SchwarzeSonne_•

I hope we see more content in this vein coming from alt-right outlets. Sooner or later they'll come around to the fact that things like this are a feature and not a bug with populism. A popular movement is defined by its constituents and not by its leaders, so should more libertines start identifying as alt-right, they cease to be able to hold what tatters of a claim of right-wingedness they have.

I've been paying some attention to the dynamics of the factions of the far/dissident right over the last several months and the changes have been quite notable, significantly due to the ascendancy of Trump. Overall I think the AR is moving leftward in general opinion, but as a result, the more rightist members are jumping ship to reaction.

24
MUH_PC_ACCOUNT•

I'm stuck in this vague realm between the two where I am more reaction-aligned philosophically, but I fucking love to watch the AltRight troll Cuckservatives and Leftists. I know it goes against the Passivism strategy that NRx-ers like, but I'm hoping that by helping to inflame tensions, we can radicalize factions in the meantime and accelerate the decline.

Where I think the AltRight center will ultimately go is Leftist economically, and anti-egalitarian (but still overall Leftist) in social issues. Maybe this can work; I think the economic and societal structure matters less in homogenous societies than in heterogenous ones.

16
LiberatedDeathStar•

I enjoy a lot of the Alt Right because I know that they are somewhat reasonable to me in relation to the other leftists of today. I would much rather share a world where there's discourse between strong traditionalism/far right ideologies, libertarianism/anarcho-capitalism, and neo-reactionary thought. The new Alt Right stuff has many qualities of all of those areas of thought, even if it takes many contemporary elements as well. It's still better than the current cuckservative/leftist bullshit. I don't know exactly where I stand in there (I think I stand as some degree of bastardization of Anarcho-Capitalist, NRx, and traditionalism), but all of those are welcome philosophies compared to the stupid egalitarian, Marxist bullshit that currently exists.

I agree on the economic stuff being less important in homogeneous societies. In homogeneous societies, everyone has the same or similar background and will work with whatever economic system is there.

24
SchwarzeSonne_•

I can say with a fair amount of confidence that you are a young man with a lot of pent up aggression, hence the appeal of alt-right agitation. That's fine really, I personally am on the fence with passivism, both because I feel a moral imperative to act, and because I love to see results. Unfortunately the results of alt-right trolling is minuscule, if not counterproductive due to the false hope it causes.

The "do as thou wilt" attitude toward social issues is leftism distilled. If it takes hold in any sort of remotely rightist circle, it is doomed.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
SchwarzeSonne_•

If you want to see actual change, set your sights low. Maintaining behavior becoming of an elite is the most important counterrevolutionary act one can carry out in this environment.

Have you read Codreanu? If you've previously read Guenon, I'd also recommend Evola's trilogy.

1
gildredge•

so should more libertines start identifying as alt-right, they cease to be able to hold what tatters of a claim of right-wingedness they have. I've been paying some attention to the dynamics of the factions of the far/dissident right over the last several months and the changes have been quite notable, significantly due to the ascendancy of Trump. Overall I think the AR is moving leftward in general opinion, but as a result, the more rightist members are jumping ship to reaction.

I haven't seen any evidence of that at all really. How is the alt-right any different now to what it was a few months ago?

1
SchwarzeSonne_•

By "a few months" I suppose I mean before Trump, and to a certain extent before gamergate.

Before Trump the general opinion was that democracy is a failed system and power must be taken by violent revolution or rebuilding after collapse. Now it's "Trump will save us." This is the single biggest and most important indicator.

3
hegelstriads•

This is an excellent article, but it could stand for some more theoretical interpretation of the Milo phenomenon. As the article states:

The Daily Beast recently termed him the young face of the Alt-Right.

Who is it that is getting to make these kinds of decisions? I think we can all easily come to that conclusion, but moreover, why are they doing this?

The powers-that-be want a 'Right' they can control. And given the state of things on the "American" 'Right,' there isn't exactly any kind of formal process to install someone into a position that people will listen to. So instead, they create an internet celebrity of sorts. Milo is the 'Right' equivalent of Dee Ray, right down to being a faggot.

