[Unverified] Anti-SJW hashtags no longer autocomplete on Twitter?

UNVERIFIED

Here's another apparent example of what seems to be Twitter’s ever-growing political bias. When you starting typing a hashtag (#), it will gradually come up with different suggestions for auto-completion as you type it out. GamerGate used to be suggested from the moment you typed #Ga, now it doesn’t show up at all. However, right now if I type #Gamer, I get the suggestion #GamerGateFailed. Interesting. #GamerG yields the additional suggestion of #gamergateTimeTravel. How helpful.

Now, when this first happened it seemed like it could just be a bug (sometimes #GamerGate would autocomplete, sometimes it wouldn’t), but now it more and more consistently won’t autocomplete, and hasn’t done so for me at all for several days. Some Twitter users explained this by GamerGate being an old hashtag, crowded out by newer ones. Fast forward to this weekend then, when #JeSuisMilo became one of the hottest hashtags on Twitter. Suspiciously (seeing how this was a hashtag that condemned Twitter’s bias and hypocrisy) it soon vanished from the list of trending hashtags, and shortly after that it completely stopped autocompleting. This despite being one of the weekend’s most popular hashtags, not a near-ancient one like #GamerGate.

However, the misandrist hashtag #wastehistime still autocompletes. #ResistCapitalism still autocompletes. Even #Killallwhitemen is still an autocomplete hashtag. But not #JeSuisMilo, not #rapefugees (another hashtag that blew up this week, for obvious reasons), and according to several German users I’ve come across, various Anti-Angela Merkel hashtags never end up autocompleting either. Now, all this could all just be a case of bugs or Twitter being slow to update – but given its record of double standards, this issue seems worth investigating further.

Posted Jan 10, 2016, 5:49 PM UTC

667167
Cakes4077•

This seems like Twitter is starting to implement containment stuff that we heard about earlier.

241
dominotw•

twitter has saudi investor ( second biggest stake holder), which makes sense given how twitter was instrumental in arab spring.

87
nmotsch789•

How was Twitter instrumental in the Arab Spring, and how would a Saudi Arabian man benefit from the Arab Spring?

14
NEWater•

How Twitter helped in the Arab Spring:

"We use Facebook to schedule the protests, Twitter to coordinate, and YouTube to tell the world."

A Saudi investor would rather want Twitter to curtail Twitter's potential in spreading movements like the Arab Spring again, because the Arab Spring was a threat to the Saudi government.

50
thehighground•

Makes sense, now SJW are in bed with a promoter of known terrorist supporters and a royal family who believe in stripping women of their rights. They really are stupid.

22
macsenscam•

Actually, the "Arab Spring" took down some of the Saudis major rivals and cemented them as #1 in the middle east. They may be sick of it by now though.

0
DStoo•

In 2016 there would be a completely different tool. These guys are playing whack a mole with technology.

Twitter helped because it was in the right place at the right time.

1
dominotw•

They are in talks to buy snapchat soon.

1
Gengar11•

Just jumping in at the top here. Can we get a #GGTest hastag going to see if it shows up on twitter autofill?

8
1428073609•

They won't censor that one, because they'll know we're testing for censorship :P

5
Gengar11•

Doubt they care.

2
sjwking•

Has George Orwell predicted this? Private companies censoring all "problematic" news seem too Orwellian

50
thipp•

Has George Orwell predicted this?

Orwell didn't really write anything about private companies censoring themselves or people who use their services. That was more along the lines of Fahrenheit 451.

39
dotbykorsk•

That has nothing to do with Fahrenheit 451. I realize that it's a common mistake on this sub but the book had zero to do with censorship. Bradbury made that extremely clear.

-26
LonelyCannibal•

the book had zero to do with censorship. Bradbury made that extremely clear.

"Students, reading the novel, which, after all, deals with censorship and book-burning in the future..." - Ray Bradbury

How in blazes you think a book about book burning has zero to do with censorship I can't fathom. Pun not intended but happily noted after punctuating.

