Coinbase Multisig Vault
coinbase.com/multisigPosted Oct 29, 2014, 5:10 PM UTC
Posted Oct 29, 2014, 5:10 PM UTC
This is actually good news.
They still know who you are and track you, they are a MSB and respond to Fintrac.
There is no privacy with Coinbase.
PLEASE READ this open letter https://bitcoinfoundation.org/forum/index.php=3f/topic/1132-open-letter-to-bitcoin-businesses-why-im-closing-my-accounts/
this. use a multisig wallet that doesn't know your identity. there are plenty out there. u/changetip 1 lawsky
But if you're buying thru coinbase anyway, it's not as if you've purchased anonymously. At least the multi sig vault is a big step up in user control for people buying from coinbase.
u/lalamin1, token_dave wants to send you a Bitcoin tip for 1 lawsky (2.025 mBTC/$0.69). Follow me to collect it.
They still know who you are and track you, they are a MSB and respond to Fintrac.
And why exactly should I be concerned about that?
Because privacy is important to some people. That's the whole reason BitCoin was created as I understand it.
[deleted]
Trustless solution Coinbase does not have access to any bitcoin stored in the multisig vault. You can send your bitcoin without using Coinbase through our open-source recovery tool.
Very good Coinbase!
48 hour withdrawal policy?
Yup, same 48 hour withdrawal clearance period.
It is however 0 for group multisig vaults involving multiple parties. Because phishing risks there are much lower.
It is also always possible to bypass the clearance period by manually withdrawing using our open-source recovery tool: https://github.com/coinbase/multisig-tool
That's their standard vault security feature I believe, to help prevent unauthorised access. Sounds like you can use their recovery tool to sweep funds immediately to an address you control though, by using the user key, along with the shared key (decrypted with user password). In that case, no action by coinbase is needed to move the coins.
[deleted]
Is in-browser crypto strong enough to do this securely?
Seems like having to be connected to the internet while generating your private key opens up some attack vectors.
The in-browser crypto is considered strong enough, yes.
Being online can be an attack vector if your computer is compromised. One way around this is to use a group vault with multiple co-signers on different machines.
I see there are 3 keys:
COINBASE KEY
The only key that Coinbase stores. Enables you to sign transactions from your Coinbase account.
SHARED KEY
Encrypted with your password and stored both by you and Coinbase.
USER KEY
Stored by you and can be used to sign transactions without Coinbase.
Am I correct in my assessment that this is implying that Coinbase does not store users' unencrypted passwords in any way (just the encrypted versions of them)? In other words, Coinbase is completely incapable of signing with the SHARED KEY without having the password provided by you, because they flat-out do not have access to it?
If so, when the user resets their account password, is a new SHARED KEY generated?
And how can a user key alone be used to sign transactions? Is it a 1-of-3?
As I understand it, the USER KEY cannot be used alone to sign transactions, it must be paired with the SHARED KEY in order to be able to sign without involving Coinbase. Meaning it's a 2-of-3.
Does this introduce an AML compliance problem? With this system, Coinbase has no way of denying a user access to their own funds.
Heaven forbid a user has access to his or her own funds.
A seriously good question. Fascinating implications of this system.
This is correct.
To manually withdraw, you'd combine the User Key with the Shared Key that you would decrypt using your password.
Correct, Coinbase in completely incapable of signing without your passphrase. Coinbase account password has nothing to do with these 3 keys. You need a separate vault passphrase to encrypt the shared key.
Some more info: http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/2kowq3/introducing_multisig_vault_you_can_now_control/clncggm
Or just inject JavaScript and grab your password
Ah, makes much more sense now. Clever setup!
I think this is where the user key comes in. From the diagram it says you need both the coinbase key and user key to recover lost password which I think means they are going to generate a new multisig address using the new password and send the bitcoins there. If you have lost both the user key and password you are screwed.
I'm still wondering what the actual security implications are though. If I stored my user key insecurely (let's say on Dropbox with insecure password), someone could hack into it, steal the user key, and use the password recovery feature to send the coins to a new multisig key, bypassing my password. Guess it seems to me instead of being doubly secure, it could be doubly vulnerable? (password + user key storage are both attack vectors now)
I haven't made a vault yet so not sure if this is the case. Maybe Coinbase has a good set of security verifications you need to pass before resetting passwords.
You need user key, shared encrypted key, and vault passphrase to steal your coins. See: http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/2kowq3/introducing_multisig_vault_you_can_now_control/clncggm
I like the Coinbase Vault. Works fine and is an extra measure of security. The Coinbase Paper Wallet is great also. Can be your own vault if properly stored in a safe place.
In the event that this blog becomes unavailable, bookmark the recovery tool:
Seems like a lot of fuss for what is more easily managed yourself with one private key. What's the advantage (other than lack of privacy)?
convenience and safety nets: http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/2kowq3/introducing_multisig_vault_you_can_now_control/clncggm
So Coinbase stores two keys - and if both of those keys are stolen, the hacker can take everything from the user? Not sure how that improves on the old Coinbase wallet then.
The shared key is encrypted and only the user has the passphrase.
Thank you.
I think this kind of service is the best response to the Bitlicense, demonstrating that technology can produce better consumer protection solutions than regs.
This is exactly the last paragraph of the letter I sent to NYDFS:
"Declare a moratorium on digital currency regulation; Encourage firms to be based in New York; Let the market innovate and protect itself through cryptography."