jctwake•

This is why I fear for 2020

6
testcase51OP•

I'm not so worried about presentation - what I fear is some weird set of judging rules with 'required elements,' like in figure skating, that forces everyone into the exact same style.

12
BermudaCake•

Most sports are judged by whatever international body exists to judge that sport, rather than the Olympics bringing in their own people and taking over the show. But, it will be interesting to see with skating what they do, when there doesn't (to my knowledge) exist some International Skateboarding Federation. Quite possibly they'll just go with the most established professional skateboarding organisation, which I guess is just SLS.

And yeah you could argue that SLS favours a particular style. Lots of 'perfectly' landed tricks in quick succession. It's not what I find entertaining to watch. I like watching a slightly sloppy skater, someone who looks like they're holding on to the trick by the skin of their teeth and still making it look good.

You brought up figure skating - there's an interesting podcast about a figure skater who 'broke the mold', skating in a wildly different way to the established norm, but the judges were very stuck in their ways and she never won any gold medals. http://www.radiolab.org/story/edge/

3
testcase51OP•

Neat - I'll check out the radiolab on my commute. I checked out some clips and she looks sick.

1
pennywiseify•

Actually there is some International Skateboarding Federation. :)

1
BermudaCake•

Damn, spot on with the name and everything... guess I could have googled it!

1
mike45010•

What's your opinion on how olympic snowboarding is judged?

2
testcase51OP•

Don't know much about it, really.

1
mike45010•

In my opinion they do a pretty good job with the inherent subjectivity of the sport. Seems to me that they could do the same thing with skateboarding, if implemented properly.

1
jctwake•

A little late with the reply, but that's another big reason. What I fear is the emphasis on technicality that is seen in all other Olympic trick sports (diving, gymnastics, etc.) that could really undermine the style that goes into one's skating. Halfpipe snowboarding was mentioned below, and while style is a big part of time spent in the air, all riders are confined to the same sort of routine which makes it easy to judge for tech (most corked rotations). Skating is a different beast, especially street, and I think it'll be really difficult to give due respect to a rider's style on a full-blown international stage (i.e. most novice viewers may appreciate the tech and be dissappointed if a more fluid, stylish skater one).

1
RBRTPNG•

I think it'll be the opposite for novice viewers. I don't think the appeal or understanding of certain tricks is gonna catch them. It's gonna be the guy who's flowing through the course. If that makes sense...I just woke up haha

1
ratherlargepie•

Skateboarding, and now for the pole vault!

sudden cut

3
skatepools•

it really doesn't matter

2
ButteryScallops•

Of course they think we don't care about the landing, we just want to see the flip!

3
WilliamGuerratejas•

I was hyped for the roll up. the gifs too long imo

1
Gurtol•

Cody McEntire gets robbed again!

3

The best part is when the g

1