r/openbroke•
ujeb

A 19 year old girl's parents aren't supporting her efforts to prove her citizenship. "Clearly they are Gypsies" Redditors exclaim

Ethnic Discrimination

Here's the thread

So a 19 year old girl doesn't have her birth certificate, a passport, or any other form of documentation proving that she is an American citizen. This led to issues such as being unable to get a job, a driver's license, attend college, etc. She tried to get her parents to help, but they refused.

Let's see what reddit has to say

It's just part of Roma culture. They see getting an SSN as giving into a culture that isn't theirs.

Ah yes, I too can guess people's cultural background based on a short video in which they don't delve into their ethnicity. I'm also an expert on cultures and can fully explain everything that is happening here by connecting it to culture.

At the same time I feel that isn't an excuse. Part of Roma culture is that it's ok to steal, so while I see why they did that I can still think they're bad parents.

DAE Roma = Thieves!?

Why does reddit hate gypsies? I usually don't see this kind of attacks on any culture getting upvoted usually.

This comment was obviously ignored. I'm sure once this post ages more it'll will eventually have giant essays written under it discussing biotruths and the like.

The one culture everyone hates... They are taught from birth that it is okay to steal. They will even have their kids steal and pretend to scold them when they get caught. I've seen it happen first hand.

More Roma = Thieves

I tend to agree with you that she is not gypsy. Going out on a limb here, but I don't think Pennington is a common gypsy name. Also she has not stolen my wallet yet.

Once again a joke that suggests Roma are thieves... the thread is filled with them so I'm just going to stop quoting these.

Okay but who said she was gypsy? She didn't, her parents were just neglectful.

Finally someone points out that we do not know if she was Roma or not, but since this is reddit the comment was ignored.

Thankfully as you go down the thread more and more people are pointing out that

  1. We have no reason to believe she is Roma

  2. Someone found her parent's blog and indeed they aren't Roma, they are in fact Christian Fanatics


Honestly at times I feel like Redditors would cheer on Disney's depiction of Claude Frollo and herald him as the protagonist.

Reference for those of you that haven't watched the Disney movie

Extra tidbit: I'm unable to find the comment anymore unfortunately but there was someone in the thread comparing pictures of Romani children to the person in the video to figure out her background

Take that as you will

Posted Feb 11, 2015, 6:19 AM UTC

406
Clumpy•

Seriously, even otherwise-tolerant people turn into Donald Sutherland in Pod People the moment the Roma are mentioned. People who have interacted with them and don't see them as sewer rats are buried under the sea of blanket statements about what they are and what ought to be done.

12
Cykuta•

The Roma are like fat people: they're "acceptable targets." Yes, there are some problematic areas in their customs and culture, much like there are health problems related to obesity. Yes, most people concerned (bot Romani and obese) are actually trying to do stuff about it. No, neither culture nor accumulated fat tissue can be dealt with overnight. But both groups are fair game because it's "their own fault" and if they don't want to be abused why don't they just stop doing the [insert things]?

And of course only a remote culture I have no idea of has any problems. Our own? Best stuff ever.

5
tawtaw•

Interesting bit of trivia: Jack Greenberg, who was the longtime head of the NAACP Legal Defense Fund (itself famous for jump-starting the career of Thurgood Marshall, among others) & arguably one of the best known civil-rights lawyers, has taken to advocating against anti-Roma(ni) discrimination in his old age.

1
Rede383•

As someone who lives in outback Australia, what's a Roma?

5
kanemalakos•

The ethnic group often referred to as gypsies.

5
remove_krokodil•

I really am sick of the casual Roma hatred. (I'd love to add "on Reddit", but sadly, I see this crap offline too.) Even some subs I really like seem to be OK with it.

4