One Last Bg-Post: The Final Chansylvanian Analysis on Civcraft

I can't believe it's come to this. What a sad, sad state of affairs.

I'll be brief, because at this point neither me nor any of the readers really give too many fucks.

The Chan Community has made the first completely unanimous decision in its history: leaving Civcraft. We didn't even need to take a vote, we asked everybody at the meeting and there was dead silence, even from the people who had been grinding on Civ 3.0 from day one.

We're done, we're out. The sun is getting real low, the canary in the coal mine has stopped chirping, our engine is running on fumes. Whatever the analogy. To stay here is death for us.

 


 

The only reason I make any particular note of this is because it did not have to be this way.

 

Just...just look at this.

Devoted: http://imgur.com/a/GUbrS

A fully fledged system of Fjords and ravines, leading into a massive lake. A Rock of Gibraltar protecting a natural harbor. Glaciers with actual paths for water runoff through them holding onto the sides of mountains. Where rivers run, little rivulets simulate erosion in the landscape. Around every corner is a vision of a potential town you could make.

 

And the best part? Procedurally generated. Not a single worldedit thing in it. What did we get on Civcraft? 10 flat maps with one gimmick like a cross section of river or a tiny, monotonous mountain range, and LE EPIC Shrekface^tm. The sense of mystery from Civcraft 2.0 was utterly stripped and ultimately was the most demoralizing thing for us. We were promised what we are now getting on Devoted for 3.0. I hope that sinks in real deep.

It's almost like the dev team forgot that building was a fundamental part of Mineman. It's almost like Jackie just shat out a few maps to fit the ''''''''balance''''''''' needs while ignoring the fact that what they were was boring, uninspired, and worthless for any sort of varied gameplay. I hear that somebody made Jackie cry by saying that before and to that I say "too bad". If you can't accept legitimate criticism of your work by doing anything other than getting defensive or crying, you will continue to produce trash. Every webcomic artist in existence from QC to Shadman has proven this.

And that's just the tip of the iceberg. I could argue more, but it's not worth it because I know that either it will be ignored or it might actually be taken to heart (doubtful) and be used to improve a server that quite frankly just deserves the long slow death that awaits it.

 


 

I am an economics major. This server was supposed to simulate politics and economics. Ironically, because the devs are obsessed with preventing the HCF, they have made a server where the only way to survive is to be HCF.

By increasing the costs and barriers to entry, you create monopolies. This is a VERY basic economic fact that holds true in every walk of life, including non-economic events like social gatherings. If there is a high barrier to entry, you create monopolies where the smartest thing to do is restrict access as much as possible while handing out things to your buddies who will go rough up the poor beleaguered competition. Reiko and his friends proved this.

Of course now, the dev team appears to be aware of this and is starting to blow hot air about 'decreasing costs'. Let me tell you what, it's too late for that.

 



 

We channers have been the people most exposed to the currents and changes in Civcraft, because we rely on large, relatively pluralistic societies to survive. We need to recruit from inexperienced players, players who don't know a thing about the game to begin with, nevermind this server. We are the canary in the coal mine.

And, well, your canary just died.

We had such high hopes for this new map, you have no idea. We wanted Nox to win in 2.0 so that they might reset the map. But when we got here we were so crushed and demoralized that many of us either quit or turned to raiding or just held out hope for anything.

I'm not going to waste any more time telling you guys how to improve, because I already did, along with the other 100 people and devs who are now happily playing Devoted. If you are going to improve, you will do it by taking the advice we've already given. If you don't (and given that you are downgrading the server and talking about adding dungeons and making Uncle Feelie/Ulca Felya a Dungeon Crawler rather than bringing the hammer down on the actual core problems, I doubt you will) then I hope you understand that you have 100% chosen this end for yourself and that you will go down in Minecraft history as some of the most grossly out of touch devs known to vidya.

 

I almost regret not being around to see it. Until next time: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NFkryh6hC-k

Posted Sep 18, 2016, 5:31 AM UTC · edited

76135
alberlb96Alber, SPQR statesman•

I think very phew people really like how they have made the shards, completely diferent worlds from one another. When they talked about the shards, I thought they would make a single map and later shard it, or atleast make every shard separte from one another but making it with the idea in mind that this would be a single world.

