Three years ago after Egypt fell to the Muslim Brotherhood conservatives warned of the Islamic Caliphate, and the left smugly mocked them.
Posted Aug 27, 2014, 4:04 PM UTC
Posted Aug 27, 2014, 4:04 PM UTC
The far left has historically been wrong with pretty much all of their predictions throughout the last 100 years.
History has a distinct conservative bias.
Don't stoop to that level. It provides no substance to the argument. At least provide some examples and then say it. Otherwise people can literally say "history has a distinct ______ bias" and claim the same thing.
[deleted]
[deleted]
History is written by the victors...
Those damn privileged conservatives.
The far right has as well. Generally the farther you get from the center, the less likely you're judging the facts impartially, leading to wrong answers.
The far right has as well.
Islamic caliphate, Obamacare failing, stimulus failing, cash for clunkers failing, Russia, Syria, Obama failing, Obama's socialism, Medicare falling apart, deficit spending... Almost the entire state of affairs today was predicted by the far right.
Instead of an elephant, our party logo ought to be Nostradamus.
Well you're listing a bunch of things that are pretty subjective and general. For instance, I think anybody on the other side of the aisle would scoff at you saying conservatives predicted things like "Obama failing, Obama's socialism, Obamacare failing, Stimulus failing" as those are all intentionally inflammatory remarks you and I both know can't be proven, at least for many many years.
As far as Medicare falling apart, it still works, just not how you or I may like.
As for deficit spending, come on. We as a nation haven't been debt free (and have therefore been deficit spending) since 1835, that's such a silly thing to say.
Syria and the IC are pretty much the same point.
You're right about Russia, cash for clunkers, and the IC, but there are, by order of magnitude, more wrong predictions every day than there are right ones. When you look at a liberal criticizing a prominent conservative, it seems like they predict every possible thing that can go wrong, then parade around when one of those million things does, proud of being right.
Well I hate to say it, but conservatives are just as guilty. For everything Obama says or does, someone on the far right predicts it will fail or he'll be wrong. So yes, there are correct predictions. But both parties are just as fallible as the other.
But both parties are just as fallible as the other.
It's not a matter of parties. It's a matter of ideas. We don't predict that everything Obama does will fail. We predict liberalism will fail (as it always has). It's just that everything Obama does is far left liberalism. Liberal ideology is just wrong, will always be wrong, and will always produce the same failures.
I seriously despise Rachel Maddow. She turns everything and I mean everything into how the republicans are at fault. Has she ever owned up to how wrong she was about the muslim brotherhood and the Islamic Caliphate?? No way.
Anyone with any knowledge of the region knew what was going to happen as soon as Mubarak fell. Obama and his crony's in the media either didn't care or were too oblivious to accept it. Fortunately the unexpected part was the Egyptian military restoring secularism.
[deleted]
Not unexpected, Egypt has historically been secular. And I don't think they didn't care, they just didn't want to interfere in the Democratic process, as that would seem hippocritical.
Maddow is the epitome of the smug stupidity of the American left. Great example.
Your comma seems to, be slightly misplaced
whoops :)
Happens to the best of us :)
Well... there is his/her user name... so yeah...
Fuck MSNBC I want nothing to do with that shit.
Heres my opinion though, I lean more libertarian than traditional conservative but its their mistake to make. America isnt the world police, let them do what they want to do when it blows up in their faces they will have no one to blame but themselves.
The problem with letting a group like ISIS "do what they want until it blows up in their face" is that it won't blow up in their face until someone like us blows it up for them.
that's the problem with the libertarian mindset: they want to ignore problems while they're small shouting "neocon!" and "imperialism!" whenever someone suggests nipping it in the bud.
if their approach to foreign policy ever took hold, we'll be using nuclear weapons against too-large enemies eventually.
I was speaking specifically about the Muslim Brotherhood.
ISIS was a series of fails most of which involved the US government.
[deleted]
I didn't.
You really believe ISIS is just going to slowly destroy itself into non-existence?
can we call it WASWAS when it does?
