r/SSBPM•
PoisonRain

What character has the most neutral shattering strategy, and what is it?

[Discussion]

Posted Nov 5, 2015, 9:01 PM UTC

1070
SidewaysInfinity•

Bowser, because...oh wait, you probably didn't mean his own neutral

41
standardegenerate•

;_;

4
Skycracker•

nice

3
jonnyc64•

Fox with his PEWPEWPEWPEWPEWPEWPEW

24
Lolzicus•

Slow characters beware, Fox can force you to approach while remaining completely safe and actionable on the other side of the stage, and he's got a button that lets him stuff aerial approaches and the speed to stuff grounded approaches!

13
veggiedealer•

slow characters beware

19
MizterUltimaman•

We must examine the characteristics of a well-designed move first.

A low risk move should have low reward. For example, let's examine Fox's SHFF Laser at the opposite side of Dreamland. It is extremely low risk (practically unpunishable except for a Fox on the other stage doing SHFF L) and extremely low reward (1%). The risk:reward ratio is balanced, so I consider it a well-designed move.

A high risk move should have high reward. For example, let's examine Melee Ganondorf's dair. It is extremely high risk (punishable on whiff) and extremely high reward (22% and a combo). Again, the risk:reward ratio is balanced, so I consider it well-designed.

Well-designed moves have a risk comparable to the reward. If a move is super risky and had no reward it is seldomly done. A prime example is Jigglypuff's grounded Sing; it is very punishable on whiff and has negative frame advantage if the opponent can mash fast enough.


A "neutral shattering" move is something that is low risk and high reward.

For example, let's look at Lucas' JC Magnet -> DJC waveland back.

On whiff, it's very low risk. (He has low traction and is quite fast, so he can get right back into DDing and very few characters can punish it). Obviously it is punishable (everything is if spammed) but waveshining back is one of the safest options that exist (and even more so if the hitbox is in front of the user).

On shield, it's very low risk. (IIRC Lucas is already in air dodge landing lag before the shielding opponent stops being in shieldstun). It CANNOT be punished with a WD OOS; Lucas hits the ground before the opponent has even started (so in other words, the Lucas would need to waveshine back and just stand there in order to take the punish). The Lucas player has the frame advantage, so it is in his favour if the opponent WDes forward.

On hit, on reaction, it's very high reward. The Lucas player can true combo it into an Offense Up usmash regardless of DI (the Lucas can do the Usmash Standing, Dashing, or Dash Attack Cancelled). I don't think it's the strongest Usmash in the game, but it is certainly quite powerful (30% IIRC with the OU, fresh, and without A-button charge).

Therefore, since Lucas' waveshine back has low risk and high reward, it is, at the VERY LEAST, poorly designed as a move in neutral.

TLDR Read the first sentence of every paragraph.

10
orangegluon•

Neutral is more complex than simple risk on miss and reward on hit. In this case, you would be pressed to consider Zelda's Din's Fire the same utility as Fox's laser when used from across stage, since its damage output compared to risk is comparable to Fox's ease of laser use/1% damage on hit.

Secondly, Fox's laser's utility is in more than just damage. Such a view of the game is rather superficial. On only a still mechanical level, Fox's laser has an extremely subtle but devious hidden asset: it can reset the stale move list and hence add to overall damage output. Leffen covers this well https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=STR214XUsEU. In practice, then, lasers, as easy as they are to spam, can actually contribute tens of extra percents for just a few pewpews that hit, and it costs very little to actually use the laser.

More subtle even than that, Fox's laser forces the opponent to approach. Its range is so large that the Fox forces the opponent to eventually approach (or risk passive damage repeatedly) AND do so while under fire taking percents. Fox's speed means that theoretically he can also avoid the opponent's approach and scamper away to fire lasers from further. Then, even if this dance is only done once or twice, it's usually at least 3-4% extra damage in neutral for every of these types of interactions.

Whether Fox's laser is a well designed move is still not 100% clear, but my point is that whether a move is well designed or not is not so simple as to be reduced to just risk/reward numbers. I like the reductionist starting point actually, so it's not a bad place to begin analysis, but context and consideration of other factors are absolutely required for properly thinking about the move's place in neutral.

14
Lolzicus•

Fox's laser's utility is in more than just damage

^ This is exactly what I tell people. On top of what you've said about forcing approaches, the amount of damage it does is negligible. Assuming perfect play, there is absolutely no reason for a fox player to approach: Sh double laser is an option that has no real consequence to using while slower characters are forced to lumber towards him.

A good example of this is thinking in terms of how the fox will react based on the options the opponent uses.