I was also very excited because ideas like making a dodecaedron aperead, that way we would have a round world, and the first person in circumvalate the world could be widely known, as was Magallanes' expedition. I as eager to explore this new world, sail every ocean, discover every island, climb every mountain and map every continent, but when 3.0 came out, what we got instead was some plane shards with nothing interesting really, no mountain chain wher e rivers born from the melted snow and ice, no rivers that go throught the mountain then plains to finaly die on a lake, a bigger river, or the ocean, no oceans so big that separates continents, cultures and nations away and on where you have to be 30 min on the boat to reach the other shore, no real transition of biomes, from more cold and snowy ones in the north, and when you go south you start to get to warmer ones until you get to the hot ones like tha desert, jungle or savanna.

Instead we got the shards we have now, that have none of those things (the most interesting thing is the shrek face) and instead have huge trees that are no where near to real trees, and even leaves dont decay.

But what i think is the worst, is the fact that it isnt a single sharded map, but instead a bunch of diferent maps thrown toghether and which combined area isnt even half of the 2.0 map (if i remember correctly, devs said the the area of the initial shards would be similar to the 2.0 one)

21
pds12345Rokko Steppe•

I actually really like the idea of shards, it seems like a very tidy way to structure your map. However it was just implemented poorly. One of the biggest flaws is that skynet now is broken and tells you when someone enters your shard. This can allow raiders to see a group of people coming from thousands of blocks away regardless if they have snitches or not.

Even more reason why reiko and his crew had such a massive success. They would just log when they recognized the PvP players coming into the shard all at once.

3
GreeenkittenGreenkitten•

Civcraft:Worlds, its in the name. They're supposed to be different worlds all interconnected. While it screams Praxis, this is an even bigger failure. The shards are just not connected enough and I doubt they ever could be without making the server feel very small.

Ironically, because the devs are obsessed with preventing the HCF, they have made a server where the only way to survive is to be HCF.

In defence of the admins here this is a fault in their communication skills. By talking to other admins one on one they quite clearly explain otherwise. Unfortunately rather than combating this misconception they only emphasise it by saying, "No, we're not obsessed with preventing invasions." This does nothing to quell fears and offers no alternative. It funnels people into thinking, "Invasion, invasion, invasion!" So the idea is perpetuated. And it doesn't help that the costs are too high to begin with. There are so many other points they could be hammering, from longevity to enforcing cooperation to prevention of one group owning every factory, there are so many other aspects they could be pushing. Too bad ttk2 would rather whine about how nobody understands him.

18
CortwadeLonely outcast of Civcraft•

Wow... I kinda want to go to devoted now...

11
dsclouse117A founder of Aeon | Not a good arbitrator •

Somehow devoted does the opposite of civ and manages to get better with each iteration. If only they could keep high population though.

7
General_ManoOPGarbage Management Specialist•

Well right now it's outdoing Civcraft 2 to 1 for people, so there's that.

7
dsclouse117A founder of Aeon | Not a good arbitrator •

No way really? I haven't had a chance to look. That's great.

5
Gregy164As much as I hate to say it IS4NTA didnt do anything wrong.•

Sad to say devoted is better than civcraft tbh.

11
General_ManoOPGarbage Management Specialist•

Devoted 3.0 is what they said Civcraft 3.0 would be.

4
Gregy164As much as I hate to say it IS4NTA didnt do anything wrong.•

devoted 3.0 map is better, the tech tree is not cancer. you can actually progress without spending thousands of hours grinding away to get a factory for a factory then get another factory to get another factory then upgrade that factor to get one thing.

9
TofeeDodger•

The problem civcraft has always had is not getting players it is retaining them, why wasn't that the focus of 3.0? Seriously civcraft has now become so much more complicated it's ridiculous, I've tried getting my friends from other servers to play, they like the concept but none of them want to play a boring game. The only people who do enjoy the grind are already playing and they are the minority in an already tiny portion of the minecraft community.

Ironically, because the devs are obsessed with preventing the HCF

This. The admins take for granted how many players and how much political drama actually arose from the HCF invasions. I would rather have drama between 100s of medium sized groups than forced role playing internal politics within the 1-2 of the only large groups on the server.

Don't get me started on how much I dislike the economy of the game.

This is a rant - me venting all the dissapoint for the things 3.0 could have been. I hate making posts like these becuase they are negative and spread this among the community leading to more and more people quitting(no one wants to play something that people believe is dying). This goes against everything civcraft stands for but honestly civcraft:worlds needs a do-over. It needs one sooner rather than later.

