Ice cream substitute with bananas!

I hope recipe posts are ok! I joined this sub because damn, I could really use the support. I've been struggling with sugar addiction for awhile. I eat healthy enough, but get extreme sugar cravings frequently. My biggest weakness is ice cream. I have tried substituting fruit, which helps some. However, I generally won't reach for fruit instead of ice cream- even though I know it will likely help, I just don't want it!

Recently, I have discovered banana ice cream! I've been substituting this for my sugar cravings for two weeks now, with great success. I only broke down and bought ice cream once, and that's because it hit me while at the store, not at home like usual.

I think because it is frozen, I can eat it with my dedicated ice cream spoon (shut up), and the texture is similar, so it satisfies my craving.

Keep a bunch of overly ripe bananas in your freezer, sliced or whole when they go in, however lazy you're feeling when you toss them in the freezer. When they're ready, if already sliced, great! You're ready to rock! If not, slice those bitches.

Put a couple cups of sliced bananas in your blender or food processor. Add a splash of milk. Push the button that makes all the noise. Stop, scrape to the bottom, repeat. Go in short bursts. If it just won't blend, add a splash more milk. Just enough to make it blend. You should still have to push the mixture to the bottom the first few bursts. When everything is good and mixed, do that thing you do and put it in your face.

This has been a massive help for me. I tried banana ice cream in the past, but all the recipes I found didn't use milk. Huge pain in the ass, and I almost broke my blender. This works awesome with milk, and I don't notice a difference in texture at all. I'm sure you could substitute any weird non-dairy milk of your choice.

Posted Apr 1, 2016, 5:20 PM UTC

9445
ladyvader119•

I wish all recipes read as this one does.

21
theFerkelOP•

Thanks, that made my day.

9
gruxz•

Is it normal for the peels to go brown when you put the whole banana in the freezer?? I tried this in the past but I wasn't sure about the brownness so I haven't gotten past the freezing step lmao.

13
theFerkelOP•

Yes it is, but you can just peel them first and stick them in a ziploc bag.

Ok I'm sorry I tried to reply seriously, but I'm laughing my butt off wondering why you put them in with the peels. Thank you, that amused me a lot. Not trying to make fun of you!

10
gruxz•

Haha it's just one of those things where you try it when you're drunk and sober you doesn't question drunk you. Definitely should have sat and thought about it for a second! Thanks!

7
theFerkelOP•

this is the best answer

3
noobwithboobs•

Oh wow, I've been doing it wrong for years. I've always just chucked the whole bananas in the freezer. I just never thought of doing it any other way...

3
monobrauw•

I only made the mistake of freezing a whole banana once, it's a pain in the ass to peel! Do as she says, peel then freeze in a ziploc and way to go.

4
kaicurious•

I normally peel them and put them in a zip lock cut into thirds or quarters

3
gruxz•

Yeah I definitely didn't think it through when I did it lol Thanks!

3
djcarlos•

Me too, I froze them unpeeled once and it was a nightmare trying to get the frozen peel off! Now I peel and half them and use for making smoothies.

3
BelaAnn•

I peel them before freezing. They go into a ziploc.

2
cpb•

The Champion Juicer, and, maybe other masticating juicers are great for this. If you like banana ice cream, you might love pineapple ice cream.

6
theFerkelOP•

oh man! Do you have a favorite recipe/method?

4
cpb•
  1. Freeze cut pineapple.
  2. Chew it with a machine.
  3. Enjoy with a spoon.

Compared to frozen mango pineapple retains the most flavour when chilled.

14
ZombieBytez•

And watermelon! I chop those up and freeze them till I'm ready for some watermelon icee :D

3
cpb•

When I processed frozen watermelon it tasted like an earthy gourd.

3
ZombieBytez•

Hm was it very ripe? I'd have it on it's own, but it gets kind of thick so I usually add a little juice or something similar. If you don't eat it right away the pulp separates a bit though.

3
speed3_freak•

Just an FYI, Bananas are still carb heavy. If you're really looking to cut the sugar, there are a lot of homemade, low carb, sugar free ice cream recipes out there that are good sources of fat and protein. You can even add protein powder to most of them.

5
theFerkelOP•

I figure it's better than my usual sugar bomb binge, for now. With ice cream I'll eat a pint in one sitting- banana ice cream I'll use about three bananas. So I'm not super worried, but I definitely am working my way toward a low carb diet. I always just feel better when I manage one!

Can you share some recipes? I can't have artificial sweeteners (Stevia is ok), they give me issues which I will not discuss in polite company.

5
speed3_freak•

http://www.ditchthecarbs.com/2015/07/17/best-low-carb-sugar-free-ice-cream/

Use Stevia. Your average banana has 14g of sugar in it, so three bananas have more sugar than a 12 oz coke. Don't get me wrong, it's a whole lot better (and cheaper) than a pint of B&J's.