They want people like Milo installed in positions of importance in order to rein-in the 'Right' when the situation needs to be done. So for instance, say a bunch of white men attack some "Left" protest thing somewhere, and a video of it goes viral. Someone will call Milo on the phone, and have him write an article that goes something like this; "While I don't approve of beating up a bunch of worthless SJW trash, I can totally understand why they did it." This tells his readership to remain passive, while also telling them he is sympathetic to their cause. The article may even suggest some other non-violent activism that you can try.

Now say things are worse, and a bunch of armed white men do something like storming the house of a federal prosecutor or a judge, and murdering him. They take a video of themselves doing it, and declare the start of the war for the Liberation of the White Nation. Then they will call Milo (or people doing his exact same job) and tell them to denounce them in no uncertain terms. Milo will write something like this: "These men are undoing everything we've been working for. They are stupid idiots, worthless garbage, and only inviting even more repression onto us. We have to do everything possible to keep men like this out of the Alt-Right, least it doom us to forever being ruled by SJWs."

That is the point of people like Milo. The powers-that-be are looking for an ideological space where they can continue fooling the masses of the White Nation to go along with their own destruction. It is becoming more and more difficult for them to do this, which is why they have to reach out to faggots like Milo in the first place. White Nationalists should interpret their desperation as a good sign. It means they are having greater and greater difficulty fighting us on an ideological plane. It won't be long before they won't even bother trying to install 'Right' people to control the conversation; soon they will resort to outright censorship of ideas that challenge the ruling ideology. Then things will start to get interesting.

21
core-questions•

This is the definition of entryism, pretty much: bring people in who can redirect and steer the movement through force of will and sheer volume.

NRx is isolated a bit from this, but the Alt-Right types are really the vanguard of this whole thing, and if they get too watered down, the momentum will all be lost.

11
GBP4tendies•

Except your whole argument hinges on the assumption that, in some grand conspiracy, some nebulous leftists are responsible for catapulting Milo to fame. You're simply wrong. He's famous because rightists love him and they consider him an eloquent version of their own voice. That's why they attend his events en masse. They choose to.

This in-fighting and ideological nit picking is absurd. It's basically "No true Scotsman" argument.

7
SchwarzeSonne_•

The "rigtists" that love him are either by definition not rightists or just fools, along the lines of the Germans that thought sending Lenin back to Russia was a good idea.

Something to be cautious of is the increasingly large number of what I would call “racialist liberals” who are claiming to be a part of the alt-right. These are people who, politically-speaking, want all or most of what liberals do, but who are either (understandably) fed up with the disproportionate criminality of certain ethnic groups or who (correctly) believe that a liberal social order is unworkable with too many underperforming minorities acting as a drag on the system. Such people are, of course, entitled to their opinions. But they are not entitled to appropriate the term “rightist” (alt- or otherwise) without being called on it.

Being on the right means believing rightist things. If you don’t, then you aren’t on the right, and you shouldn’t claim that you are. So, if your claims that you are a rightist when you really aren’t are due to some sort of mistake or confusion, I’ll be happy to help correct any misconceptions you may have. If, however, they are intentional misrepresentation, then you are a left-entryist who must be revealed for what you are and ruthlessly denounced until you are hounded out of rightist circles. Again, you are entitled to your opinions. If you’re on the left, go be a leftist, and if the left is presently too racially egalitarian for you, then you’re welcome to agitate however you like to try to change that. But you aren’t entitled to acceptance under false pretenses, and I won’t extend you any.

https://antidem.wordpress.com/2016/04/11/short-takes-april-2016/

1
GBP4tendies•

Great, you found someone on the internet who propegates purity extremism. But the AR movement is in its infancy. It's preposterous to claim that this blog writer has some privileged reference of authority. The movement is a living thing. And even if there were a set-in-stone list of tenets of the movement (there aren't), people can still "join the party" if the movement echoes their own beliefs better than anything else, even if they don't agree 100% with everything.

Do you really even want !00% agreement with everything? At that point you just have a bunch of thoughtless drones. And even if this is what you want, it's not possible. No movement in the history of ever has had 100% internal agreement. This purist rhetoric is not only childish but counterproductive.

Lastly, what does that quote have to do with anything? You still haven't provided evidence why you believe Milo and his fans aren't true Scotsmen alt-rightists.

6
SchwarzeSonne_•

I'm not in the alt-right. I believe the alt-right is fundamentally leftist and thus damaging. Why? In essence the most consistent idea I've seen is that "liberalism is great, we just need to kick out the niggers, spics, and kikes."