10
General_ManoOPGarbage Management Specialist•

no one wants to play something that people believe is dying

It IS dying.

civcraft:worlds needs a do-over

It is not salvagable. The mod team will never be able to face its own failures and redo this entire shit-show from the ground up. And now that Devoted is doing what basically everybody who complained about 2.0 and 3.0 wanted, they can't regain the population even IF they redid the server.

5
TofeeDodger•

There's still problems with devoted I fear it will reset quickly or die of unless it can retain its player base well, which I hope it would. It also doesn't have the framework to sustain 1000 players, civcraft did but it was executed horribly. Another benefit civcraft has its xp production which gives actual value to farms - I always liked this about civcraft, the fact that you could sell farm produce in a dynamic economy without using some forced plugin like buy sell shops at an admin shop. I'm just typing sorry bout bad formating grammar what ever the fuck!!

8
BonkillShaded - Mt. Augusta•

We've done ok work with player retention, gotten better each map.

We will only reset if we see another super low drought of players, but ExilePearl should help prevent that in the future.

3
Wugglet•

Another benefit civcraft has its xp production which gives actual value to farms

One of the dumbest things this server has done was the banning of alts and botting and to continue to allow xp production through farms. It's dumb to force people to afk farms for xp while being able to only play on one account and making them manually run up and down a wheat farm. Botting needs to be legal unless the goal is to drain everyone out.

-10
ownagedotnetChiefNug - Falstadt•

how many times do we have to tell the admins were not having fun?

9
Cyborg27XAScouter9001•

Chief. Let's make maps. Make something and send it my way. Ping pong it.

1
BlackXnt•

What did you do in 2.0 that was so much more fun?

-1†
xpNcCitizen Watch -- Full Ross•

explored

17
BlackXnt•

Exploring was so much fun because the map was 2 years old and wherever you went you could find ruins of civilizations. It will take some time but 3.0 will be the same rather quickly considering the map is much smaller.

-7
xpNcCitizen Watch -- Full Ross•

There is nothing interesting about this map. There is nothing to explore. The actual process of accurately mapping out 2.0 took multiple people years to accomplish. 3.0 was entirely mapped in 2 days.

24
kovio1453/r/devoted 🏴•

Both him and I played since 2.0 day one, wet lived in Kappi. That's not why exploring was fun.

3†
Lowtuffcurrent lowtuff status: merely a peaceful volans snow farmer•

Have to disagree there. Exploring was an incredibly rich experience from day 1.

3
dhingusMercenary | Hitman | UN Representative | Newfriend•

Hey he really loved cliffs and cookie cutter rivers, don't rain on his parade.

1†
ownagedotnetChiefNug - Falstadt•

not everyone played during 2.0

i am simply commenting on the nature of 3.0 thus far

4
JacinthJoyCivcraft LADmin•

I hear that somebody made Jackie cry by saying that before and to that I say "too bad".

Sorry to disappoint, but I have not cried over Civcraft or Civcraft's maps.

I see lots of flaws in my maps and understand that they are not liked by all (or perhaps even most).

9
alberlb96Alber, SPQR statesman•

The problem isnt how the maps were made, but the idea of making single, separated and unrelated maps is.

12
JacinthJoyCivcraft LADmin•

And that's a fair assessment.

6
Evocat0rDick-tator of Aquila•

Everyone does appreciate the time and effort you put into making them. Like albertb96 said, it's just the separated and unrelated maps which limits the amount of exploration. xpnc worded it perfectly, "There is nothing interesting about this map. There is nothing to explore. The actual process of accurately mapping out 2.0 took multiple people years to accomplish. 3.0 was entirely mapped in 2 days".

5
Peter5930•

I'd say the problem actually is in large part how the maps were made. The human mind just can't compete with procedural generation when it comes to creating a consistent level of detail, variety, surprise and promise to the map that extends from the largest down to the smallest scales.

Procedural generation does crazy things that don't occur to people, which adds promise and hope to exploration, since who knows what you'll find over the horizon? When we explore in 3.0, we've already been told 'there's ice plains over the horizon, because this is Isolde. Also there's swamp a bit further east, because that's Drakontis', but a huge part of what was so good about the 2.0 map was the fun of trying to find the perfect location to call home. For some, it was a special coordinate like 0,0, even if it looked like someone had shat all over the landscape for miles around, and for most it was a beautiful spot where two or three biomes intersected and created a diverse set of building opportunities and opportunities for resources. Everyone was free to pursue their dream, and could harbour the hope that out there in the vastness somewhere, they'd find what they were looking for.

