Is Scanlan ignoring his ability to add +2 to all his initiative rolls?

Question

Edit: For the record, Matt addressed/resolved this in E30 at ~0:55:35 where you can see Geralt of Rivia inform Burt Reynolds of the change :).

On at least one occasion Sam has commented to Orion after one of his frequently low initiative rolls that it's "plus 0", i.e. that he's not adding anything to his initiative rolls.

However, bards above level 1 have "Jack of All Trades" (ph54) that allow you to "add half your proficiency bonus, rounded down, to any ability check you make that doesn't already include your proficiency bonus."

This is further clarified in the Sage Advice Compendium (which contains official rule interpretations) on page 4: "Don't forget that initiative rolls are Dexterity checks, so Jack of All Trades can benefit a bard's initiative, assuming the bard isn't already adding his or her proficiency bonus to it."

That would mean that while Scanlan is between level 9 and 16 he should be getting a +2 on all his initiative rolls (4/2 for lvl9-12 and 5/2 rounded down for lvl13-16). If true (and I'm not just missing something), someone (and just one) should probably tweet this to Sam and/or Matt (I don't use twitter myself). [No need to tweet, Matt's aware!]

Posted Oct 27, 2015, 9:24 PM UTC · edited

366
MatthewMercerMatthew Mercer, DM•

Oh snap! Thank you for the clarification! I didn't think Initiative was considered a direct Ability check (which is dumb of me). I think he'll be happy to know the change. :)

60
dchapesOP•

Great to hear from you!

From my reading it seems quite easy to overlook initiative as a regular ability check and not at all dumb; there is a reason WoTC thought it was worth pointing out specifically in SA. I'd image it's even easier to overlook such a small detail like for someone like yourself who is familiar with many different rule systems and also trying to keep track of all the player's many abilities (which you do an awesome job of!).

+2 may not be much but with a large party often by the second round of combat it doesn't get to his turn (he was recently quite surprised when you called on him for the second time within a single encounter) so I'm glad to see anything that has any chance of getting more/earlier actions from our favourite bard (especially if that includes awesome inspiration songs!).

<3

14
Project3•

And you just got a shout out from the DM hisself (better than my measly upvote). Congratulations!

6
Phalinx666How do you want to do this?•

Tweet him about it?

@samriegel

4
Capt0bv10u5•

It could be a carry-over from the homebrew. I would think there are things besides soceror points and the gunslinger that had to be carried. So there may be some balance or old stats at play from Pathfinder. Not knowing much about Pathfinder, I can only venture this as a possibility.

0
nilius37•

Sorcerer points exist in 5e

5