Painting_Agency•

The ministry is also proposing to give a 10-year exemption to new limits on hexavalent chromium for the Owens Corning glass plant in Guelph.

Despite this, O-C is still planning to massively downsize, leaving only 50 workers in Ontario and moving most of the plant's production to Mexico. Basically, "give us concessions, but fuck you anyway". Baffling.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
shellkek•

I feel like many would leave anyways. Why pay workers here when someone in Mexico will do it for 10x less.

Also it looks like states in usa are playing a race to the bottom when it comes to tax breaks and incentives for any big project (ex. Tesla battery factory) I want manufacturing here but I don't want a race to the bottom to drive people here.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
Painting_Agency•

Why pay workers here when someone in Mexico will do it for 10x less. Because educated, dedicated and good employees are worth a lot.

To be fair, Mexicans can be well-educated dedicated employees too. But wages are low and their government is willing to give massive concessions to companies to locate there, and thanks to NAFTA, there's no downside to it.

5
SuperSoggyCerealAlberta•

Why pay workers here when someone in Mexico will do it for 10x less.

Maybe ask Bombardier about that, I'm pretty sure they'd have a few answers for you. coughttcstreetcars

1
shellkek•

I agree they shit the bed but lots of cars and products are made in Mexico (lg plasma's and VW jetta) I think knowledge workers are the exception so keeping there well paid is crucial!

1
Painting_Agency•

I mean it's baffling that we/our government tolerate their completely mercenary behaviour. Nobody should expect a corporation to act like anything other than a hungry shark.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
Uncle007British Columbia•

Canada's glory days were from 1945 to roughly mid seventies, a huge middle class was born. Everyone thrived people paid taxes including tax paying corporations. Infrastructure was built, roads, bridges, etc, on not too much debt. Things changed when Global Corporatization started. Corporations have gotten their way by not paying their fair share, lowering corporate taxes, etc, most everything they have asked for. Look around you , infrastructure crumbling around you, where is the pay back from our benevolent Corporates. All the promises and after thirty years what have their promises produced. Now all I hear and read from guys like you is every man for themselves. Its all those lazy Canadians paying more then their fair share of taxes. All Corporations have a right to be as selfish as possible, doesn't matter if they made themselves wealthy on the backs of Canadians, they owe nothing , zilch. The Corporates have raped and pillaged and now its time to move on to the next third world country and lie to them also. Love your attitude. Tell me how is Capitalism working out for Canada in the last thirty years giving the Corporates everything they have asked for.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
going_for_a_wank•

Somebody didn't bother to read the article. The word "carbon" is not used even once in the entire article.

It even includes a table that lists the companies in question, the pollutant the exception is for, and when the exemption expires:

CompanyContaminantApproval expires
U.S. Steel (Hamilton & Nanticoke)Suspended Particulate MatterDec. 31, 2020
ArcelorMittal Dofasco (Hamilton)Suspended Particulate MatterDec. 31, 2020
ArcelorMittal Dofasco (Hamilton)Total Reduced SulphurDec. 31, 2018
Essar Algoma (Sault Ste. Marie)Suspended Particulate MatterDec. 31, 2020
Harsco Metals (Nanticoke)Suspended Particulate MatterDec. 31, 2020
Glencore (Xstrata smelter)Sulphur Dioxide (24-hr average)Dec. 31, 2018
Glencore (Xstrata smelter)Sulphur Dioxide (1-hr average)Aug. 23, 2022
Glencore (Xstrata smelter)CadmiumDec. 31, 2018
Glencore (Sudbury smelter)NickelJune 30, 2026
Vale (Sudbury)NickelDec. 24, 2021
Vale (Sudbury)Sulphur DioxideDec. 24, 2017
Oxy Vinyls (Niagara)Vinyl ChlorideFeb. 1, 2017
ADM Agri-Industries (Windsor)Suspended Particulate MatterDec. 15, 2018

There is also a proposed 10-year exemption to new hexavalent chromium limits for the Owens Corning glass plant in Guelph.

The whole point of the exemptions is that the technology to meet the emissions requirements does not exist yet. Not giving these exemptions would mean that all these manufacturing jobs would be sent to China or somewhere else with lax environmental standards.

2
garlicroastedpotato•

Suspended Particulate Matter is made of carbon monoxide and elemental carbon. So yeah, steel producers are most definitely major contributors to global warming.

1
deadfulscreamYukon•

Suspended particulate matter isn't always carbon monoxide and elemental carbon. ADM is grain.

3
going_for_a_wank•

What? No, are you making this up? The amount of carbon released as particulate matter is minuscule compared to other sources of atmospheric carbon, and the magnitude of the overall effects of PM on climate is highly uncertain. The carbon particulate that has the greatest effect on the climate is black carbon, which is produced by incomplete combustion - mostly from incomplete combustion in diesel engines and the open burning of forests and savannah, not from steel mills and refining livestock feed. It only stays suspended in the air for weeks, and most industrial black carbon emissions are from China and India where emissions regulation is weak.

The reason that suspended particulate matter is regulated is because the small particles (<2.5 μm) can penetrate deep into your alveoli and cause serious health effects and exacerbate lung disease - especially among children and the elderly. These emissions regulations have nothing to do with climate change, that is a completely different set of regulations.

1
garlicroastedpotato•

Wow that glowing defense of big steel. It only has a moderate effect on our environment and will cause serious health effects. Better not regulate it then I guess.

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
PM_PoutineBritish Columbia•

These companies produce a lot of pollution because of the nature of the operations, and there is no way around that. If they weren't exempted, they would move just elsewhere and create the same amount of pollution.

3
going_for_a_wank•

Did you read the article? The technology to meet the new emissions standards does not exist yet. Most of the operations listed are already working on upgrades to reduce emissions. The 9 of the 10 exemptions are for less than 5 years, and exist to give the companies a chance to improve their emissions controls.

Penalizing companies for not having non-existant technology will just serve to push more manufacturing out of Ontario to Mexico or China.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
going_for_a_wank•

It is relevant that the technology doesn't exist, it means that the government is placing impossible restrictions on businesses. It doesn't disadvantage their cleaner competitors because there are none - smelting and metallurgy is a dirty business, most people are just lucky enough to live far away from it.

The fact is that if we don't accommodate these businesses while they change to meet new regulations, then they will leave the country. If they move to countries like China or India, the overall emissions will increase - demand won't go away and they won't bother to meet western environmental regulations when Chinese and Indian rules are much more lax. This phenomenon is called pollution outsourcing, and is becoming a major international issue that the US IPCC is discussing.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
WilliamOfOrangeOntario•

Just another trade mark case of liberals picking the winners and the lossers through government exceptions to what are supposed to be blanket regulations

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1