I need a little advice on this British Brown Ale (2015 BJCP 12C) recipe

EDIT: argh, sorry! Title should be 2015 13B. Can't seem to edit on mobile app though. Brown and Biscuit in my version should be oz, not lbs. Fixed that.

Well, actually, it's a Northern English Brown Ale (2008 BJCP 11C) recipe. There aren't a lot of proven recipes for the 2015 categories floating around yet, but the description and stats for 2008 Northern English Brown Ale seemed pretty similar to those of the 2015 British Brown Ale, and I found a medal-winning recipe for it, so figured I'd give that a try!

The original recipe is:

5 Gallons, OG 1.056, FG 1.018, ABV 4.99%

8lb British Pale Ale
1lb Dextrin
2lb Crystal 75L
1lb Munich
0.5lb Brown
0.5lb Biscuit
4oz Special Roast
4oz Chocolate
4oz Victory

1oz Northern Brewer @ 60min
1oz Williamette @ 30min
1oz Fuggle @ 15min
1oz UK Golding @5min

WLP002

It calls for mashing @145F for 30 min, then raising the temp to 152F and holding for another 60 minutes.

After adjusting the grain bill for my system and desired batch size, I came up with:

5.5 Gallons, OG 1.055, FG 1.018, ABV 4.99%

5lb British Pale Ale
11oz Dextrin
1lb, 6oz lb Crystal 75L
11oz Munich
5.5oz Brown
5.5oz Biscuit
2.75oz Special Roast
2.75oz Chocolate
2.75oz Victory

????? oz Northern Brewer @ 60min
????? oz Williamette @ 30min
????? oz Fuggle @ 15min
????? oz UK Golding @5min

WLP002

The adjusted grain bill will give me nearly the same OG for a larger batch size on my system, while still keeping the proportions of grains the same (58% pale, 14.5% crystal, etc). I have no clue what to do about the hop schedule, though. The original recipe's hop schedule results in an IBU of 42. The IBU range for this style is 20-30 IBU, and without adjusting the hop schedule on my adjusted recipe, I'd end up with over 50 IBU. I know that hops are more than just a number, and that the fact that the original recipe was 12 IBU over the "limit" wasn't a problem because it medalled... but I don't know enough about hopping to make the ideal adjustments to my version of the recipe.

So...

Questions:

  1. What should I do about the hop schedule?
  2. I don't usually step mash. Would I probably be OK just mashing @152F for 60 minutes and calling it good?
  3. How does the recipe look overall?
  4. Water! I always ask about water these days... would >= 50ppm Ca w/a balanced SO4:Cl ratio work well for this beer, or should I aim for a maltier SO4:Cl ratio?

Thanks!

Posted Apr 10, 2016, 2:32 PM UTC · edited

14
TheGremlyn•

Holy crap that's a lot of specialty grain. I'm very averse to overly complicated grain bills, and medal winning or not, this is the very definition of overly complicated. I'm sure it makes a good beer, but this is the second head scratcher award winning recipe I've seen this week based on all the specialty grains. I wonder if the brewer that wrote it made this recipe, had it work out, and then never questioned the complexity of the grain bill.

I don't understand the concept of such a low (or long) mash and then adding dextrin malt. To dry out an English style beer it would be more traditional to mash higher then add sugar, though I don't think that is needed with a brown at all.

Having victory and biscuit, while they are not exactly the same, seems redundant. The same goes for brown, chocolate, and special roast. Lots of overlap, probably unnecessary to have them all.

Also, unless you want a hoppier English style brown, I'd skip all but the bittering addition. Could do some very late and/or flameout hops for a slight hint, which I have found in some English brown beers, but it isn't necessary or even expected in the style.

My English style brown beers share a similar grain bill composition, which is 4 grains, all with purpose: Maris Otter, Crystal 60, brown malt, chocolate.

6
mrthedonOP•

Thanks for the comparison. Yeah, it does seem like quite a lot of specialty grain.

1
Z-and-I•

12C is English IPA, British Brown is 13B

Edit: Did you mean to have the brown and biscuit be 5.5 LBS each? I assumed it was a typo. If not that changes things.

The recipe you have there looks like it would make a good southern brown. In fact minus the hops that is pretty close to what mine looks like.

Don't worry about step mashing. Just mash at 152 and you will be fine.

For the recipe I would cut the crystal down about half of what you have there. And the yeast I would change as a well, for something more attenuative. If you cut the crystal out consider lowering the IBUs some. I would keep the bittering but at a half ounce and move the EKG to 15 min and cut out the rest. I think that would get you in the FG range and IBU range for the style.

2
pwnslinger•

If you predict your average boil gravity will be about the same, just scale the additions to be ten percent higher for each addition.

2