40
CaptainDogeSparrow•

Bradbury said many things during his lifetime. Mostly bullshit.

4
thipp•

The book literally talks about censoring things in order to not be offensive.

If Bradbury wrote that and then insists the book wasn't about censorship, then he's the shittiest author in history.

3
JasonWaterfall•

He didn't need to predict the phenomenon because it already existed - he had a lot of trouble finding a publisher for Animal Farm because of the prevailing pro-russian sentiment at the time. He talks about it in the foreword to that book.

8
scorcher24•

Eve Online. Corporations are in power there, governments have basically nothing to say. Only neutral power is concord, but they only watch over the rules of war, they don't interfere unless an attack was illegal.

4
Aestiva•

Grrr, goons.

1
thatcoolmartian•

What containment stuff?

8
Cakes4077•

I may be getting my stories mixed up, but I believe they were going to implement stuff similar to shadowbans and unviewable containment subs, but for Twitter.

10
AdamMc66•

That seems.... stupid and so counter-productive to Twitter as a platform to not even be funny.

1
Cakes4077•

One of the reasons why if Twitter doesn't do something it's stock will be 0 before too long.

4
Strazdas1•

correct me if im wrong, but wasnt that facebook, not twitter?

1
Cakes4077•

Like I said, I could be getting my stories mixed up, but it wouldn't be any sort of stretch to believe Twitter would do these things too.

1
IronicSpeech•

Can you really get any dumber? Dear twitter, hiding something from the people is just gonna make people search for it more!

It seems like all their attempts to destroy history made them not learn from it. If seeing a comment graveyard on a normal post doesn't make people think "what a great action by our mods!", why would the deletion of auto complete for my favourite source of soggy knees do anything different?

We really need to start digging a grave for twitter, right next to MySpace and every attempt of Atheism+

102
baskandpurr•

All these attempts to control the conversation can do is stop it happening. Twitter is a platform for people to discuss and making that more difficult is signing your own DNR.

11
Immolus•
92
TeuthexAwesome Person•

...So it autocompletes to a typo of notyourshield?

87
Ironic_Chancellor•

Yes.

It also completes #JeSuisMilo as "Mila" or "Milou" depending on NA or EU respectively.

60
Orgell_Evaan•

I'd expect them to use typo redirects for most, if not all the terms; it's far less obvious and accomplishes the same thing (even better if there's a rotating set of typos, to dilute even further).

33
Rannos22•

Please stop giving them ideas.

0
DStoo•

Stop using them.

2
brontide•

I'm thinking they are not autocompleting to typos, but once you blacklist the original the typos rise to the top.

19
Antikyth3ra•

Yep. Which seems to me further evidence these hashtags have been purposefully blocked from autocomplete. They're not just removed for being old/unpopular, because the typos would be nearly as old as the correct tags, and much less popular.

14
Immolus•

Exactly.

2
HBlight•

What region are you in? I'm getting results as a euro, but my account has also got posts associated with those tags too.

But it's no secret that there are people in power at twitter who are willing to let their ideology dictate the reality of a communication medium.

10
Immolus•

East Coast, US

2
gabrielmodesta•

Tested a few, yep this appears to be the case. Interestingly someone else mentioned this and I tested the same just earlier today. Looks like the updates are complete and the filter is fully in place.

I'm really happy to see this though. I'd like to see twitter bankrupt. The only barrier to replacing twitter is obtaining critical mass, which is impossible with a responsibly-run Twitter. By pushing an entire segment of their users out on political lines, they have created an opening.

77
Spidertech500•

So, how would I replace twitter? What would people want us to build?

5
OPPRESSIVE_SHITLORD•

Here's an old school idea. Instead of an online platform for e-celebs to send their followers to bully each other, we build an actual gladatorial arena for followers to defend their e-celeb's honor in and livestream it.

Actually, let's just forget twitter existed.

34
voatthrowaway0•

Two men enter, one man leaves.

1
will99222•

Beyond Tumblrdome

5
Xzal•

Christopher. Walken. Wins. Aah. Fatality.

