Protoss Macro?

Hi guys,

So I'm switching back from Terran, however, now that I've improved my macro as a player, I wanted to ask a question about Protoss macro. As Terran, you're always making scvs, always making supply depots, and always using EVERY building you have to make units. However, I feel like in mid game as Toss, when you're moving over to a different tech, you don't have the resources to use all of your buildings anymore. Same thing with early game, with gate robo expand for example. Your robo finishes, but you only have enough resources to lay down that robo bay, not to make anything out of the robo. Is this normal? Or should I always be pumping obs/immortals and delay the robo bay?

Also, when you do a two base all in, you stop making probes yes? That's a very foreign idea to me.

I guess I'm just a little confused about how toss macro works. If you guys could help me out, that would be great. Thanks!

Posted Nov 14, 2014, 1:42 PM UTC

28
sc2Coldflame•

My basic advice to increase someone's win rate is to make as little gateway units as possible. (if you are all-ining, ignore this and all in with as MANY units as possible) The idea as stated by another is that gateway units are NOT your main source of dmg and should be viewed as purely tanks. Compariativly to other races "mid-teir" units protoss units are tankier but do not deal as much dmg, Thus you rely on AOE, so getting to colossi, and HT are super important. For the most part it does not matter which you go first, as long as you realize you are going to need both.

Little Tid bit, the ONLY 2 units in the protoss army that perform well on their own, are Immortals (obviously vs ground units), and archons. Everything else gets its power from synergy with other units. Not to say other units cannot be good such as stalkers in a blink all in, or flanking chargelots, its to see that protoss relies on syngeries, thus you need to make as many different units as possible to have a complete army. (its also the reason why protoss goes for the deathball)

3
VELL1•

As a rule, if you think you are safe - start teching.

And while you are teching you are extremely vulnerable, pretty much all terran timings are are meant to exploit our transitions. Immortals are good, but Colosi are better (sittuational). So if you think you can get a colosi before he attacks, go into colosi, if it doesn't seem possible try to get an immortal. I mean, if you don't see terran move out at first, they are probably waiting for the medivacks. So untill they are done you are in a good shape - tech like crazy.

That's why we have sentries. When you fast tech, you need to know what your opponent is doing and then need to block him on your ramp if he decides to engage and you are not ready. I mean it depends on the match too, kind of hard to give you an advise there.

If you are playign against terran, even if I am going straight to robo bay, I pump at least 2-3 observers, otherwise drops are going to pick you apart.

If I am playing zerg, I am not too heavy on the observers. It's pretty much customary to get at least one observer before the colosi regardless of the match though. Some pros make enough to pretty much cover the whole map. Depends on the style you are playing. I find immortals to be fairly weak in PvT...I add them only after I have colosi.

2
ChlckenChaser•

dont want to derail the thread or anything, but im a high plat toss that was dianmond in WoL, and im having real trouble defending against terran drops. Most of my losses vs terran are when im ahead but the drops just pull me apart. What do you do with your obs to spot drops? leave it over his army to see when the medivacs split? or have it patrolling around your base to spot them in advance?

1
VELL1•

Well I try to do both. Now terrans very often scan themselves first to make sure there are no observers and then do drops. So having observers on top of their army often is not enough. On 2 bases I have at least 3 observers. One around ramp on my natural, one on their ramp which I then use to follow their army when they move out and one around common drop route.

Once you go to 3 bases you need to start putting pylons to spot his army and his drops.

1
somerandomtoss•

Well there is a number of scenarios when you might choose not to produce out of your buildings, but that is very strategy based. So if you going 2 range less colossus in to fast storm, you stop producing from your robo as soon as you have 2-3 obs and 2 colossus out while investing in TC tech route. All in all our army don't come in 1 size fits all package, you have actually think what you need to produce, not blindly go for that mmm mix.

Early game you only want as little gateway units as possible without dying, and all your spare money goes in to teching.

2 base all ins are aimed at hitting precise timing, otherwise they wouldn't work so you can make only so much probes and afterwards all money goes in to army.

1
sfoperatorOP•

I've read somewhere that Protoss is kind of like Zerg+Terran, where you kind of bank your units in gateway numbers (like Zerg would in larva) unless you were building up for a timing, and you would constantly produce out of your tech buildings appropriately, of course unless you're going something like HT which then you would make them as early as possible to build up energy. Is this true?

1
somerandomtoss•

Well I don't think it is: you usually have a set BO/game plan in mind I do this and then I do that (tech wise). You gateway units are meat shield (except HT, and blink-stalkers in case of blink all in), so it is not like zerg storing larva, you want your main tech units to survive no matter what, and you can only replace your meat shield fast.

Also you don't always produce from your tech buildings. You channel your recourses in to tech path that you think will give you advantage. Lets take standartish BO of expand in to SG in PvZ. After expand you build SG and produce 4-5 phoenix out of it, and then it stands still for most of the game (unless zerg goes muta), while you going in to other teches to get an advantage. Or let's take late game PvT: after big fight terran is left with a lot of Vikings, you Robo's will mostly stay idle as you will produce HT based army, and try to hit fast and hard before terran gets number of ghosts up.

What am I trying to say, you can't "bank on gates" and produce units when you need (like zerg would with larva), and you can't always produce out of your tech buildings (like terran would), you must know what, when and how many to produce.

2
Zerashk_•

I think the answer here is a Yes, but with exceptions.

Yes, our warpgates function largely the same as Zerg larva as in you want them idle and not making units unless you need them (like zerg wants to be making drones, or banking larva (aka not making army)). BUT the big difference here is that you must invest 150 min each into a building that will (for the most part) sit idle until you need it. That is why u/somerandomtoss pointed out that the units that come out of a lot of idle gateways won't contribute to your army equally to the units Zerg can make from idle larva.

Again with Terran, Toss strength comes from the high-tech units, but just blindly producing those units (like Terran does MMM) will most likely lead you to defeat. You have to know WHAT your opponents composition is (and what they are going for), and you must know what units you need to counter their composition, and then what you need to protect those units that will counter their comp. This basic principle is why Protoss is such a frustrating race (for the player, and the opponent); if the Toss player makes the correct composition, and has moderate controll (obviously), Toss can pretty much A-Move through any army. This is what makes Protoss so infuriating to play against, other races can make the "perfect" composition for their race, and get melted/embarassed/destroyed by the correct toss deathball counter-comp.

On the other side of things (for us toss players) taking a round of stalkers instead of a round of zealots can mean watching your army disintegrate in about 5 seconds. That is why u/somerandomtoss 's last sentence is the real key to Protoss

you must know what, when and how many to produce.

Each unit you make (especially high tech units) have a relationship with other units in the tech tree and adding those units together into a deathball is what makes the correct toss composition unstoppable which u/sc2coldflame pointed out with

Everything else gets its power from synergy with other units.

1