If opponent dashes directly towards the fox from across the stage: Continue SHDL until the opponent moves into threat range, then DD ->whiff punish

If opponent attempts to Jump in aerial: Continue SHDL until opponent moves into threat range, then Jump-> Nair/Bair/Uair/Shine OR DD -> whiff punish.

If opponent attempts to wait for you to approach: Continue SHDL

If opponent attempts to use platforms: FH laser to follow them until they move into threat range, -> Nair/Bair/Uair/Shine OR DD beneath them -> Uair

All of these examples are without the Fox being forced to approach, and cover most if not all non-character specific aspects of neutral. The fact that Fox can also choose to approach himself lets him dictate when and where fights occur, and his powerful aerials give him an oppressive air game, while his fast DD options allow him to outpace slower characters and force the neutral game into punish. Shine is icing on the cake, being able to be used to stuff some grounded approaches and covering his mistakes.

Fox's laser allows him to dictate the game to the extent where any neutral lost is entirely on the Fox player choosing to approach when unnecessary or being caught by surprise from character specific tools.

9
MizterUltimaman•

Just to clarify, I think there's more to reward than damage. (And more to risk than distance.) I was just focused on that 1 aspect in my earlier comment, so I didn't think about other types of things that can be risked and rewards that can occur.

I think Zelda's Fire on the other side of DL is MUCH worse than Fox's laser on the other side of DL. Zelda has to commit for sooo long to set it up (sending it out to full length, setting it, and calling it back in); it's gotta be at least 5 seconds. Not to mention, if she overshoots (or the Fox runs in) then Zelda loses a part of her defensive game (at least until the firething comes back) that she is balanced around.

Fox has to have under 30 frames in his SH FF autocancel.

They're not even of the same caliber. Zelda has so many things she has to consider in whether or not she uses the Fire; Fox just goes ahead without hesitation. Time is just as much of a unit as spacing or hurtbox volume, and consequently spending frames (or in Zelda's case, seconds) putting out a move is a risk; it's risking a unit of time for the possibility of getting a hit.

> stale move list . . . Leffen

I always forget about that video.

> More subtle even than that, Fox's laser forces the opponent to approach.

> Fox's laser forces the opponent to approach.

You could say that about any character with a projectile. I'd go as far as say that's Day 1 fighting game training; the characters with projectiles can camp forever, while the characters without projectiles are forced to close the distance to use their non-projectile weapons (and not be dodging projectiles till eternity ends).

Fox's laser isn't just OP because it forces the approach (Snake and Samus and any character with a projectile, inherently, forces an approach). It's OP because even if the opponent approaches Fox, Fox still has the best options on defensive... I don't think I'm going to find any flaws

I thought I'd try arguing all of the pros of Fox's lasers in neutral and then switch to the cons (for an objective/unbiased look at Fox). I couldn't find any cons, other than it takes a little more time than in Melee to deal the same damage.

2
orangegluon•

The difference between most projectiles and Fox's is that it's not so easily and safely spammable. Most projectiles are at least clankable, or slow enough to be easily avoided. Perhaps the only characters with projectile fireability close to Fox's are the Links and Samus and Falco, since they have so many good projectiles. But those projectiles come with fairly big cooldown. Arguably Samus's missile barrage is quite comparable or even better than Fox's SHDL, but that's an anomalous case. Falco's laser is considered better for other reasons, but its rewards are much sweeter for approaching with lasers, and the only real response to them I've ever seen is "git gud @ puwursheeld." But that's neither here nor there.

Mario's fireball can be jumped over pretty well, or easily powershielded without much consequences, and have exuberant endlag compared to the Fox SHDL's. Luigi's is even slower. ROB's projectiles come with large wait times in between, GnW's bacon has limited and uncontrolled range compared to most projectiles (even though it's an amazing combo starter, to be fair), Olimar's Pikmin are highly variable, Diddy Kong's peanut popgun has fair cooldown, etc etc. My point here is that these projectiles, while more painful per blow, are not as commanding from far away.

What might be a random possibility I thought of is if Fox's lasers lost power from further away. At mid range they might do a percent or two (closer in than their max range now), and at very close in they could do significantly more damage. This discourages circle camping, and pushes Fox to do what he seems to be designed by Sakurai to be good at (i.e., getting lots of quick hits) while making himself at risk of retaliation during SHDL or even SHSL when he tries to encroach and keep a mild distance from the opponent. Therefore, Fox has to use his laser ability tactically rather than by camping hard. The big drawback I foresee at the moment is that this may encourage just camping of a different kind, throwing a laser up close and then retreating. While this is bad, it's also forcing Fox to at least partially approach.