I do not believe that IS (I personally hate referring to them as such) was considered when the Muslim brotherhood was making such a statement. They are completely different groups with no relation in ideology or beliefs.
Here's the current Conservative media template:
[$TIME] ago, [$commentator] warned about [$BadPolicyDecisionBy(Obama|Democrats)], and the Left smugly mocked them.
Let's start listing the bad policy decisions that are coming back to haunt the Dems:
Obamacare
Ukraine/Russia
ISIS/Islamic Terrorism in Iraq
I don't even know where to go with this list because there are so many examples, but these are the latest ones.
Ukraine/Russia
Immigration, stimulus package, deficit spending, green energy, bankrupting coal, Al Qaeda in Yemen...
How is Obamacare failing? Genuinely hadn't heard much bad about it other than the website snafu.
Would you have advocated military intervention in Ukraine? Just want to get a baseline of what the options were.
And how did democrats contribute to the rise of ISIS? As I understand, that's more a consequence of a destabilized area due to war.
Obama said that healthcare bills would be reduced by $2500/year, when most people are paying $5000-$7500 a year more in premiums and deductibles. People are being cut back to >28 hours/week in order for employers to escape the insurance mandate, and the individuals are still on the hook to purchase health insurance.
Romney said that Russia is the US' biggest geopolitical foe during the 2012 debates, and was mocked by Obama. Romney was proven right when Russia invaded Ukraine and took Crimea.
Obama cut and ran from Iraq without leaving a stabilizing force. He also demanded that Assad in Syria not attack the "rebels" who have been proven are ISIS, now marching across Syria and Iraq, murdering non-Muslims left and right. Dozens of Conservative pundits said that bailing out of Iraq and getting involved in Syria would end badly, and it has.
I do agree that for younger people, the plans seem too expensive. As for the hours, I think that may have a positive to it; in that having fewer full time employees creates more part time jobs for the unemployed.
Yeah, you're right about that. But consider that Obama has to deal with the Ruskies on a daily basis, and probably was in a tough spot where he didn't want to raise tensions with them. Romney was under no such pressure. But I do agree with you.
As a recently former Soldier, I don't think there was any way we were going to stabilize Iraq to a point where it would have remained peaceful after we left, so I think it was the right call to cut our losses and stop losing our boys over there. That place was going to be fucked either way, and I don't want to die for it.
Obamacare was designed to fail, because the left wing radicals want single payer. Obamacare was designed to bankrupt insurance companies, and make health care providers bad guys for charging high prices for services.
I think it's more pro-conservative than you give it credit for. Think about it; people can't just mooch off the system anymore by getting free ER trips; they HAVE to have insurance. No more of what was effectively welfare before by letting taxpayers cover those bills.
I just wonder how much money and blood it would take to solve this problem. I don't think we as a people have the appetite to solve this one. Its unfortunate but let those people solve their own problems we can exert outside pressure. Poor handling by Obama to not strike hard at the beginning.
http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2011/01/egypt-us-foreign-policy-at-nadir.html
We find among the most perspicacious American commentators something extraordinary, an awareness of reality which approaches actual moral consciousness. The power conservatives at Powerline, for instance, write:
My guess is that Arab dictatorships, like autocracies elsewhere, will prove surprisingly brittle once they are challenged. What the current unrest will lead to is anyone's guess, but there is no reason to think that more popular input will lead to friendlier regimes. Instead, we may see more Irans and Gazas. Be that as it may, there is a certain relief in seeing the dam finally break and the ossified, archaic, anti-free enterprise ruling elites of the Arab world come tumbling down.
Here is the true arsonist's logic, approaching real mens rea - almost, but not quite, a conscience. Of course, if I throw a Molotov cocktail into this church, it will burn down. Lives may be lost. Lives will be lost! But, I mean, what a flammable building. Look - the whole thing is made entirely of wood. Even the siding. And it's such an ugly, cheap, common little building. And besides, those horrible snake-handling Pentecostalists...
