r/islam•
KASKAx

[META] Can we make this sub more about Islam rather than current events that are tangentially related to Islam?

The front-page is usually filled with something related to the illegal apartheid occupation of Palestine or something else like that. Can we actually have some content on Islam instead? This sub used to be quite different a year ago, but now it has just turned into a giant aggregate for anything on r/worldnews that is related to Islam.

I don't mind the threads about current events, but when you have so many of them that the entire front page is filled with them for weeks on end, it's probably not a good idea.

Posted Feb 15, 2015, 7:39 AM UTC

2941
BeNiceToAll•

I'm posting text posts about Tafseer lately, but they're getting downvoted for some reason. I'm afraid it gets lost that way and nobody ends up benefitting from it. Not that that is my intention though. Purely for Allah. But still... I would like people to read & benefit from it.

18
Shizzin•

Do not worry. People do read your thread. Continue on despite the random downvotes. It's just imaginary points with no real life benefits. Your threads are very beneficial. We can extract lessons and apply to ourselves.

Jazakallah khair for the effort.

13
Nistrel•

Taking away the people who actually do downvote. There is also the fact that reddit has an algorithm which makes automated up and downvotes to posts. Its affected by time and amount of votes in general. And its there to manage which posts show up on the frontpage.

Don't look to much into the votes.

7
shadowlightfox•

Don't get rid of your tafseer vids. If it means anything, I give upvotes to them.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
uwootm8•

I know what you mean. I wish it was different.

14
angelocrator•

Why don't you start with yourself? You are are among those constantly posting threads and posts about Israel and Zionists that have nothing to do with Islam and now you complain about this.

Are you kidding? I mean, wtf?

https://www.reddit.com/r/islam/comments/2v5e1t/a_brief_account_of_muslim_history_know_your_past/

https://www.reddit.com/r/islam/comments/2ulrul/reminder_to_all_brotherssisters_israeli_apartheid/

https://www.reddit.com/r/islam/comments/2u9mwq/islamic_republic_of_iran_institutions_to_hold/

https://www.reddit.com/r/islam/comments/2tszrk/students_at_the_canadian_school_concordia/

And then there is this gem of an anti-Israeli pallywood propaganda piece that you posted and defended:

https://www.reddit.com/r/islam/comments/2t528o/israeli_soldier_gives_74yearold_palestinian_woman/

Here's what you wrote:

The fact that there are even people on this sub who say "hurr durr what does this have to do with muh Islam" demonstrates their utter and total lack of understanding what Islam even is. Free Palestine -- participate in Israeli Apartheid Week at your local university campus (a global event).

YOU are the one claiming this is about Islam. YOU!

How on earth can you now do a full 180 and complain about this?

9
zeeginganinja•

And why don't you start being respectful of everyone here? Its fine to disagree, debate is definitely welcome. But you have been nothing but mean the past few days.

16
angelocrator•

What goes around, comes around.

When I joined this subreddit and other Muslim forums, I was nothing but respectful and even supportive.

Never in my life have I encountered so much hate just for being a non-Muslim and disagreeing with a comfortable narrative.

Never in my life have I seen so much hypocrisy as by Muslims.

"Know your place, dog"

"Why should i trust a kafir?"

"Sure it's ok for a Muslim to have a non-Muslim slave but the other way round is completely impossible"

And the endless accusations of spreading hate and islamophobia JUST for demonstrating that a Muslim was wrong about something or was being hypocritical.

Not the mention the endless stream of anti-kuffar, anti-Jewish and anti-Western hate.

You think that non-Muslims demonize Muslims?

Do you have any idea how many, many Muslims think and talk about us kuffar?

I don't hate Muslims at all but I really despise the ideology that makes many Muslims act in the ways I describe above.

-1
ilikereddit55•

You've spent the last few months circlejerking in this sub. There is literally not a single comment not related to Islam or Islamic violence in your history. What a sad life :(

13
DoubleDot•

You are not fooling anyone.

11
Darkpursuer•

You might want to treat Muslims as individuals, not a hive mind. Some Muslims are brought up on hate, some by peace. If one hates you, ignore them. Don't feed their hatred. If there is cause to engage in civil discussion, try not to get emotional about it. Remember behind the monitor there are different people with different ideals.

9
angelocrator•

In regards to everyday Muslims, sure.

In regards to this place: there are Muslim users here who regularily insult and abuse non-Muslim and get upvoted and encouraged. That tells me enough about the mindeset of the majority of the participants.

I am well aware that this does not apply to the majority of Muslims.

-3
zeeginganinja•

How do you and the rest of us visit the same sub and you come away with those ideas? You might should get your head checked.

6
theunderhillaccount•

Never in my life have I encountered so much hate just for being a non-Muslim and disagreeing with a comfortable narrative.

Well, now you understand...take what you've learned to the rest of the world. Although, whatever you do, don't draw cartoons about it--you'll most likely get shot to the thunderous applause of hundreds of millions of Muslims.

