Audi have successfully made diesel fuel from carbon dioxide and water
sciencealert.com/audi-have-successfully-made-...Posted Apr 27, 2015, 9:38 AM UTC
Posted Apr 27, 2015, 9:38 AM UTC
Meh. People won't care about it until we need it. Maybe find a company that makes diesel fuel with this process and drop $100 in its stock and save it for your great-great-grandkids so they can all be millionaires in the future.
I doubt 100 bucks will turn into millions.
It's unlikely, but possible. If they become a leader in a certain industry, their stock increases by insane amounts. Sure, you might invest in a company that flops and you lose your 100 bucks, but there's also the chance that the company you invested in buys out or pulls ahead of competition and becomes the biggest name in renewable diesel fuel.
Imagine the gains made by people that invested in railroads 200 years ago or Carnegie steel 100 years ago. I think it's entirely possible to make millions from your $100.
That is absolutely amazing.
What's more amazing is that I didn't see anything about special engine mods/calibrations being required. If they can produce it on a truly massive scale, this can be a massive blow to our CO2 production.
No mods are needed because it IS diesel. If you have massive amounts of electricity you can do this, people are doing it today just with natural gas and coal as a carbon source instead of CO2.
Why wouldn't they just run of pure hydrogen? It is as pure as it gets, and they would save the last "two steps". But if they really need an alternative diesel fuel it is an an amazing idea
As I've heard it explained, hydrogen is extremely hard to keep in storage for long periods of time.
Hydrogen is basically impossible to store indefinitely. Even the current fuel cell vehicles vent off the hydrogen stored in the tank over time.
This fuel can be used in existing diesel engines without modification.
Because hydrogen is incredibly dangerous to use. It produces an invisible flame and it is highly flammable. That and the infrastructure is too costly. Pretty hard to keep hydrogen where you want it.
Can't really use it in a diesel engine, besides all of the other reasons posted. You'd need stupid high CR to make pure H2 auto-ignite in a combustion chamber. That means a lot of heat, more than what diesel engines are used to right now (OEM ones at least) and more NOx emissions which are already problematic at 17:1 CR.
Because Hydrogen is extremely explosive, expensive to transport, and hard to store
Using hydrogen as a fuel for cars is plain stupid. It's exactly what I would expect reddit mouth breathers to parrot.
It's because it bleeds through virtually any container
Not to mention is significantly less energy dense than fossil fuels, while still requiring the energy to produce and contain it...
Hydrogen will be (and always has been...) the fuel of the future.
This does seem to be an astounding breakthrough, and I'm stunned that I'm reading it on a subforum on a site that's not specifically about either technology or cars.
Does anyone have any "background info" on this, i.e. what has been achieved before? What was holding the process up before? Has there been some big breakthrough in catalyst / engineering technology that has suddenly made this possible?
Amazing "new" technology: 1925 Fischer-Torpsch process.
tl;dr: It is very energy inefficient. Digging oil out of the ground an making diesel from that is a lot cheaper. Unless you have absolutely no access to crude oil (Like Germany during WWII).
If you want to read up on the topic you can also search for Power to Gas, basically the same idea: producing Methane from Co2
The Fischer-Tropsch process is old news. The basics of it are Hydrogen + Carbon Monoxide --> Long-chain hydrocarbons + Water. I believe Audi simply obtained the CO from CO2 and H2 from H20, which is even less economical than the current process which uses coal or methane as a feedstock.
[deleted]
Why not just skip the middleman, and use electrolysis to create H2 and run fuel-cell vehicles. Would save so much time, effort, and energy.
Because that isn't an efficient process. If you were going to go that route, solar power would be a better option. Elon Musk did a great job of answered that question. Can link if requested.
Adding to what u/Porsche_Curves said, H2 is also not very energy dense in comparison to fossil fuels, and requires a lot more energy to store (we essentially HAVE to pressurize the mobile tank to very high pressures to carry a useful amount around).
Good to know when all the fossil fuels are gone I can still drive my 99 Ford Taurus SEL at 19 miles per gallon of Magic Gas
Isn't it feasible some technology will come about that allows us to produce a metric shitton of CO^2 a minute just because we need it to. Something that uses solar power to run a reaction putting off CO^2, and we just run it daily. And we get larger machines to mass produce the electrolysis machines. Give it time for the technology to mature and this could be very viable. When other company's start cashing in on their own and the market gets competitive.
This is the best tl;dr I could make, original reduced by 83%. (I'm a bot)
German car manufacturer Audi has reportedly invented a carbon-neutral diesel fuel, made solely from water, carbon dioxide and renewable energy sources.
Once it's been refined, the resulting e-diesel can be mixed in with our current diesel fuel, or used on its own to power cars in a more sustainable way.
Sunfire analyses have shown that the synthetic fuel is not only more environmentally friendly, but also has superior combustion when compared to fossil fuels.
Extended Summary | FAQ | Theory | Feedback | Top five keywords: fuel^#1 Audi^#2 use^#3 being^#4 e-diesel^#5
Post found in /r/worldnews, /r/cars, /r/Autos, /r/EverythingScience, /r/Diesel, /r/misc, /r/tdi, /r/environment, /r/wec, /r/science, /r/technology, /r/Audi, /r/theworldnews, /r/NotYourMothersReddit, /r/news, /r/topofreddit, /r/Stuff, /r/worldnews, /r/funny, /r/todayilearned, /r/realtech, /r/chemistry, /r/Futurology, /r/denser and /r/peakoil.
From the top comment in this thread:
(Emphasis mine)
TL;DR - nothing to see here.
Wait. If they use the unlimited energy from the sun to create this diesel then it would be a good thing. It would be reducing CO2 in the atmosphere (or at least not creating any more) and would be providing a usable energy source to the public. Especially since most 18 wheelers aren't solar powered yet.
