Deadly Tales of the River - Got any?
Every year somebody dies in the James.
I'm mostly interested in stories of mishap, near death or death related to river accidents or underestimating the power of the river.
Posted Jun 22, 2015, 10:55 PM UTC · edited
I'll start with a few tales I've personally witnessed.
One fine summer day I was walking along the path at Belle Isle and saw a couple in an aluminum canoe starting to negotiate the rapids towards the center of the river. They clearly had zero experience in that water. Neither wore a life jacket. No auxiliary floatation in the boat. Nothing strapped down. Several kayakers saw what was coming and got their boats up on the nearby rocks in preparation for the inevitable spill. As the couple came down past Hollywood cemetery, they capsized. Their cooler and everything else they had went everywhere. Kayakers raced to help. The couple got their boat back and some of their stuff. Incredibly they held on to their paddles. But there was more to come. After they got back into the drained boat, they floated down a little more, just past the Dominion building, before they overturned again, losing all their remaining stuff. From there on out, they just swam/towed the boat until they were able to get to shore under the pedestrian bridge.
On another fine summer day, a friend and I were coming down from Pony Pasture to Reedy. In the distance, I could see someone in the center of the river, on the rocks, but no boat. Still, easily swimmable, right? As I got closer, the person saw me and started waving his arms. Eventually I get to the guy. He's standing ankle deep on a rock with water all around him. I ask what happened. He'd come down from Huguenot, in his brand new boat and decided to test his mettle by going as far as Reedy on his first voyage in the boat. That didn't go well. Because he had no experience at all, when he was challenged with a minor rapid, he capsized. He lost the boat (forever), his paddle and his phone. To top it all off, he couldn't swim. At all. Soooo, we talk to the guy and decide the only way to get him out is to get him to the South bank where he can walk back to Reedy where his friend may or may not be waiting for him. Luckily most of the water is pretty shallow, and we can walk the boats from rocks to islands, etc. Me on one side of the boat and him on the other. Not too bad until we get to the last crossing which is deeper and moving rapidly. As we're debating the best method to deal with this, a couple comes into view in a canoe. We wave them over, and they were nice enough to actually come up to us. We explain the situation and they allow the dude into their boat. Problem solved! Almost. As we continue down the river I get out a little ahead of the couple. Suddenly they go over a small drop in their big canoe and it's spillsville. The couple struggle to get up on the rocks, but incredibly the dude hugs the now water filled canoe and won't let go. He's not about to lose a second boat today!! I paddle over as fast as I can, and the couple has hopped over the rocks and caught their boat. After emptying the many, many gallons that a large canoe can hold, they resumed their paddle and made it to Reedy without further incident. Dude called his friend on my phone and he got a ride home. Every time I'm on the river I still look for his boat at the bottom (though it's probably in the bay by now.)
Another time, I was paddling with two friends in the big rapids right next to Belle Isle. I got through OK, but my friend got turned over by that monster wave about midway down the island. He tried to roll, but as he stated "That rock came straight for my face." He smashed his chin, but luckily didn't pass out, and bailed out of the boat. I finally got to him, and he was pale, bloody and disoriented. After awhile of resting and direct pressure, we decided to make our way to the 14th St takeout where the cars were, via the river, because the walk would have sucked. He ended up needing several stitches and still has the battle scar.
I was paddling by myself from Reedy to Belle Isle (intending to carry the boat back to Reedy.) It was a beautiful day, and the river was very low, so I shouldn't have had any problems (though paddling alone always has inherent risks.) On the last rapid before Dominion, my boat got stuck as I went down through a narrow channel. Instead of being smart, and just getting out of the boat, I tried to dislodge myself with the paddle extended a bit behind me like a lever. Eventually that worked, but as I'm attempting to paddle again in the slower water, my left arm seems to not be working very well. I look down and it seems like my shoulder is coming out of my upper left pectoral area. So I end up having to bail anyway, because I can't paddle at all. I get onto the beachy area just below Dominion and gingerly pull off my PFD to discover my shoulder in pain and dislocated. I imagine the drama of a river rescue and all the people at Belle Isle watching it unfold and decide it's time to relocate the shoulder. After a few contortions, I figure it out and the pain immediately stops. I'm able to get back to Belle Isle, just past the pedestrian bridge and haul the boat out and hike it back to Reedy, where the van is parked. After several more dislocations due to the damage, I eventually needed surgery on that shoulder and I have a permanent wariness of doing anything too strenuous to it. I seldom paddle whitewater anymore because I don't want to risk reinjury.
I saved the worst for last. Not a personal story, but one recounted to me by a friend who lived in Oregon Hill in the late 90s-early 2000s. He was walking his dog along the Belle Isle path next to the river when he sees two guys in a canoe coming down the south side of the river, where the big rapids are. They capsize. All their gear goes everywhere. They make it to shore, but the boat gets washed downstream. As they're catching their breath, my friend asks if they're OK. After awhile one of the dudes decides to try to recover some of their stray gear, which is still floating in eddys nearby. He climbs out on the rocks and as he's reaching for his stuff, he falls in and gets pinned to the rock. He's basically hugging the rock while the water pressure pushes him against it. He can't do anything but struggle to keep his head above water. His friend jumps out on to the rock and grabs his arm, but can't pull him up, due to the water pressure and friction of the rock. The guy in the water is slowly getting sucked down by the water. My friend sees what's happening and jumps out to help. Two grown men pulled on this guy and couldn't get him up or around to the side of the rock. As my friend is holding this guys hand, the guy's head slipped under the water and in less than two minutes he was dead. My friend has a hard time telling that story over a decade later.
So, in summary: The river can fuck you up and will kill you if you don't respect it's power. Be careful out there.
I don't understand how someone gets in a canoe or kayak on a river and not know how to swim.
My coworkers daughter's college rowing team had to kick out a bunch of girls because they couldn't swim. They found this out in turbulence on the Potomac.
I was on the crew team in HS, in NOVA. We had to take a swim test every year before we got near the water. We had to be wearing a sweatshirt and sweatpants and swim 4 laps without touching the sides and then tread water for 2 minutes. If you couldn't do that you couldn't be on the team.
They never intend on getting into the water, so they're overconfident and unaware that the boat could actually tip.
Jesus. That last story.