back, so if one hits you when you're inhaling, especially if you're hyperventilating because you're scared that you're going to drown, you'll suck in a bunch of water which increases panic. it's not easy to hold your breath and time the next one just right when you're freaking out.

There's also the problem that swimming is a weak instinct in humans. The other great apes can't swim at all because of the shape of their shoulders. Humans have been a swim-capable shape for only about one or two million years, so we're not great at it.

We're also still the wrong shape for swimming. Dogs and their antecedents have been roughly the same shape for millions and millions of years with legs that hang down from their torsos underneath their lungs. It balances them much better in water. Our long muscular legs that stick straight out from our spines turn into anchors of muscle and bone in water. The end result is that we have to work much harder to stay afloat than a dog/cat/mouse/horse/elephant.

TL;DR Swimming doesn't come naturally to everyone, that's why I stay in the mountains.

2
apatheticviews•

Legs are full of muscle. Muscle is not buoyant. It is literally dragging you down.

Your chest is full of air. It is "trying" to hold you up. Depending on how muscular the rest of your body is, your head may or may not be sitting above or below water.

2
reking•

Not swim? Well, OK... couldn´t you just hold up your arms and press them back: Boom, boom. Boom, boom. Boom, boom. Boom, boom. Boom, boom. Boom, boom.

1