This idea isn't that well fleshed out, but it may be worthwhile thinking about.

3
Lolzicus•

Fox's lasers already lose power from further away, but even if they did 1% from edge to edge they still force approaches.

Edit: It actually is 1% from edge to edge. I checked. Damage is the least concerning of this move's properties.

3
MizterUltimaman•

The big drawback I foresee at the moment is that this may encourage just camping of a different kind, throwing a laser up close and then retreating. While this is bad

I've thought about this before; I think it's a good idea of have the lasers function like this. It encourages getting up close as oppose to avoiding the opponent and camping. Which one would you rather have; a Fox that tries to get in close and spam lasers, or one that hangs behind and spams lasers? Actually, let's take personal opinion out of this and try to make Fox play similar to his Starfox 64 playstyle. Does the Fox in Starfox 64 camp and shoot lasers? Or does he actively approach the ships, chasing them down and shooting lasers?

My only knowledge of Starfox is that Brawl Demo thing, so I think it's the one that heavily encourages shooting up close and completely negates laser camping.

1
EclipseKirby•

I feel like you're undervaluing the main component of neutral: position . If your low risk-high reward option forces you to lose control of center as you do it, you aren't shattering neutral; you're slowly losing it.

11
MizterUltimaman•

True. And Lucas' WD back goes far too, so he's really putting a lot of stage positioning on the line for a gamble.

It's not so much that I'm undervaluing the importance of neutral. It's player differences showing; it's more so that my DD is an extreme strength of mine (everybody has their strengths and weaknesses and this is one of my strengths) so I never even considered losing stage as losing anything because it's practically free for me.

(I feel like I'm bragging about my DD so I want to balance it out; I have an extremely bad projectile problem. I can't even do anything against genuine button-mashing scrubs; I just run through the hits.)

1
LifeSmash#Buff Pit 2016•

The thing is that in order for Lucas to magnet->wd back, he either cannot do it infinitely (expending stage position as a resource, thus increasing risk for future interactions, to do a move that has a skewed risk-reward ratio in the moment) or he has to move forward to do it (thus exposing him to risk because if the opponent also moves forward with like a SHFFL nair or something he's gonna get hit before magnet comes out). So you can't call it a low risk high reward move because even though the actual magnet->wd back sequence itself isn't particularly risky, creating a situation where it is actually useful requires additional risk.

3
SnoopKitties•

Falco lasers. Ez.

7
TheCyberGlitch•

Falco's laser against certain characters is ridiculous. It's very low risk, high reward, and cancels out certain approaches entirely. GnW's Bacon has a similar effect in certain characters, though at least his bacon has limited range and can be destroyed with a decent priority hitbox.

Falco's lasers are unique, being one of the only transcendent projectiles. This means they ignore priority. They cannot be cancelled or clashed with by other attacks, such as a jab or an aerial, and they cause flinching, interrupting any attack the opponent was attempting. The only way to avoid this flinching is to dodge the laser (which moves fast and horizontally, ideal on most stages), reflect it with a special move (which isn't especially effective against double lasers), break through with an armored move (which is generally predictable), or shield it (which doesn't allow you to approach at all, unless you powershield). Basically, a number of characters can't jump in neutral because lasers can stuff them no matter what they do. Approaching on the ground isn't a great option either, given the laser's ground covering trajectory and Falco's impressive mobility.

The laser completely removes certain characters options to approach, breaking their neutral game. A number of characters seem to have been buffed specifically to deal with Falco's laser, especially tall ones who had few options to avoid them. Charizard was given one of the fastest ground speeds in the game. Ganon was given a way to hover over them and reflect them. Donkey Kong was given fast ground speed and a dash attack with light armor just strong enough to ignore Falco's lasers (most other projectiles/attacks stuff it). Bowser was given light armor while crawling. The game has literally been balanced around this neutral breaking projectile. Despite these efforts, Falco is still a really difficult matchup for most of these characters, since laser still disabled their airborne options.

Removing the laser's transcendent property could go a long way to making these matchups less broken.

5
marineman43•

I agree entirely. It's a very hard thing to change because it's been around since the beginning of Melee and people would be up in arms if it was removed, but I'm of the opinion that Falco's lasers are stupidly good and make the neutral really miserable for most characters, and near impossible for some.

3
danbandwagon•

Falco's laser is fine. Just powershield it; that's what Melee players have been doing for years.

Falco needs a good neutral because he gets punished incredibly hard, is super light and has a really short distance recovery.

With the nerf of his ridiculous dair in Melee, he's probably one of the most well-balanced characters in the game.

