Creative/art directors, managers, etc..., how you find a good balance to keep your designers somewhat content?
I know it's impossible to make a designer truly feel happy about his/her job. But what sort of practices or tips do you have to help them NOT feel like a production monkey or resentful of their day to day work?
Posted Mar 20, 2015, 1:49 PM UTC
Stop ruining their designs. Let them design and fuck off. Do you wander into the kitchen of every restaurant you eat at and demand to throw spices you like into the mix? No? Then don't wander into the design room and tell them to move pixels and change colors.
Edit: Unless you are a good designer yourself, then it's collaboration.
Nit-picking is always annoying, but isn't it the AD or CD's job to bring the best out of a designer and meet the client's needs? I get that bringing the best out of a designer also sometimes means stepping aside too.
Well, your designer should have the creative brief. He should be aware of the needs of the client. If he failed to use brand colors or something, yeah, you need to remind them to change it.
But saying things like, "Oh, lets add some contrast here... Maybe a subtle glow to that? Lets get the text out of that." Pretty worthless unless you hired a person who can't actually do the job they were hired for.
I disagree, first off not every designer is at a senior level with 20 years experience. Many companies also don't just hire people with that level of experience. So if a company were to higher someone of lesser experience and an AD makes some suggestions on their work, the company hired someone who can't do the just because it wasn't done perfectly? I'm sure even senior designers miss stuff too. An AD can also be an extra set of eyes and another person to bounce ideas off of a collaborate.
I'm not saying they need to micromanage or hover over the designer, but I still think they play a crucial role.
I replied to that, nothing else. That kind of direction isn't art direction, it's micromanaging.
I 100% agree with you here. I have 2 junior designers that are still learning a lot. School doesn't always prepare you for every single detail, considering there are so many different types of design jobs you can land out of college. Client vs agency can be a complete different atmosphere. You learn how to use the tools and some design theory in school, but it isn't until your at your first gig you begin to push your knowledge and education.
There's a line there. Giving good feedback to improve the design is arguably the most important job of an AD/CD.
Yup. I agree.
Going with the metaphor the parent thread gave, you wait for your meal before you complain about the nutmeg in it. Maybe your meal wouldn't even have the nutmeg you saw sitting on the counter. You don't know until you're eating it, right?
Showing up behind your designer before he gives you a proof, a concept, first draft, whatever, and telling him to push around pixels is obnoxious and slightly degrading.
Show up and say, "Oh, that's lookin' pretty fun, man! Remember that piece you gave me last week, with that type treatment? I bet the client would like that here. Try it out and see if it works." That is great and helpful.
Is not the same as "Oh, yeah.. Lets go ahead and change up that typeface. San-Serif really isn't what I want to see. Oh, is that the blue you're gonna use? Lets throw in maybe.. 10% black." Plenty of ADs and CDs do this. If you do it enough, your designer will find a new place to work, I promise.
Word!
If you aren't a designer and you're telling the designer what to do, then your help is not needed anymore than any other job where you aren't an expert, and feel the need to tell the expert what to do.
Imagine literally any other field. Just because someone has eyes doesn't make their opinion worth a shit.
I agree with you 100%, I think all designers get annoyed with that kind of behavior. However, I wouldn't trust any AD or CD in the design industry that wasn't a skilled designer to begin with. And if they're not, I'd certainly hope they'd know when to back off and listen to their employees. I'd also hope the designer would communicate their design decisions if there was an issue of contention worth discussion.
I think the AD should have more experience and skills and in that instance, maybe it's the designer's responsibility to take feedback without being huffy.
I was more concerned with the "manager" part of the title. I've seen lots of instances of unhappy designers having to appease either clients directly or under managers who aren't designers.
If the Art Director has skills and a great portfolio, the designers should respect that. If the Art Director is managing designers better than them, they should be able to respect that too.
There are probably instances in which junior designers don't understand something subtle the AD is trying to get them to do, but that should probably fall under the respect category.
This is a really narrow minded view which you will regret later. If you ever become a creative director, a client will tell you to move pixels and change colors, and believe me they don't want shitty attitude from a vendor.
I've been a designer for 15 years. Clients pay experts all the time to do things they can't. Except in design. Have a pair of eyes? Then you're basically just paying the designer to use photoshop/illustrator/whatever, right? No. You're not a designer. You're going to ruin the design this professional created, have a shittier end product, and piss off the designer.
What's the solution for this? Manipulative contracts and complex systems designed to guide the client so they ruin as little as possible. This shouldn't be necessary.
You've missed my point and proved it at the same time, you sound pretty abrasive here and in your original post regarding OPs question. His question is actually a great one, I applaud a CD looking to make his relationship with his designers better. Annnnd you told him to fuck off. Top choice advice from the 15 year veteran.
I have a tendency towards abrasive speech. I assume adults can handle speech not laced with niceties. Do you really require a handjob with every piece of information you don't like? This is the internet. Is every comment thread to be laced with happy words made of smoke blowing up your ass?
My actual advice was to talk to his designers and ask them why they're unhappy. The lack of communication is likely part of it.
Don't accept prescriptive feedback from clients. Fixed.
I don't mean to offend you, but you kind of sound like a jaded employee. It's the job of a CD / AD to ensure that the output is up to scratch, and on brief, so naturally part of their position will be guiding the designers under them.
It sounds like you are experiencing a CD, or an AD who may be unsuitable for their position.
And in regards to the kitchen analogy, I would most definitely expect the head, and sous chef to have control over their chefs, so that analogy kind of doesn't work.
Not offended. I wasn't so much focused on the CD/AD part, but the "manager" part. If you're a manager telling designers what to do, that's why they are pissed off. My assumption would be that if you've managed to make it to the AD/CD position you are designer enough to command respect. This isn't true in all instances, as some people design like shit for 20 years.
Yeah... but you didn't say any of that... you just said to fuck off and stay out of the design room. Manager is just a title just like Creative Director. If I outranked you and told you to make it pink and you told me to fuck off you'd be on a fast track to getting replaced.
I'd consider it a favor to be sacked by a manager who has never been a designer and keeps ruining my designs.
I think some of the work requirements are unavoidable. I guess what Im asking is, what ideas can you apply outside of the work process that can help inspire and motivate a designer and help them to scratch that "itch".
Ask them why they're unhappy and what would make them happier.
You don't, it's not your job. My job as a CD and AD was to A) make sure my team hit their numbers/schedules/deadlines/budgets, B) produce work that met expectations, both external and internal, C) functioned well, D) buffer & translator between other teams, clients, sales, etc. It's more important that people can find satisfaction in life and work rather than I try to provide that to them. If someone isn't inspired, or challenged, either they're the wrong fit, or the project was established incorrectly, or something's out of whack (staffing, workload, whatever).
Some teams are really simple, and like bullshit like Friday afternoon drinks, or monthly outings to a museum. If that floats your boat, and theirs, great. Right now, my team is more interested in having a life outside of work, and making money. Both of which we strive for.
Well, they do put salt & pepper on the table, so this metaphor isn't perfect.
Anyways – just as a designer needs to justify their decisions based on strategy to clients, a CD should justify critique based on the same strategy. Whoever can't justify their decisions, loses the argument.