Mind over Meta 2 - The Personal Metagame
Hi again everyone! After my first post last week was so well received, I've decided to try and write one of these weekly. Anyways, onto the topic this week - the personal metagame. This was proposed by u/GeZ_ in this comment thread here. He gave me quite a few leads and ideas to work with, and deserves to be recognized for this topic.
Finally, forgive me if my writing is rusty. I just pulled an all-nighter to finish a few essays and may not be at my analytically best. If you would like to expand or criticize what I wrote, feel free to do so in the comments - this is more of a prompt than a resource, and I'd love to learn what you'd like to share. However, it may just be that some get more out of "theoretical discussions" than others, and if that is the case, let me know as well. I wanna cover what you guys wanna hear (thanks u/Ephile).
THE PERSONAL METAGAME
I believe really strongly in imitation, actually: I think it's the first place you need to go to if you're going to be able to understand how something works. True mimicry is actually quite difficult..
- Eleanor Catton
Smash is a game where personalities and attitudes can project themselves onto the character through the player. Whether it be the difference between BizzarroFlame's disrespectful Ganon, or the hyperagressive never-say-die Ganon piloted by Kage, the true beauty of smash is that any character can be played any way by anyone. However, there are certain techniques some characters have to know, such as pillaring as Falco or the (aptly named for this article) Ken Combo for Marth mains. While there is plenty one can do to make a character "their own," today's topic will be talking about the opposite side of the spectrum: What you can do to improve your game by learning from and imitating others.
A SHORT INTRODUCTION (thanks u/GeZ_)
For this week, GeZ pointed me towards a conversation on smashboards he had about Mario with Nausicaa. Nausicaa said something quite eyeopening in this conversation, as seen below.
You're relying on things within the limits of your play and not going beyond them, just like SB and everyone else. When you + SB + every Mario is literally playing the exact same character, and rarely branching into each others dynamics of how to use the tools you're all given aside from some basic WD Dmash/Dthrow > Fair stuff, it will be of value to attempt utilizing the different maneuvers and MANARISMS of different players with those same tools.
You do what you do for a reason.
SB does what he does for a reason.
Everyone does everything they do for a reason.
All of it works some of the time, find what that time is and use it, all the rest, take it out.
Chances are, somebody does something in those 'not-working-for-you' times that you can incorporate.
Gez's response just about sums up mine:
This post is damn good. Especially what you said about playing a character like other PEOPLE. I think that the metagame concerning play style is a lot more downplayed in the smash series than other fighting games
Now, let's talk about what Nausicaa means when he (or she, not sure, sorry Naus:( ) talks about incorporating other's style.
WHAT IS THE PERSONAL METAGAME
Any player that wants to learn will watch videos. It's simple - you want to improve, it's what you do. The reason, though, is deep-seated in something I've named "The Personal Metagame." It's simply the strategies behind how YOU play that affects the match, rather than the match situations in general.
An example (to stick with the Mario examples) is let's say I start off really good in neutrals because of my skill with fireballs. However, I have a terrible time converting off of grabs because I lack experience. Then I watch a Boss video where he Downthrows into a fair and gets a kill. I implement this into my game, I get more consistent, I'm now a better Mario, with bits of Boss's playstyle now being used.
Why this is important is a bit deeper than just getting better though. By learning a new tool, you have just that - a tool. It isn't a skill you can bust out whenever, it's something designed for a certain situation. Therefore, don't just pay attention to WHAT people do, but WHEN they do it. A shine out of neutral is much different than a shine out of stagger.
This comes to my first so-called "lesson" of the day: Adapt for situations, not for characters. You'll learn more by using great techniques in the situations they were meant for rather than just throwing them around. However, this is pretty shallow and I assume most of you already know this, so we're going to expand into this topic.
THE BALROG
Let's continue with Gez's quote from earlier
A good parallel to what your talking about is this American Street Fighter player, named PR Balrog. He is currently regarded as one of the best employers of the "play dumb" strategy. He's incredible in that he can play two matches of a set to 5 playing like himself. His pokes are calculated, footsies strong, and his game overall solid. Now you get to the third round and he begins by rushing you, as bluntly as possible. He beats a lot of players with this because he's ruining their rythm. Whatever ability they got to gauge his play is gone, and they have to quickly reaclimate to his strategy, or (in most situations), die.
This works, works ****ing WONDERS, in Project M, dualistically because of other players unfamiliarity with it, and it's effectiveness in any game that involves THINKING at odds with your opponent. It's usually a bit more complex than changing from staying back to pushing, but that outlines the concept pretty well. So change it up! Play like a Guatemalan coke addict! (or in another fashion if you fall into that category already) Rush them, then control space, then punish, then do a jive.
So we understand that learning from those better than us AND properly applying this information is the key to winning. But if everyone did that, only the M2Ks of the world that analyze all frame data would be top ranked. That's where "The Balrog" comes in.
