‘Take Yo Panties Off’ defense: Redskins cite other protected products in trademark appeal
washingtonpost.com/local/take-yo-panties-off-...Posted Nov 3, 2015, 8:08 PM UTC
Posted Nov 3, 2015, 8:08 PM UTC
"It's not offensive for me to call people niggers! Little Wayne did it in the rap music!" I get that whether something is offensive and whether something is offensive enough for the trademark office to censor it are separate issues, but just because other distasteful things exist doesn't mean that you should keep doing your distasteful thing.
Jesus fuck. Just change the name and be done with it.
Exactly. I understand their argument, but personally I think it makes the name-defender powers here look MORE in the wrong.
Not enough people are saying this, IMO.
Their defense essentially boils down to, "Yeah, we're complete assholes, but look at all these other people being assholes, too!"
Its more like 'You, government, don't get to decide who can be assholes and who cannot. If you want to enforce this standard, it must be enforced equally.'
Fair enough.
I wonder if all of the companies listed in the 'skins filing are pissed, because they are now at risk of losing their trademarks. That would be awesome
(Full disclosure: I hate the Redskins and Dan Snyder, and schadenfreude doesn't go far enough to describe the utter joy I get from watching the team implode.)
How does the most political city in the country still have a fucking football team called The Redskins pulling this shit?
The team practices in VA and plays in MD. DC has no control.
Yet they're called the Washington Redskins. Makes sense.
I've persuaded my organization to drop our 10k/year season tickets to the redskins. I will be issuing a letter stating exactly why we won't renew. Dan Snyder is awful, their organization sucks and I cannot support a racist bullshit name. I'm speaking with my company's wallet.
Neat.
I mean the long story is client events aren't fun at NFL games because you're stuck with each other for an entire day, the weather sucks and everyone isn't fun. But the redskins being an awful organization made it a lot easier.
I applaud what you're doing, but supposedly the redskins have a long season ticket waiting list. That said, if enough people drop out, maybe we'll expose the fact that the waiting list doesn't actually exist.
Here is the filing: http://pdfserver.amlaw.com/nlj/Pro-Football%20opening%20brief.pdf
Go to page 24 for the example of trademarks, "many of them unprintable in The Washington Post”.
Other startling examples that would reflect government endorsement under the decision below include: SHANK THE B!T@H board game; CRACKA AZZ SKATEBOARDS; ANAL FANTASY COLLECTION, KLITORIS, and OMAZING SEX TOYS sex toys; HOT OCTOPUSS anti-premature ejaculation creams; OL GEEZER wines; EDIBLE CROTCHLESS GUMMY PANTIES lingerie; WTF WORK? online forum; MILF WEED bags; GRINGO STYLE SALSA; MAKE YOUR OWN DILDO; GRINGO BBQ; CONTEMPORARY NEGRO, F’D UP, WHITE TRASH REBEL, I LOVE VAGINA, WHITE GIRL WITH A BOOTY, PARTY WITH SLUTS, CRIPPLED OLD BIKER BASTARDS, DICK BALLS, and REDNECK ARMY apparel; OH! MY NAPPY HAIR shampoos; REFORMED WHORES and WHORES FROM HELL musical bands; LAUGHING MY VAGINA OFF entertainment; NAPPY ROOTS records; BOOTY CALL sex aids; BOYS ARE STUPID, THROW ROCKS AT THEM wallets; and DUMB BLONDE hair products. Word limits prevent us from listing more
The "Edible crotch less panties" trademark doesn't disparage an entire race of people. I fail to understand how this compares. It all seems pretty desperate to me.
I mean... ok. But there are a lot of examples there of marks that could be considered disparaging to women, "little people", people from the south, old people, blonde people, African Americans, etc.
You have to see that this applies, right?
I don't think you understood my initial post. With trademark law, almost any trademark is initially granted. Someone can then challenge the mark (as happened here) and it can be cancelled. If someone challenged any of the marks listed above, they would be cancelled.
The difference as a matter of law is that no one is challenging any of those trademarks. If someone challenged them, I'm sure those registrations would be cancelled too.
A point I expect the Redskins to make is that if those trademarks were as widely known as the Redskins, someone would protest them as well.
Dan Snyder is so disingenuous. Before this debacle, he was the guy accusing everyone of antisemitism for drawing devil horns on him, and trying to sue newspapers for printing unflattering, but true, stories of him.
A trademark has nothing to do with free speech. Dan Snyder can continue to use the name, it just means he won't be the only one making money off it, and he can't sue other people for using it. This argument stinks of the worst kind of whining..."I shouldn't be in trouble because EDIBLE CROTCHLESS GUMMY PANTIES DID IT FIRST!"
Not even that - the team still has common-law trademark protection available to them. It's only the federal trademark registration that has been canceled - and that doesn't even become official until the appellate process is concluded and the final court to hear the case ends up affirming this decision.
Wow thanks for that clarification.
[deleted]
Agreed. My personal opinion is that the name should change so I can rep my city while traveling without looking like an asshole, but they shouldn't be forced to change. It really is a first amendment issue and the lawyers provide some good examples as to how arbitrary and capricious it is for the trademark office to decide what is offensive enough to be censored.
Although this is a shift from the argument that the names not offensive at all and just refers to warpaint. I wonder if this will come back to bite them
Well, you could rep your city with one of the four other professional sports teams that play in the actual city. I mean, that's a thing.
I could, but I have no interest in other sports
I'm sorry to hear that.
Huh? No one is telling them they have to change the name. This is about protecting their trademark. In other words, their ability to profit from selling items bearing the racist logo.
[deleted]
Go to Santa Fe wearing a Redskins sweater and tell me if it's racist.
I thought so too until i saw u/njherdfan 's post
https://www.reddit.com/r/washingtondc/comments/3reaw6/take_yo_panties_off_defense_redskins_cite_other/cwov0f6