On so many issues today, especially in foreign policy, this is the difference between the American liberal and the American conservative. The liberal delights in the fire - he hates the church, this church, any church, all churches. Once it is burned down, he thinks, it can be replaced by a modern, handicapped-accessible and well-stocked library. His reforming impulse is founded in cupidity, in the human lust for power, but above them he has built a charming little cottage of delusions and good intentions.
The conservative knows that burning the church is wrong. He knows that nothing will be built on the rubble, that it will remain a heap of charred bricks and snake corpses for years and perhaps decades. But he also knows that some liberal will burn the church if he doesn't; he, too, is human and delights in the sight of flame; and he's not a Pentecostalist. So he goes right along and flicks his Bic.
Obama and Obama's supporters want Islamists to rule over Arabia instead of secularists, because Islamists will always oppose the American right, but secular leaders are less predictable.
Why hide this in a conservative subreddit?
And 12 years ago, when people across the spectrum were warning that invading Iraq would lead to chaos throughout the region, the right smugly mocked them.
It would seem to me that politicians from both sides are pretty bad when it comes to predictions.
Even if you agreed with her, I don't understand how any can sit through a Rachel Maddow show. Her snarkiness makes her so unlikable.
There's a certain form of condescension and self-righteousness mixed with self-hatred that is exclusive to the liberal commentators. You don't see the pundits on the right bring out the mockery and profanity the way the left does. It's what you do when your (specious) argument can't stand up on its own merits.
(not really related to the OPs point, but I just couldn't help myself).
I was just thinking the same thing. "The Left smugly mocked them."
It's the left. Are they capable of doing anything without doing it 'smugly'?
Smog checks for cars, smug checks for journalists.
http://imgur.com/xfVG0bh
Aren't Bill O'Reilly and Rush Limbaugh pretty guilty of that?
Tbh I can't stand MSNBC or FOX news, they're both disdainful of views contrary to their own
Bill O'Reilly seems to appeal to the left in some way. You see him with Jon Stewart at least once a year. It's probably his educational background they can't simply ignore him as ignorant. Maybe it's his humor as well.
Rush is comedic about his smugness. "Proven right 99.6% of the time." "Excellence in broadcasting." etc. Maddow smug in the shittiest most condescending way possible.
The Excellence in Broadcasting is because he is part of the EiB network. The Excellence in Broadcasting network.
I think you may think he's funny because you agree with him more, and people who like Maddow probably think she's funny too. I just think they're both tools that inflame the other side of the aisle to the point that we can't discuss anything reasonably.
When was the last time Madcow used a self deprecating phrase like "illustrating absurdity by being absurd"? Limbaugh does this regularly. Maddow is pompous, arrogant and generally unpleasant.
I can agree that there's attitude on both sides. I think the difference is that the Right does it more in a writing off way, or a "whatever". Almost like they know they are right, and they know they can't can't change the lefts mind.
Liberals on the other hand just get pissed when you hold an opposing view as if they think they can change your mind.
As a left leaning independent, I find myself agreeing with you more than I like to admit. I like to hear other opinions, that's why I joined this subreddit. I disagree with a lot of stuff I've seen here, but I've found that if I respectfully make a counterpoint, the response is rarely negative. I have not had nearly the same experience with liberal forums.
I find it ironic that this is the more open-minded group.
Thanks for the insight.
I find conservatives aren't out to change the world, they just want things to stay the way they are (for the most part, or at least in the moral sense)
Liberals, obviously want change, their main vehicle for change is activism (protests, rallies, campaigns etc). Conservatives don't really know how to do this. Exhibit A) every tea party gathering ever.
A liberal throws a red paint filled water balloon at the local puppy mill, while the conservative says "this country is going to hell" at the nightly news.
Of course there are exceptions, and a lot of Conservatives are very active and passionate about what we stand for and against.
I think you've got a point though, that attitude is almost everything.
Agreed, she is so irritating and frames all issues around her cool-aid narrative.
guess you've never seen dennis miller
Bill O'Reilly of the left