All they need to do it make it a little more reasonably priced and have government incentives make it competitive with regular diesel.
The problem that most people dont see is the first step. Getting CO2 out of the atmosphere, by distillation or other method, requires incredible amounts of energy, far more than will be contained in the final fuel product.
In theory of a cheap clean renewable energy source like solar could be used to power the extraction it would be a great way to make a liquid fuel. However, we dont really have a source of power that good yet.
Well you also have to keep in mind that there are plenty of sources for almost pure CO2-Gas available we currently just vent into the air.
The reduction of hematite to 1t of pig iron using coke results in 1,5t heated and almost pure CO2 athmosphere that you could instantly convert back to methane or diesel using the process in the article. That's about 1.2 billion tonnes of CO2 worldwide... Still very energy inefficient but not as bad as you describe.
There is plenty of CO2 to be captured from industrial process, however the vast majority are not equipped to capture their CO2 emissions and it would require incredible investment to retrofit facilities to do so (if even possible).
Plus the other half of the reaction is H2, which also requires a large amount of energy due to needing electrolysis.
Its not that its not possible, just that its very economically unfeasible.
But the CO2 would still end up back in the atmosphere after being used in the vehicle.
And that is just one step of the process. Electrolysis isn't a low energy process either, let alone producing the "high temperatures" and pressure required for the final step.
160 liters a day from a plant is incredibly low production. A whole plant (of unknown size, using unknown energy), running all day produces less crude than could fill my tub at home. Yes, that's right, you bathe in more water than they'll be making in one day.
Ah yes, and that brings up the last point. The article talks about the process to make what they call "blue crude". Typically, crude is used to define a precursor to gasoline (crude oil). Does that mean there is even more left in the process to get to the fuel?
there was an episode of James May's Big Ideas where he spoke to a bunch of guys in Nevada or somewhere using giant parabolic mirrors and focused sunbeams to do something like this. it looked promising.
IMO the best way is to use genetically modified photosynthesizers that can digest decaying matter and produce energized gases like methane then also be refined/fermented into liquid fuels. I'm talking algae here, in particular. Biology already has this all figured out, guys. We just have to harness it (especially because I really don't think the technological breakthrough with batteries everyone is waiting for is going to happen. We only have so many elements to choose from, moreover these elements are rare and destructive to mine/produce.)
What's the problem with using solar energy though? It's unlimited, and very efficient. You could use solar for all the steps in the process and basically make free fuel after you cover the costs of the solar panels and machinery.
Solar is improving and getting much cheaper, but realistically all the solar in the world is nothing compared to all the energy produced from fossil fuels.
If you have 10 energies and it takes 2 energies to make 1 energy, how long will you have energy for assuming you require at least 1 energy per day? Forever?
What I was saying is put up industrial solar cells so that you get the 2 energy per day that you need to make the 1 energy that the general populace can use.
That way we would have a lower net gain of CO2 emissions than if we used only regular fossil fuels, and do that until Solar power is a reasonable power source for the general populace to use.
We don't have that kind of solar infrastructure, we would have to build it.
Building it requires energy.
Building it, having it, and then refusing anybody use of it because you want to cut all the energy production in half for the environment causes people who would be customers to seek alternative energy sources, which circumvents the principles of doing this in the first place. Until everybody has all the solar power that we need, and this can be produced at the quantities needed with the "extra", then it is just a fantasy. Solar is already clean. If we don't have enough solar(which is the case), then there's no point cutting your solar production in half in order to have other clean energy.
[deleted]
I was saying to use the sun's energy to create diesel for a stop gap until it is feasible for everyone to use solar energy.
It is much more realistic to build 1 or 2 solar plants to create diesel as a stop gap while technology catches up than to expect everyone to swirch over to solar immediately.
[deleted]
I feel like you are being overly dismissive. Isn't using renewable energy, even at a deficit, better than using non-renewable energy to extract a finite resource for refining into fuel?
Better? Yes. But not more economical. This is a process thats been known for a long time, its just that refining fuel from oil is just so much easier and cheaper. Nobody is going to buy "renewable diesel" if regular diesel costs 1/4 the price.
Also, it is possible to use CO2 as a carbon source for fischer tropsch, extracting CO2 from the atmosphere would require far more energy than is contained in the final fuel product. Today most use gasified coal or NG as a feedstock and arent really renewable.
Isn't this how all sources of energy start though? As "Not so efficient as xxx"(insert earlier invented/exploited energy source).
Perhaps this technology could be viable in 10-30 years when "fossile diesel" is running short?
If thats an option though, I'm curious to see what they're going to do about NOx-emission problems in crowded areas...
Perhaps when fossil fuels start to run low, which will be much longer than 10-30 years away, it will become a more viable option.
The main thing needed for this is a clean and cheap supply of energy, most likely electricity from renewable or nuclear sources. Then it will be seen if electric vehicles become more useable or if it is easier to create synthetic liquid fuels.
Well Audi could feed their renewable energy source into the grid and thereby reduce the need for fossil power plants instead of wasting 50% of it during this process. (Yes it is VERY inefficient)
Granted if there is a ridiculus surplus of renewable energy in the future, you can use that to produce Methane or Diesel from CO2 and H2O, but as long as we use other fossil fuels such as coal as a power source there is no way this process is more economical or ecologial compared to just using the electricity.
That's why in the article, it states, as step one of the process, to use renewable energy sources to power the process.
Oh so it's just plain old gasification. That isn't new. But, while the process isn't new, applications are. Using green energy to make a fuel compatible with current cars is something that has potential. It wouldn't be a magic bullet, but another viable option isn't something we should just dismiss.
Came to mention this. There was no way anything starting with electrolysis was going to be economical.