Liberalism, democracy, holding any intrinsic value to the notion of freedom are all aspects of leftism. Just because you aren't like by most leftists doesn't mean you aren't one. The Bolsheviks didn't like anarchists- does that make one group any less leftist?

I'm not calling for 100% conformity; I'm calling for conformity to a specific set of ideas that are intrinsic to being a rightist. If you fail to accept those ideas you simply aren't a rightist.

Why is the sodomite hymie a leftist? Because his entire political philosophy is predicated on freedom, just the same as all leftists. In his case it is freedom for men to masturbate into each others rectums and to annoy feminists, but freedom nonetheless. He actually believes that free speech is an ideal to be protected, when it is the exact issue that brought us to this point.

1
Trigger_Warnings•

I do often wonder how much milos faggotry influences perceptions of him amongst the alt right/reactionary circles. I feel that if he was straight then there wouldnt be such an inertia against him.

I like milo, hes calling spades spades, he is a protected class ao leftists cant so easily dismiss him and yet reactionaries seem hung up on his sexuality and his greekness.

2
SchwarzeSonne_•

People always fail to consider how important behavior is. This man preaches something masquerading as conservatism while practicing disgusting and civilization-destroying behaviors. Granted, we all have our vices, but he revels in them and makes a central tenet of his philosophy.

4
[deleted]•

I think it's hard to pin down where Milo really stands, but he definitely has traditionalism in his philosophy. He knows it isn't for him, but I think he has some self hate due to the fact that he can't have that life. He cites things like women being less happy than ever despite being "liberated" and such to argue for traditionalism in interviews that I have seen. And he defends the RC church despite not really being a devout Catholic. I believe he honestly thinks that at least some traditionalism is the best for society even if he doesn't practice anything like that himself.

And even if he was all the way onboard with alt right philosophies, he would have to tone down a lot of opinions in public just to gain the exposure and media presence he gets. He's also an opportunist but who can blame him for that?

11
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
AutoModeratorMOD•

Your comment has been removed because it is very short.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
SwaglordTrump•

Milo isn't one of us, but he is a good man, and a tireless opponent of the Left. He may be the embodiment of modern decadence, but even that is a strength in some regards: it takes away an ad hominem the Left could use against him.

9
atheistfagz•

weak article. TRS doesn't get that being legitimate nazis will never grow the movement and that this article does nothing but to pigeon hole them into even more obscurity. While the aims of TRS are not terrible, they seem to want to push away normies.

8
SchwarzeSonne_•

I'm not sure you are in the right place. Reaction doesn't want "normies"- it wants principled and strong men to live among the ruins and ride the tiger.

2
atheistfagz•

dont be condescending i've been a part of this movement for a lot longer than you think. You can't win a war without the support of the normies. You can't change our culture without a war. What other conclusion is there to draw here?

2
SchwarzeSonne_•

What movement? Surely not reaction, given your populism.

The war has already been fought and won by the left. For now the solution is to start carving out enclaves of like-minded men who can begin rebuilding when modernity finally breathes its death rattle. You can push it along, but numbers are a minute part of the solution. If something is popular it is probably wrong.

In the event of an actual armed conflict the intellectual peasantry, the norrmalfags, will side with whichever warlord is the most impressive. Our job is to become the impressive warlord, not start raising an army.

4
atheistfagz•

So basically, you want to fade into complete obscurity. Good luck with that. The war has not been won by the left. What kind of ridiculous fatalistic thinking is that. The overton window has shifted so far in the last year.

You fail to realize that the stage we are in right now is drawing sides, and it sounds like you WANT to be on the losing side because you don't care about convincing people to our side.

If you think I'm populist you don't understand what that means. A nobleman has a duty to protect his peasants and citizenry. You don't go protecting your citizenry and setting a good example by being like "OK here's the new rules, only 5% of the population is applicable to our new group and we're gonna win".

Good luck with that. It's thoughts like this that kill reaction because it makes it completely unpalatable.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
muuh-gnu•

So, your solution would be to compromise?

If you dont have enough power to take over on your own, the solution is to make allies. The point of an ally is to have someone to help you who isnt you, but temporarily shares a subset of goals with you, and achieving those mutual goals is more worth than fighting out the differences between you.