Balrog, for a TL;DR ruins his opponent's reads on him by switching his playstyle to adapt to his match, not his opponents. By switching his playstyle on the go - and more importantly, being able to - he has the edge on anyone who cannot adapt to him. This is actually a big reason M2K loses short sets but not long ones - when given the time to adapt, the smarter player wins. That's why a wise player doesn't let his opponent adapt.
Let's go back to our Mario example. I've learned how to do most "Mario stuff." But the guy against me has me read. Maybe he plays with a Mario main, or is one himself. Do I try to outskill him? No, I change. I adapt to make him adapt. Not all adaptations should be reactive, in fact, it's often the preemptive adaptations that win games.
M2K, ironically enough, since he's our example, shows us a great job of this in LTC2 Grand Finals v. Neon. M2K gets bodied early on, but spends the time learning and adapting to his opponent. Come the second set, he's playing like a different man. Where he would stall on the edge or throw shadowballs he now goes in and 0-deaths Neon right back. Conversely, Neon took the first set from M2K because of his playstyle. M2K is no stranger to aggressive play, but Neon does an excellent job of disrupting the pace of his combos. Where another dair or fair would've done fine, Neon may opt for a zair or pkfreeze, throwing off M2Ks timing and thus continuing the combo.
The lesson today isn't about what to apply, it's about how to apply it. If you're being beat, sometimes you don't need to play better, you need to play different. Tempo is a large part of gaming in general, whether it be the "card advantage" from my MTG background, or a no huddle offense in the NFL, the player that controls what happens in the game and when it happens will win 99% of the time.
Imitate away. Learn new things, copy that sick guaranteed 0-death from Sethlon or Ken or Poob. But knowing when to use them is BY FAR more important, as simply changing between gameplans wins games and sets.
LOOKING WITHIN - THE ESSENCE OF THE PERSONAL METAGAME
Read the entire third block quote from Nausicaa on the smashboards post. No really, do it. This is probably one of the most important lessons you can learn in both smash and life. It's too long for me to post here, so instead, let's analyze parts of it:
-
YOUR mental state is by far the most important aspect of smash. Staying calm, picking the right option, picking up on habits and making your play less predictable is ALL related to your state of mind while playing. Stay Calm, Have Fun, and you Win More. Don't hesitate to take breaks, or wait up on the respawn platform. You won't win unless you're in the best mental condition (this has robbed M2K of MANY victories, look at Amsa v. M2K at KOC4.
-
While it's nice to play unpredictably, LEARN EXTENSIVELY. You want to be able to use what you already know and apply it rather than have to figure out a matchup or solution on the fly. That takes time, and during that time, you may lose.
-
This is the key quote, in my opinion, and the namesake of this week:
Building upon that is where the real dynamics of the game have to be developed. The player's own meta-game flushes out with depth, but this takes the conscious effort to break the mold, their OWN mold. It may shattered that foundation a little (make the player worse for a while) as they try to branch out, but this will only strengthen that foundation long-term, as the kinks are worked out.
- Finally, play with self-awareness. Yes, you may be the best and can win with pure techskill, but this means NOTHING. Life is about self improvement, and Smash is no different. Take risks, do badly, play outside your comfort zone, give a character that's seen as bad a chance, because maybe, like yourself, they don't have their meta developed. Meta is not just a game term. It's how we operate, it's the status quo, and unless we go out of our way to push it and break it and find new opportunities to rise above it and everyone following it, we never will.
FINAL REMARKS
I'm sorry if this is a weak article. I feel as if there is great information to be found in Gez's post on smashboards, but again, I'm all tired out of writing and couldn't research as thoroughly as I'd like.
While defining what is your personal metagame and changing it may take time, it will be worth it. It'll be a long journey, learning and playing new characters, playing aggressive when you want to sit back and shoot lasers, but it will be worth it, because it's the not unpredictable foe that is dangerous, it's the skillfully unpredictable foe that is.
Nausicaa (who, at this point, should be credited with writing the article along with Gez), says it best, and I'll leave you with his/her quote:
"Think of method as a fine silvery stream, not a raging waterfall. It will go meandering here, trickling there. It will find the groves, the cracks, and the crevices. Just follow it, never let it out of your sight, and it will take you."
Piece, of, cake.
Until next week, may you define your personal metagame, and never stop chasing the stream of method,
- Matt "PlayOnSunday"
DISCUSSION
-
I'd love feedback on the column this week - I doubt this is my best work, but if you got something out of it, let me know. Likewise, if I ranted and said nothing like I think I did, let me know as well, and I'll fix it next time.
-
What do you do to define your own personal metagame? What stories do you have from doing so?
-
What's the personal metagame to you? What advice or thoughts do you have on it?
-
Special thanks to Gez and Nauticaa - I may have overquoted and used you guys this week, but the post was so fascinating and opened my eyes so much, I don't think I could have used a different source. Shout out to these guys.
RESPONSES
Posted Nov 25, 2014, 6:25 PM UTC · edited