There's no sense of exploration to 3.0 not only because it's smaller, but because we know we'll never find that perfect spot for our town where the jungle meets the sea with a backdrop of mountains in the distance. Every shard in 3.0 has it's theme and purpose and there's little mystery left and no promise of better opportunities just a little further over the horizon.

The move to double down on these adventure-style world-painted maps by introducing smaller dungeon-crawler maps won't improve matters. They'll be mapped out nearly instantly, the mystery will last 2 minutes and then it'll just be the place you have to go to to grind out 50,000 of item X that you need for factory Y.

How about if instead of choosing between the blandness of world painting or the imbalance of unfettered procedural generation, you use procedural generation to generate potential shards, and then select the ones that are the best fit for what you're trying to accomplish, and go in and add some dungeons and caverns and stuff as a final step in map creation?

3
doughy-goodsdoughy_goods - Mt. Augusta•

They're okay. A bit monotonous but there's always the chance to make cooler ones and learn from your mistakes in new shards. That's the best thing about the sharding system, there's always room to expand and improve the world.

3
dsclouse117A founder of Aeon | Not a good arbitrator •

LADS don't have the emotions necessary to cry.

2
JacinthJoyCivcraft LADmin•

Good point. We can only consume tears, not shed them.

1
storelogixiusethisforgood - ten33•

Tears lubricate the drama engine

1
storelogixiusethisforgood - ten33•

I like ur... Maps....

1
Ultra_Patriot•

I think they were great it was just a lack of shards imo

1
sashimiiWill Provide Discreet Political Consulting for $$$•

I am an economics major

Does the balance slack have any? Open question.

6
BonkillShaded - Mt. Augusta•

It has me

7
dsclouse117A founder of Aeon | Not a good arbitrator •

Rip

4
General_ManoOPGarbage Management Specialist•

It has Shaded, but they ignored him. The dev team is made up of poly-sci and arts majors.

1†
MaxopolySquidmin•

Completly made up claim

7†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Elithysrip•

Hey. I know we haven't talked a lot, and when we have it was exclusively throwing insults at each other, but I never thought I would be so sad to see you and Chanada go. I started playing civcraft a little too late, and while I was still in Chanada I was a newfriend and didn't talk much. Maybe in another timeline we would have played together more, and of course, I'm really sad to see the whole group go. I guess the presence of a group of "my own brothers" was a comforting feeling, even if we never interacted, I don't know. But I do see your point, and you're right. 3.0 is all over the place. I guess I just wanted to say goodbye, and that I care.

6
General_ManoOPGarbage Management Specialist•

I wish we hadn't fought either. Truthfully, I did alienate Libra and Librans when I did not need to. Know that all is forgiven and if you want to hang with us, you are welcome to.

I was struck by how sad I was to see some of you guys disappear. You weren't bad people, just caught on the other side of a political divide that went back orders of magnitude longer than you had played. You were a newfriend on one side while Yearn and I had our constant political duels. I don't blame you for it.

6
Yearn2•

It's just a game. Best of luck on the flip side my dude. Quitting was one of the best things I've done in a while.

2
General_ManoOPGarbage Management Specialist•

Best of luck to yourself, Yearn. I won't apologize for our disagreements, but I will say that I wish they hadn't happened and that the rift between us hadn't been so big. The people of Tazmily had something to add to Chanada and I was honestly very sad to see you guys leave us and then lose many to quitting in 3.0.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

5
[deleted]•

[removed]

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

2†
TheeloutIGN: Spongesuds | Frontierland's Mayor | Misipi Trading Co.•

wtf i hate civcraft:worlds now

well that's it I am now a #DevotedMissile

5
dsclouse117A founder of Aeon | Not a good arbitrator •

Haha sucks to be right again.

Sorry to see such a large group leave. Maybe it will push some real changes to the general dynamic and not just tweeks to the drastically broken ones. Or this could just be the beginning of the end for this map, maybe the server as a whole.

5
TambienTreasury Minister and Foreign Policy Advisor of Aurora•

I think it's a valid citicism. I just wish Devoted wouldn't reset. One of the biggest things I like about Civ is the idea that it's a continuous map where I can find ruins from years ago.

4
BonkillShaded - Mt. Augusta•

We've only reset due to player loss.

8
BackStabdArchbishop of Banterbury•

Advertise until we can't anymore :^)

3
dsclouse117A founder of Aeon | Not a good arbitrator •

What's the map radius this time around?

3
General_ManoOPGarbage Management Specialist•

It's a 10k by 10k square, but it will expand a bit to be a circle, I think.