3
nargi•

Bananas also have fiber and potassium and vitamins C and B-6.

And Coke has high fructose corn syrup. and is highly acidic.

But yeah, they're totally totally the same, health-wise...

0†
speed3_freak•

I didn't say they were the same health-wise, I said 3 bananas have more sugar than a can of coke. If you're worried about sugar intake (which I thought was the whole point of this sub) then eating 3 bananas is not good for you. There are a lot of other low sugar options to get your fiber, potassium, and vitamins.

That's like diabetic people who thing they're doing well when they sit down and eat 4 oranges and pear. That's still a lot of sugar even if you're not eating a candy bar.

4
reeblebeeble•

I'm contributing as someone who doesn't have a problem with sugar cravings. Subbing cakes etc. for fruit was the best thing I ever did with my diet. If you really love sweets and you have an addictive personality, subbing refined sugars for fruits is probably the best way forward while minimising your chances of losing control and bingeing.

Carbs are not inherently bad for you; while some people may benefit from a very low-carb diet, not everyone who has a problem with sugar should accept that premise-- it depends on individual metabolisms. Cutting refined sugar is a great thing to do, but the form you consume it in does matter. Sugar + fibre is a good combo (e.g. oatmeal with fruit), sugar + fat is a bad combo (e.g. ice cream, cakes, etc.).

4
speed3_freak•

Carbs are not inherently bad for you, but studies have shown that all non-fiber carbs are treated roughly the same by your body.

Sugar is sugar regardless of the form that it comes in. Yes, refined sugar has all the sugar with none of the nutrients, but a banana with 14 grams of sugar has just as much as a piece of candy with 14 g of sugar. Is it better for you? Absolutely. The candy is empty calories while the banana is nutritious. However, this is a sub about limiting the amount of sugar you consume, so people need to understand that honey, starches, glucose, fructose, etc are all treated the same after they enter the blood stream.

Is eating 3 bananas better than eating a pint of ice cream? Absolutely. Is eating 3 bananas good for you if you're trying to limit your sugar? Absolutely not.

1
reeblebeeble•

Right, but because the presence of the fibre actually helps control blood sugar, the effects of the sugar are different after eating high-fibre foods than in low- or no-fibre foods. You still get a blood sugar spike after eating, but the fibre smooths out the spike-and-dip cycle that makes pure sugar so addictive. So, I mean, yes, sugar is sugar, but when you're talking about the sugar in a banana, that's really by definition alone. Because the sugar in the banana is not refined sugar (also by definition). There's a reason most dieticians don't "count" the sugar that's in fruits and vegetables towards recommended sugar limits. It's not just that the sugar is a necessary evil in order to consume the vitamins that are in the banana. The sugar in the banana is literally less harmful because of the fibre package it comes in.

1
Cige•

Also a suggestion, this works great for milkshakes too. Just add some frozen berries.

4
vashtiii•

Yep, frozen berries, banana and milk is terrific. More of a meal substitute than a drink, but better than soda.

6
PlaidPCAK•

Dessert bullet or yonanas are made for this.

Edit: I've only used dessert bullet does its job well

3
theFerkelOP•

What's a yonana? Is it a thing just for making banana ice cream? Cause that would make me laugh. A lot.

4
PlaidPCAK•

Yeah it's a kitchen appliance

5
BelaAnn•

That's what it is. But I use it for a lot more than just bananas.

2
nargi•

If you have a food processor or a good blender (like a Vita-Mix), these kitschy things are completely unnecessary.

0
flippityfloppity•

Oooh add a tablespoon of [unsweetened!] cocoa powder and some apple slices to that shit and it's like a chocolate milkshake!!!!

3
EminentlyReasonable•

I have some sliced bananas in my freezer right now with this in mind. :) I add cinnamon to mine.

2
theFerkelOP•

of course! I can't believe I haven't yet, I love cinnamon.

2
nargi•

adding cocoa powder isn't a bad thing either.

1
DarxusC•

What happens if you finish making the stuff and then freeze it?

2
theFerkelOP•

I haven't tried that yet!

3
EminentlyReasonable•

It will stay ice cream like at least for 5 days or so. I've never kept it longer than that.

2
Alia_mondo•

Love this idea!

2
jessr16•

Also to help with ice cream cravings I love Halo Top ice cream. Check it out. It's amazing!

2
BelaAnn•

I do something very similar. We bought a yonana machine when they first came out. It's been great at keeping DH off of actual ice cream. I make it in huge batches and use different fruits with the bananas for flavor. They go into the freezer in preportioned bowls. No worries about sugar, fat, etc.

1
fitwithmindy•

Frozen banana ice cream is a lifesaver. You can also use frozen blueberries or other frozen fruits mix in with some cream cheese for low carb ice cream options. Check out r/ketorecipes for some low sugar dessert options.

1
spoonsforks•

Banana + Peanut butter, mash and freeze. AMAZING

1