0†
TheCyberGlitch•

I'm talking about matchups with characters that weren't viable in Melee. Of the characters I mentioned, the only one close to viable in Melee was Ganon, and Falco was one of his worst matchups for the same reasons I listed here. For these characters, "Just powershield it" wasn't good enough then, and it isn't good enough now. These characters need to be able to leave the ground.

And while Falco has limits to his recovery, which justifies him having a strong neutral game, I would contend that his Side B is a potent recovery option. What it lacks in vertical distance, it makes up for in speed. In PM, getting back to the ledge/platform before your opponent had time to take it is very important. I'd also point out that his lightness is largely offset by his high fall speed, which reduces vertical knockback and can give him survival comparable to floaty Heavies.

In any case, no amount of poor recovery justifies giving a character a neutral option that completely shuts down another character's options. That's just bad game design.

2
danbandwagon•

There are definitely ways around Falco's lasers.

I'm a Ganon main. It's not impossible.

1
TheCyberGlitch•

Could you elaborate? It seems like a pretty damn harsh matchup in Melee at the very least.

1
Pegthaniel•

Nah he's still incredible. Maybe even buffed in a vacuum given that a somewhat weaker dair (still better than PAL Melee) is well worth B-reversible and wavebounceable lasers. His combos are slightly less good on average since PM is a bit floatier but he's still a monster.

0
danbandwagon•

Yeah he's good... but he's not even top tier. And he doesn't have anything janky about him. I don't understand why people think he's so godlike. There's just a lot of good Falco players.

2
Pegthaniel•

He's definitely top tier still... I don't know why people think hes' gotten so much worse.

1
TheCyberGlitch•

Tiers have to do with a variety of factors and a variety of matchups. We're just talking about the neutral game and a handful of matchups where Falco's antiapproach weapon is far too effective. Even if another character has a better neutral game on average, Falco has some of the most polarized neutral game matchups by design.

1
jtarun•

"buffed in a vacuum" literally means nothing

Also, b-reversible and wavebounceable lasers are definitely not worth weaker dair, decaying laser, and invincible shine.

He is still pretty good, but definitely not buffed.

1
Gotohellcadz•

gnw with the free bacon hits...

4
Epicfaillord•

ganondorf flair

no kidding man fuck that move to hell and back

3
JekyllMD•

Samus with the super wavedash kappa

3
Epicfaillord•

You'd be surprised. Super wavedash>whatever is safe anywhere.

2
PoisonRainOP•

Falco laser -> shine -> whatever you damn well please.

It's like all of Squirtle's wet floor tech. If it was safe in the neutral that's all we would do.

5
Epicfaillord•

Yeah but you can shield falco stuff, you don't get anything for shielding samus shenanigans.

1
PoisonRainOP•

There's so many unactionable frames though. You're literally spreading your hurtbox across half the stage before you can do anything. Any projectile or a well timed smash attack can knock you out of it. Not to mention you give a big hint in advance by using morph ball bombs far away from the opponent. I don't have to be falco either. I'm pretty sure I could start winding up a falcon punch, and land it if you try to follow through.

3
PoisonRainOP•

lol yeah! It works on my little brother all the time!

1
LnktheWolf•

I'd probably say Falco's lazer. It flinches with no knockback, stopping you in your tracks. It has a long range, getting you from across the stage. If done correctly, it's decently safe and extremely frustrating. And it's transcendent, with the only way to not get hit by it is to shield, which can be punished, and avoiding it completely.

On the flipside, even though it's not what the thread is asking, the think that just crushes the non-neutral to submission are the flame throwers and Luigi's get out of jail free card.

3
JiggzSawPanda•

Define neutral shattering.

2
PoisonRainOP•

Mewtwo's original Teleport-nair was neutral-shattering, because you could use it from most anywhere and it was pretty safe on shield (not to mention effective on hit). It skipped a lot of the footsies that happen as players try to get each other to mess up and leave themselves open.

10
VaranFenix•

Luigi wavedash when applied correctly. The only real answer is a sex kick or being able to dominate ground approaches safely and quickly.

2
MizterUltimaman•

Wouldn't Falcon's DD be better than Luigi's WD? I'd imagine it's faster (if not the exact same speed) but MUCH more controllable (due to there being no 10 frame commitment).

1
VaranFenix•

The difference is that Luigi carries momentum after choosing an attack. So he can cross up shield freely and be way out of range of OoS options. His Up-smash makes his head intangible so he can shark people who leave the ground super easily. And the 10 frame commitment is negligible when your wavedash carries you over 60 frames lol

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
RoadWarriorRonin•

Always thought Ivy was like that. The person could be trying to keep me out in neutral then I start healing myself and they immediately stop and resort to offensive play

1
Tjmachado•

Well a well-played Mewtwo could do this in my opinion:

Approach? What approach? Disable Grab-Combo

Projectiles? Have it back. Confusion

Lasers? How quaint, I have a projectile that actually does something Shadow Ball

1
SailorMercurySSB•

Squirtle.