Best example: The leftists and Islam. Under other circumstances, theyd lead a total war of genocide and extinction against each other, but they band together against western christianity as the common, overpowering enemy of both, even if both of them know that after Christianity is gone, there can only be one.

The leftists are masters of the "game of thrones" and alliance building. During the middle ages, they supported every heresy under the sun against the RCC. Then they supported the "poor" against western monarchies. Then they supported the "workers" against evil capitalists. Then the women. Then the niggers. Then the homos. Then Muslims. Then the freakazoids. Basically they randomly supported any and every subgroup ever and successfully allied with any of them to reach their goals.

The right, on the other hand, seems to be completely unable to grasp this concept, and no matter how often it fails, unable to realize that the hyper-K-selected-lone-alpha-wolf wont win against thousands of rabid rabbits. And even IF he could win, theyd still get his female and his pups and then outbreed him.

Whatever you thought about Milo's fondness to be gang banged and bukaked by ugly, STD-infested, IQ-60 niggers, even if he isnt "one of us", right now he is a fellow traveler, and a highly visible, aggressive and effective one. He is a SJW-killer-machine with an invincible gay protection shield. Let him use and abuse it against them. You can always burn him at the stake later, AFTER we won together, if he ever tries to approach your children. If he helps us win, and respects your authority and doesnt try to infect anybody elses children, let him keep his basement niggers and live in peace as a gift for his invaluable services. He'll die without genetic succession anyway in a few decades.

Building alliances with enemies of your enemies, and using and abusing useful idiots isnt "compromising", it is called getting and holding power.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
SwaglordTrump•

There is room for aggressive ethnonationalism without bringing up red herrings like the "JQ" as TRS does.

And while I support traditionalism and seek an end to modern decadence, religion is not a major issue anymore. That's why Trump, another embodiment of modern decadence like Milo, slaughtered his evangelical foes. We could stand to de-emphasize the matter.

2
gildredge•

When did he say he was one of us? As far as I can tell he's always been quite clear he isn't one of us. The most I've ever seen him say is that he sypathetic to it.

Unless that changes this is an argument against a claim that has never been made. Of course it's worth guarding against entryism, and Milo does look like he may well be attempting exactly that, but given how specifically the alt-right is a reaction against the entryism and subversion that occurred within conservatism I don't see it having much trouble defending it against that. The second anyone attempts to shift the movement to the left people will be on them like a pack of wild-dogs.

6
citizen_beyond•

I'm not even surprised that a flamboyant gay ended up being one of the more popular figures. This just shows you how Marxist our culture has become. People are willing to interview or listen to a gay man. At least for now. I'm fact, as demented as it is, the fact that he talks so much about sleeping with black guys also probably makes him more palatable to the normie population.

5
atheistfagz•

don't you understand that his homosexuality is what allows him to be a leading figure? Regardless of how you feel about his lifestyle or how it "applies" to our movement, the fact that HE is taken seriously while WE are not, says something.

Maybe, just maybe, taking the argumentative and "out there" (by most peoples' standards) TRS stance just pushes people away.

8
citizen_beyond•

I agree with you, his homosexuality gives him perceived "victim status". This allows him to appeal to a much wider audience. This is our current Marxist culture.

When I said "at least for now", I meant that as the left moves ever more leftward I'm not even sure a gay man will be victim status in the future. He's still a (((white male))) after all. Some obese black tranny will eventually tell him to sit down and shut up, and the crowd will cheer and snap her/him/it on.

Perhaps I'm in the echochamber, but this is really an interesting case of Marxist inversion of values. It wasn't that long ago that a man's opinion might be given particular weight because he was a family man, came from good stock, was a respected elder, etc. Now the left doesn't care about any of those things, actually some of it probably works against you. They give particular weight to men who put black cocks up their ass.

2
atheistfagz•

yeah that's exactly what I'm saying, it's kind of like we need to take advantage of what we're offered right now. If you completely push back like how TRS wants, literally NO ONE will listen to you except for your own tiny in-group.

While this is the ideal situation for most of us, this will never happen without a huge war or some kind of mass killing, which NO NORMIE ever will support, since most people in our society are already poz'd

2
SchwarzeSonne_•

Why does it matter if people are pushed away? Reaction is decidedly antipopular. The sort of people that are bothered by minutiae aren't wanted anyway.