1
mypasswordisdonkeys•

"NotShitter" - as someone said in another thread about this

2
Thammuz90•

Do we need a replacement?

The world was fine before twitter existed and it's pretty clearly "healing" itself of it pretty fast. Their stock has nothing but decreased in value in the last 2 years and the userbase has been deteriorating fast.

Just let it die and good riddance.

2
sunderkeenin•

Are you sure it's worth replacing twitter to begin with? It was a bad platform for acting as pretty much anything other than a glorified RSS feed.

2
gustianus•

Something decentralized is always the answer but people will just won't use it.

1
Spidertech500•

It needs oversight and maintenance and costs

1
gustianus•

I was thinking like available only on Android, no website, just an app that sends the twits to your followers.

Forget about oversight, make it completely free.

1
garethnelsonuk•

bitmessage

1
dingoperson2•

When I type #GamerGat I get a bunch of "#Gamergate [word here]" but not "#GamerGate" on its own.

Also, "JeSuisMil" resolves to "JeSusMila", but not JeSuisMilo.

67
Kienan•

It was also JeSuisMilou or something. Gamergate has been Gamergate trans - which was about how GG hates trans people - and also Gamergate Cibile and, I believe, Gamergate Sunset. Twitter thinks they're clever.

Also, I have no clue what #GamergateTimeTravel is, but it sounds badass. Like, the other side can't time travel, unless you count revisionist history.

17
Urishima•

This is a problem. Did they find our Delorean? Who's the last guy who took it out for a spin/timetravel? Let me check the logbook.

4
voatthrowaway0•

What is a logbook? We use booklogs.

3
TonchMS•

Also, I have no clue what #GamergateTimeTravel is, but it sounds badass.

I'm fairly certain that was a tag used by GG at some point when things that happened before GG were being blamed on it.

At some point it turned into "GG killed the dinosaurs", et cetera.

3
Kienan•

Oh, we killed the dinos? Shit, man. Our bad.

1
BasediCloud•

The hashtag #tcot (top conservatives on twitter) also doesn't autocomplete anymore.

43
Antikyth3ra•

Works for me, just checked it.

1
destinypallooker•

During the #JeSuisMilo thing a few days ago, #JeSuisZoeQuinn would show up in the auto complete.

37
the_nybbler•

Yep, no #GamerGate by itself, no #JeSuisMilo even if you fill in all but the 'o'. Misspelled "#notyoursheild".

But hey, #killalljews still autocompletes along with #killallmen

Surprisingly, #trump2016 not censored yet.

37
Kienan•

Twitter on point right now. What are they doing?

1
Orgell_Evaan•

It would be interesting to, if possible, run a script to see the breadth of terms considered verboten under the New Order. To see who the fellow travelers are, as it were.

28
sauron50•

Why is it that the bad guys get the cool names :(

4
backtowriting•

Just tried it now. No #gamergate autocomplete, but it does recognise #killalljews.

24
KiA423469420One of the cutest asses /u/ExhumedLegume has ever seen•

This is actually one of the problems with censorship. Once you start deciding what people can and cannot say, the whack-a-mole game never ends. Even if the censor was an inerrant genius who only made good decisions about what statements to disallow, human stupidity is not finite.

24
050607•

No #gamergate autocomplete, but it does recognise #killalljews.

Is #killalljews from Muslims or leftists in the West? I can't tell.

9
Teyar•

Come on man. Leftists in the west are typically plugged in enough to realize that The Jews as a whole are vastly separated from the Zionist regime. I know a lot of Jews who are disgusted with Israel.

3
Strazdas1•

I was under impression they are one and the same?

0
B-VOLLEYBALL-READY•

Last I checked, this was the case.

JeSuisMilo and Gamergate, for sure.

23
DerberAuner•

interesting, but not unexpected.