3
TambienTreasury Minister and Foreign Policy Advisor of Aurora•

I think they said it had a diameter of 5k.

2
BonkillShaded - Mt. Augusta•

Radius so dia of 10

3
dsclouse117A founder of Aeon | Not a good arbitrator •

Tiny but reasonable. Hopefully since it's procedurally generated they can expand the radius in the future. Not sure how possible that is though. But 10k by 10k is amazing. Will feel like a real map.

2
TambienTreasury Minister and Foreign Policy Advisor of Aurora•

How often do you forsee that happening in the future?

2
General_ManoOPGarbage Management Specialist•

Never. We have 50 people and intend to keep recruiting just as we always have. Add on the other 100 or so redditors and Devoted will never die barring a catastrophic fuck up.

2†
TambienTreasury Minister and Foreign Policy Advisor of Aurora•

I seem to remember people saying the same thing about Civ...

-1
axusgrad•

After a long dark night... dawn has come to Padzhar.

But seriously the feedback is valuable. Hope you don't actually hate the dev team, I'm glad you are having a good time on Devoted.

4
AberrantWhovian.-.•

While I can't speak for the maps since I stopped playing as a newfriend in MA shortly before the Nox conflict or whatever it's called, I can agree on the barriers of entry. All I could do all day was axe trees, clear sand for people, and chase Stonato's ideas. I came too late to actually do anything.

4
JohnFairfaxVOLTERRA SUPPLIES RAIDERSVOLTERRA SUPPLIES RAIDERSVOLTERRA SUPP •

tumblingdown.mp3

3
stormsweeperSeldomshock | Doge of Senntisten•

Yay, less shitty people. 3.0 is turning out well.

3†
JohnFairfaxVOLTERRA SUPPLIES RAIDERSVOLTERRA SUPPLIES RAIDERSVOLTERRA SUPP •

Haha yeah dude a large group of players quit the server. 3.0 is turning out well!

35
JamesgardinerThornian leader•

A large group of players that never communicated with the rest of the server apart from to tell people to get off their land or be pearled.

7†
TofeeDodger•

It's called diversity - not everyone wants to use reddit. People quitting regardless of there play style is a bad thing. Different groups with different ways of going about themselves actually makes the server fun - even if the base game is disgusting.

18
quicksilver991R A R E O R E D O N O T M I N E•

Diversity isn't a good thing.

4
TyreMeme•

Thats like saying you hate Best Korea rl wth fam

2†
JamesgardinerThornian leader•

Ay hold up there "Best" Korea implies there is more than one true Korea watch what you're sayin son.

4
Yearn2•

Did they hurt your feelings?

1
JamesgardinerThornian leader•

I've never had any interaction with them in 3.0, and my interactions in 2.0 consisted of using their nether portal. That's why I don't particularly care that they are leaving, nor feel that the community as a whole will suffer from it.

1
General_ManoOPGarbage Management Specialist•

Yay, less shitty people. 3.0 is turning out well.

Dude, suck my dick. The largest single group of people just walked out of your server and you're celebrating?

10
Kjartan_AurlandSt_Leibowitz | Sic Transit Mundus•

bg don't fuck this up. If they're celebrating that means they'll stay here and Devoted won't have them.

7
BackStabdArchbishop of Banterbury•

Just because you don't like someone doesn't mean they are shitty, smh seldom :^(

9
FoltersPeri betrayed volans for potatos. •

Just because I like you, it doesn't mean you're not shitty.

2
ShibestLogibear2- Mayor of Victoria•

I'm sad that you guys are leaving. I know I've had personal issues with much of the leadership and some of the users but over time I've come to realize it was more ideological issues between me and much of the chan body rather than personal issues which I've assumed since I was more established in Polynesia.

I hope you guys come back eventually, I don't think devoted is really going to last from what I've seen of it.

2
LPTSOmeh•

you took the words right out of my mouth. im like a mofo cassandra up in here, cuz ive been calling this shit out from the beginning. i quit on good ole civvy months ago. twasn't fun anymore. but i tried to stick around by raiding a bit, but it wasnt worth it anymore. ive been periodically gleaming through the subreddit to see if other people would cave in like me. surprise, surprise, you guys quit too.

tis a shame whats happened to 3.0. when i first discovered civvy, back in 2014, i was so glad because i had been searching for a civilization server with basically no rules for, like 3 years. civvy was everything i ever wanted, and more. tis a shame how much its let me down.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1