1
atheistfagz•

It matters because armies of normies angry at us for (((reasons))) will just kill all of us in the coming war

1
GBP4tendies•

I honestly don't think his sexuality is a serious contributor to his fame... He is extremely well spoken. This is irrefutable. His homosexuality is just icing on the cake, in terms of his privileged situation to inflame leftists. It adds to the humor and circus of the thing. He is, after all, a "professional provocateur".

5
Trigger_Warnings•

This just shows you how Marxist our culture has become. People are willing to interview or listen to a gay man.

Youve got it wrong. Things are so bad now that it takes a gay man to say the unsayable.

2
GBP4tendies•

I'm sorry but this pushing of intellectual purism is bullshit, and I stand with Milo on this one. Overall I agree with his core ideologies, especially the part on racial issues. I have no problem with people of other races as long as they're willing to adapt to Western white culture. I have friends of all sorts of ethnicities that are fully white by their actions. I think that is great, and what America is built on. It's only a problem when immigrants refuse to adapt.

2†
allmybeard•

I have friends of all sorts of ethnicities that are fully white by their actions. I think that is great, and what America is built on.

But that's blatantly inaccurate. America was built by racially white people.

6
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
muuh-gnu•

I have no problem with people of other races as long as they're willing to adapt to Western white culture.

Even if they adapted to white western culture, theyre 30-40 IQ points apart, and if you mix with them, youre getting dumber, and if in addition to mixing with you and dumbing you down, they have a higher birthrate than you, then theyre basically slowly swallowing you.

2
[deleted]•

The ones who can adapt to western culture are more likely to have above average IQ for their race or ethnicity which should moderate the effects of this, to be fair.

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
GBP4tendies•

But that's only true for blacks. It's not true for asians or jews, so why are you so afraid of them, even when many many of them assimilate flawlessly? (Might as throw latinos in there, too, even though they seem to be a mixed bag of sorts. Many of them have European heritage, and racially they're considered "white".)

3
muuh-gnu•

even when many many of them assimilate flawlessly?

They dont. As long as you somehow "know" that theyre "only" assimilated, and not "real", there is this uncanny valley effect going on. Because of that, they are always considered and treated as "foreigners" by the host population, so they feel as a "minority" no matter how well they assimilate.

Would you let an "flawlessly assimilated" chinese with family in china lead your army in a war against china? No? Then he neither is nor can be assimilated to become "one of us", so he is doomed to be a forever-minority, and this leads to resentment, and resentment leads to all those tiny minorities banding together against the host population majority to take them apart from the inside, until everyone of them gets a tiny piece of land on which he can become a president and on which hs isnt in the uncanny valley.

That basically means if you let many of them in, theyll tear you apart from the inside whether they belong to one big group or dozens of different groups.

6
GBP4tendies•

Your argument still hinges on your belief that real assimilation isn't possible. You are simply wrong. That's why the phrase "self hate" exists (a silly phrase, but we know what it means.) There are plenty of racial minorities who literally hate their racial peers due to their unwillingness to adapt to white western values. These people are both commendable and valuable.

0
Jungkonservative•

If I may be so bold as to speak for TRS as a whole, The Right Stuff has a nonnegotiable objective: the establishment of a White country in North America that will advance our interests.

And what has it, or any other institution done to promote or advance this goal? Absolutely nothing. It's a fantasy created by people who don't want to make it their life work to establish a new country.

Milo is a cultural libertarian. [...] He is not a traditionalist.

Yes. He's a person with personalized interests, just like the rest of us. Do real 'traditionalists' even exist? How many people who yearn for a warrior-aristocracy are actually fit for a role in such system? I haven't really seen anyone. If the so called neoreaction or alternative right wants us to disregard influential people who are actually making in-roads towards making race critical theory,SJWism, etc a laughing stock to normal people, simply because they don't meet their elitist and quasi-religious standards, they are going to actually have to do something other than sub-standard intellectual whining. They are actually going to have to display to people that they are the so-called 'aristocrats' they think they are.

2
atheistfagz•

I just feel like TRS is the right-wing equivalent of leftists and SJWs, it's a bunch of kids who REFUSE to sacrifice idealism for any semblance of pragmatism. While they have a noble mission, they don't do anything other than make the alt right seem like a bunch of nazis, which does literally nothing to further the cause

2