But not #JeSuisMilo, not #rapefugees (another hashtag that blew up this week, for obvious reasons), and according to several German users I’ve come across, various Anti-Angela Merkel hashtags never end up autocompleting either.

give me the hashtags, ill test them out, and may be able to verify what exactly they mean, i.e. if they are maybe just racist level bullshit, or worse, if they actually ARE just hashtags against merkel. :S

21
XenoKrissOP•

Racist level bullshit, unlike #killallwhitemen? :) Merkelmussweg is one, as far as I understand it simply means "Merkel Must Go".

Also #abmerkeln, #Pegida (anti-Islam movement) and #AfD (anti-immigration party).

26
DerberAuner•

yupp, all those hashtags do not autocomplete.

pegida is not "anti-islam", it is "anti-immigration"/"anti-refugee".

"afd" is, as you state, a political party, that among other things IS anti-immigration.

"abmerkeln" means "to 'Merkel' down". akin to "to suit up/down" only with merkel.

6
XenoKrissOP•

Doesn't PEGIDA stand for Patriotic Europeans Against the Islamisation of the Occident? Sounds Anti-Islam to me, which is 100% legitimate in my view, and a position I share.

9
BasediCloud•

Anti-Islam in the sense of "No Islam in Europe". I don't think they care that much about Islam in other countries. You will not find Pegida advocating for sending troops into Islamic countries. Just to clear that up.

8
DerberAuner•

your interpretation of the abbreviation is correct, however:

whatever they may say or claim to stand for, their position is largely based on feeling, not fact, and they are (rightfully, arguably) viewed as lunatics in germany. trust me on this one, you dont want to be associated with them.

they are mostly made up of unemployed people within east germany, who see foreigners as the origin of all their woes.

look, while its absolutely true, that this sort of censorship can and should not stand, pegida is not someone i would want to be associated with, and neither should you. sorry :S

-4
BasediCloud•

"abmerkeln" translates into "to do away with Merkel" in the sense of the Penn Jilette meme "into the trash it goes". It does not mean to put her down, which would be killing her. It's not a death threat. It's a harmless "We don't want you anymore".

9
DerberAuner•

true, its like "suit up!" in how i met your mother. only "merkel down!"

i thought i made that clear?

2
DerberAuner•

Racist level bullshit, unlike #killallwhitemen? :) Merkelmussweg is one, as far as I understand it simply means "Merkel Must Go".

yupp, to both of them.

"merkelmussweg" does not autocomplete. just tried it. however a new one has popped up: "merkelhastogo". which would be the english equivalent.

("popped up" may be wrong. i dont know if its old or new, but it IS there)

1
Strazdas1•

according to Twitter hashtag timeline it had small popularity in 2013, then a few more tweets in may of 2015 and seems to be alive again since yesterday.

1
yars_retirement•

Well, hopefully Twitter resists capitalism all the way to obsolescence.

20
cvillano•

We should start a new hashtag called like #GGAutofilltest or something, get it trending and then see how long it takes until it's remived from the list of twitter autofills

18
Slumber_watcher•

Or use some other tag like #SuperbOwl that isn't used at the moment, or #igf/#igf2016. It is not like Twitter would block those.

12
voatthrowaway0•

How about gamergoat

3
JonnyMonroe•

So I assume we'll be seeing an anti-censorship competitor for twitter soon then.

10
tumblrazi•

ahem app.net, anyone?

1
superseriousguy•

This is fucking bullshit.

8
Limon_Lime37k + 48k Knight Commander - Order of the GET•

Yup.

6

Jesuismilo and Gamergate haven't for awhile, I am sure there are others.

5
Limon_Lime37k + 48k Knight Commander - Order of the GET•

1milliongamersstrong stopped showing up.

9
KiA423469420One of the cutest asses /u/ExhumedLegume has ever seen•

I've noticed several hashtags that don't autocomplete for me.

4
soitso•

I don't know what clients other people are using, but this theory is easy to debunk in the twitter web ui. http://imgur.com/5KOimIr

4
superseriousguy•
6
soitso•

That looks like the front page if you're not signed in? Mine was from a logged-in account. Looks like it's searching different stuff.

3
ClassyJacket•

Nope, it won't autofill for me either.

1