-1
Nmathmaster123•

I don't think people care your non-muslim, I think the conflict stems from the fact you disagreed with them :/

Nonetheless you make a good point and I have to agree.

5
KASKAxOP•

My OP clearly said it was alright once in a while, just that it's not useful when it's flooding the front page.

3
ilikereddit55•

The great ad hominem attack rearing its ugly head again. I agree with OP and haven't posted any Israel related thread here, what do you have to say to me?

-1
angelocrator•

Nothing. The post was directed at OP, not you. All the posts I linked to are from OP.

How on earth is it an ad hominem when I show that OP has been doing excatly what he demands others to refrain from?

So, why do you ask? Why do you want to make this about you? The post is about exposing OP's hypocrisy and as usual, I get downvoted for it.

2
ilikereddit55•

Except OP said he didn't mind some posts but he was getting annoyed of every single post being political. how is that hypocritical?

6
ThisIsOwnage•

I get what you mean but here's the only place we Muslims can successfully get out our opinions on stuff, if we went to world news we'd just get downvoted and then our opinions would seem like the wrong ones to others l.

8
Nistrel•

It depends on what sub you go to. In most smaller subs its actually quite good. And r/worldnews is a whole different story. Its the only sub which i visit frequently but never read the comments.

2
Nmathmaster123•

People like u/possibleatom come forward and say something stupid/radical and play straight into the hand of anti-theists that makes them say "SEE!? DHUR LE MOODSLIMES R ALL REALLY VIOLENT TERRORISTS!! SEE!?" Quite frankly it's extremely frustrating because that's the thing outsiders remember from the sub instead of the opinions of normal muslims.

0
happybutunhappy•

They'd make us look bad even if we did something good. What did he say that was "radical"?

0
Nmathmaster123•

People who insult the prophet deserve to die, the synagogue attack was justified because le israel . . . Unislamic shit like that which violated our baisic religious principles.

1
moon-jellyfish•

This

I really think we need to make a megathread for this stuff, or people need to post in one of the many other subs

7
cubebulb•

My hope is that this sub met the minimal requirement in surat al-3asr with appropriate portion.

By time. Indeed, mankind is in loss. Except for those who have believed and done righteous deeds and advised each other to truth and advised each other to patience. http://tanzil.net/#103:1

5
Nmathmaster123•

I feel you, I just stopped browsing this sub on the day of the chapel hill attack because that was literally the only thing on the subreddit at the time, and now this.

5
Blackbeard_•

It just reflects reddit in general. If you want serious discussion on Islam, you can not find it on reddit. That's like going to the KKK to learn about black history month.

4
SpecsaversGaza•

Exactly, this subreddit attracts the scared, the thoughtless, the plain stupid and the bully who think they're achieving something by coming here and posting their drivel.

1
Darkpursuer•

Perhaps we should consider filters?

3
Shizzin•

We do have filters. It's in the sidebar on the left. We also have flair system, too.

4
Dromar6627•

I don't mind the threads about current events, but when you have so many of them that the entire front page is filled with them for weeks on end, it's probably not a good idea.

I don't disagree; but Islam does not, and is not mean to, exist in a vacuum.

But maybe the mods could delete a link if it's a re-link/post the same week. As long as they make it part of the "Moderation Policy" on the sidebar, and notify the OP of course.

3
jamicam•

There can be more than one subreddit on Islam. Perhaps it's time to create a few others. One focused on religion, another on world events, etc.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Xray330•

THIS, can the mods make flaring your posts obligatory? and than get one of those buttons to filter out certain topics, like for example, the ones that r/worldnews has.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Alienm00se•

I'm with you, it's just difficult not to address these issues when our faith is in the headlines so much. It's nigh-on unavoidable.

1
ThatWeirdMuslimGuy•

Well considering people don't tend to comment on completely directly Islamic content within the sub, that's unlikely to happen. It seems this sub is turning into a place where muslim Internet users are able to remove some frustration. The more annoying thing to me is how people keep asking the same questions over and over again, as if it's a tape recorder. People should ask new questions.

1
Thread_water•

Y'all don't like seeing some of the atrocities Islam causes? I'm not surprised.

-3
theonlywayoutis•

If Islam is the sole cause, then it must be pretty darn bad at atroicty causing considering the tiny amount of jihadist loonies compared with normal, decent everyday Muslims.

7
Thread_water•

Nah Islam is certainly not the sole cause. It's not even the main one imo. Bad upbringing combined with stupidity combined with religion leads to these things in my opinion.

then it must be pretty darn bad at atroicty causing considering the tiny amount of jihadist loonies compared with normal, decent everyday Muslims.

Yeah I agree Islam doesn't make most people or even a significant percentage of people to do mean things. This doesn't mean it doesn't do it to any people. This doesn't mean we shouldn't discuss Islam as a possible problem.

-1