I honestly feel like the vast majority of the movement tech he can do just straight up should not be in this game. It's one of the last remaining examples of something that is poorly designed that exists in PM, and imo its presence makes the game look bad.

All characters have a base set of movement options available to them that are universal (dash dancing, wavedashing, RAR, wavebouncing, etc). A couple characters (ike, lucario, rob, etc) have an extra burst movement option that you must watch out for in the relevant matchup, but that's all the additional stuff you have to look out for - it's like certain characters having a "divekick" of sorts.

Squirtle's movement options make him more like taking a guilty gear character and dropping them into street fighter. It doesn't matter if you balance all of their attacks around it, having a guilty gear character in street fighter who is capable of completely running circles around everybody else in the cast in totally unique ways would invalidate the overall design concept of the game and the way its neutral is supposed to work, flipping it on its head versus that one character and only that one character.

It's just bad news.

-1†
Lolzicus•

Lucario flair

7
SailorMercurySSB•

Lucario's gimmicks just allow him to punish really hard/weird - they don't give him heaps of new character-specific movement options that completely change how the neutral is played in comparison to the entire rest of the cast.

7
Lolzicus•

I absolutely agree: Lucario isn't going to throw anybody off with his neutral. However, his punish game, especially shield pressure, works so different to every other character that he forces you to learn options to counter it specifically: If you get caught in shield you're forced to buffer rolls which can still lead to combos, and if you get hit normally counterattacking is incredibly hard and your mindset needs to shift entirely to defensive options like DI. His OHC gives him the ability to be incredibly oppressive against offensive playstyles and arguably makes him one of the strongest characters in the game.

In other words, Lucario is just as if not more polarizing than Squirtle, as Squirtle has good neutral tools and Lucario has good punish tools.

Edit: Didn't even mention his Aura charges which turn options like Down-b or Up-b into approach options at the expense of a charge which honestly at high level play can be regained by continuing the combo out of the approach. He's got a lot of things going for him as well.

3
SailorMercurySSB•

At the end of the day though, lucario's cancels allow him to have a good punish game because they let him take his relatively weak attacks and hit people with them lots, where other characters' regular-ass hits allow them to have good punish games while hitting people not-as-much. The basic principles of the punish game remain the same across lucario and everyone else in the cast - one player is getting hit and trying to DI/tech/dodge somehow to get out of it and not die, and the other one is trying to follow that DI/tech/dodge somehow in order to convert into a kill. Lucario is not given some ludicrous amount of tools that make him more capable of following up and chasing the DI of somebody he's comboing compared to everybody else - he just has tools to put out lots of hitboxes really fast.

His shield pressure is also definitely not unique.

Now, I'm not that up on a lot of PM-specific frame data (so it could be more than just the 5 characters I'm about to mention), but I do know that having extremely tight/frame safe shield pressure that requires the opponent to buffer roll in order to get out is something shared by, at the very least, all space animals (because of shine - and note that these are also extremely popular characters), peach (because of float cancelling), and lucario (because of cancelling into command grab). So other characters do have it.

Regardless, and considering the neutral is like... one of the deepest and most beautiful things about smash, I think having a character with a ton of extra tools that nobody else has that completely change the way it's played at a fundamental level (squirtle) is much more of a big deal/glaring flaw than having some characters that don't change the game but have particularly strong punish games in certain situations (spacies/lucario/peach).

2
JekyllMD•

Having an invincible approach that can be canceled into an attack is different though

1
Turbo1928•

It's not invincible anymore, so it's a lot weaker than you would think

1
shinyskarmory•

What specific issues do you have with his toolkit?

I mean, his range is awful with very few disjoints, his killing power isn't unusual for PM, and his tech roll is objectively awful as compared to other tech rolls. All he has is his mobility techs, which I assume is what you think is jank about him.

Like without those techs Squirtle wouldn't be a viable character, he'd be Pichu who doesn't deal self damage. Being slippery is all Squirtle has that makes him worth playing.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
MizterUltimaman•

It's far from "jank". If you can get in this face he can't pivot (because he can't run; if he's getting pressured the best he can do is dash). His pivot is the only unintuitive aspect of him I can think of.

I'd imagine Lucario has good shield pressure (especially with a Command Grab at the end of the magic series).

TLDR Get up in his face and don't let him do his confusing things and you won't get confused.

1