Should I award bonus xp based on an encounters adjusted xp value?

Advice

So, my group leveled up again last week, and a player mentioned to me afterwards that they were leveling up really quick. I have been using the Kobold Fight Club encounter calculator to help with my encounters, and I tend to prefer more enemies (so far its been a bunch of goblins and skeletons) than a solo.

They mentioned that I should only be using the encounter total xp and awarding roleplaying on top of that.

Any suggestions on how you all do it? I'm pretty new and don't want to unbalance the progression, but I also like the idea of rewarding my players for overcoming some fairly difficult scenarios.

Thanks!

Edit: Thanks guys for the input. My group went from 3 to 4 in one session as some of their encounters were in the hard to deadly range, wrapped up a couple quests they had been working on, and are roleplaying well. I think I'll be slowing down the progression from here a bit as far as encounter xp (maybe giving some smaller bonuses for particularly difficult ones) and focus more on roleplaying and questing.

Posted Apr 6, 2015, 9:33 PM UTC · edited

64
ayline•

I've only given them the XP value for the monsters, not multiplied based on the number. So fighting more monster at the same time doesn't increase the XP value per monster, even though it's a tougher encounter. I've also given the players XP for completing certain tasks and other stuff like that.

2
cillkupid•

I give out xp based on how the encounter went. If it was an easy encounter that I built to be easy then I give less. If it's an average encounter then level appropriate. If I build a bad ass encounter that is meant to be difficult and they barely beat it, then they get appropriately awesome xp. If I build a ridiculously hard encounter and they find a creative way to make it a cake walk then I reward the awesome xp and then give bonuses as appropriate to players. I also hand out random xp for whatever I feel like: Making the DM laugh profusely, giving the DM a ride, buying the DM food, helping other players with rides or food. Anything appropriate.

2
ademonicspoonDungeon Master•

I haven't had any issues with progression as a result of awarding the full adjusted XP value. I recommend doing it this way so as to avoid unrewarding, difficult encounters

1
N_Who•

Strictly speaking, you're not supposed to be awarding XP based on an encounter's adjusted value. The adjusted value is there to help keep an encounter's difficulty in line with the number of heroes in your party. It's a budgeting/balancing tool, not an adjustment to how much XP the encounter is actually worth.

As a DM, I don't use XP for progression. My players and I prefer milestone progression, where they level up when I say they level up. The DMG has some guidelines for this, but among those guidelines was a quick estimate of how fast leveling should be: Leveling from 1 to 2 should take one session, from 2 to 3 should take two sessions, and 3 to 4 and up should take three sessions each.

Does your leveling about match that progression?

1