r/Civcraft•
Wugglet

Make 3.0 using 1.0 mechanics with not alts and bots

Further you move away from vanilla the lower the active player base will be.

This morning I was skimming through the github, and with the current mechanics we have now I don't see how you can get an active player base anywhere near 1000 even with advertising. If you can't vision 500 players on opening day it's time to change the gameplan.

Posted Jun 13, 2016, 2:09 AM UTC

1319
IntellectualHoboThe Thanatos of Dankmemes•

1.0: HCF invades, pearls "half the server," and politics "stagnates". Significant portion of the population blames vanilla mechanics for making it too easy for such a thing to happen and calls for a change. "Post HCF era" is fairly short lived as the map is leaked and world ends.

2.0: Changes away from vanilla happen (as requested), most get nerfed pretty quickly (RB anyone?) or are ended up balanced for botters, dupers, and alts. Server performance buckles under the strain from bots and accompanying automation. Economy is wack and server stagnates.

3.0: "Hmm, maybe everyone shouldn't have everything available in the techtree on day one like you could do in 1.0. We can also provide as much in the way of in-game informational tools to explain how things work so we can expand the techtree beyond vanilla's ridiculously simplistic and shallow techtree. Oh and with sharding our performance problems are a thing of the past!"

"Bring back 1.0!"

MFW

31
597Since before 1.0•

This is right.

1
g10greg56Falstadt Minister of Memes•

People will always have bad ideas

0
MaxopolySquidmin•

We had a similar discussion about 2.0 a while ago in slack. Here is ttk's reply, which reflects what most of us think about "bringing back X.0"

http://imgur.com/mXLdJRq

7
Dr_JawaHold the door•

Running servers is hard tho :(

2
Kaiser_Cheesebubblessenior director of fun squishing, emperor of all defem volk•

"I don't care about alienating oldfriends"

Somebody is far too optimistic about the amount of people that 3.0 is going to bring in. I doubt it will even double the playerbase, and if anyone is still clinging to "1000 players," they are delusional.

You have to acknowledge that Minecraft as a community had stopped the constant growth that it had 2 or 3 years ago. If anything, it's slowly shrinking. 1000 players, or even any enormous growth, is simply not possible in the current server market - hell, even having 50 players on is a pretty big server at this point - the Civcraft 2.0 model worked for keeping players. You wouldn't believe how many servers simply died off during the period that 2.0 was up. It was a strong model.

tl;dr 3.NO

1
BelovedDictatorSigned. Pearled. •

PrisonBed when

6
Dr_JawaHold the door•

I would love a modern prisonbed

6
BelovedDictatorSigned. Pearled. •

Maybe if you attach a prison pearl to a bed, the prisoner is kept summoned without using up any resources. Could be very cheap and easy for low-security pearls, but would be a lot more expansive and less safe for high-security pearls.

2
Jackson8960Plantation Owner *Goliath Target-Locked*•

Yesss.

3
cynest/Hallusk of Columbia•

As it turns out, that's not not the game the dev team is interested in making. While there exists room for compromise and fun is a priority, at the end of the day I don't think any of them want to just make another factions coolpvp server, which is incidentally all that particular mechanics set is good for with the current playerbase.

4
IPostWhenIWant•

What do you think they are planning?

4
Kaiser_Cheesebubblessenior director of fun squishing, emperor of all defem volk•

A nice cozy bonfire with the donation money.

5
NewzBot•

Can confirm, and the reason for all the delay is global warming, we're just waiting on the coming nuclear winter

1
Fellowship_9Concordian MP•

Go on, try and tell a group of people that everything they've been working on for a year should be scrapped, I'm sure that will work out well.

4
AerothersSpace Communist•

Code it yourself

2
_ewolfe_•

I actually just found ttK2's [gameplan] (https://media.giphy.com/media/l41lSx2fxqkrm9p3G/giphy.gif)

1†
CosmondicoProphet of the Lamp •

Please, hush.

1
fk_54the funk will be with you... always!•

I mostly disagree with your assessment. Vanilla might be a short-term thing, but would die off very quickly once everyone gets bored.

The beauty of what Civcraft is trying to accomplish is that they have bold enough of a vision that they are willing to count on seasoned players who 'get it' to create lots of dynamics and momentum that will in turn attract other lesser-experienced ones and go on to train them.

It's logical for someone who is really good at Minecraft to want to level up to this amount of sophistication, and to stay motivated once they've learned the ropes because the challenges will be much more drawn-out, and possibly dynamically modified with on-the-fly changes for special occasions.

I might not necessarily see eye-to-eye on some of their choices, but a lot of those specifics can be fine-tuned from gathering player data once the map is started.

There's nothing in the current plan that would appear that much off-target, except it remains to be seen that they will have the wherewithal, resolve and resources to steadfastly run the multi-faceted advertising and outreach campaigns necessary to accomplish the goal. This includes continuously creating fresh content, coming up with slogans, possibly contests even, getting reviewed in all of the right 'zines, social media and gaming communities for it to go viral.... This sort of thing doesn't happen by accident, it requires professional planning and execution.

If anything, I am quite optimistic on their chances for success, as long as they don't underestimate the amount of advertising, publicity and general hype they will need to get the word out, and keep getting more players to check it out.

1